News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by jackmott on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:35PM (#15119842)
author cheats, thinks it works, roots for cheaters
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by aetherson on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:46PM (#15119915)
Please describe your feelings on athletes wearing contact lenses. How about athletes who have ever had a surgery? What about athletes who are, at the time of competition, using non-prescription antihistamines? How about pseudoephedrine?
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by matt4077 on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:59PM (#15120008)
It's pretty obvious, isn't it? If something is used as treatment for a pathology it's not doping.

Besides, the difficulty to define something so as to cover any potential eventuality is a fallacy: -100degF is cold, 200degF is hot, and saying that any line we might draw as a cutoff for hotness is arbitrary in no way challenges the concept of heat itself.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by FullMtlAlcoholc on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:21PM (#15120605)
That line is not so clear. For example, it is not that uncommon for medical students to take beta blockers for increased performance during lab practicals and patient procedures, or surgeons. There is a murky line between jittery nerves and anxiety.

Also, what is to be done about athletes that are diagnosed with ADD? This was a major controversy in esports, although im not sure if those individuals were clinically diagnosed.

Modafinil is specifically prescribed to people who need to stay alert during work hours if their schedule has a disruptive sleep routine. The 24 hr Le Mans is certainly disruptive to one's circadian rhythms.

This may be a nonsense scenario, but what about transgender men powerlifters or bodybuilders who regularly need to take testosterone to conform to their gender identity? Should they have their own class? If we allow them, since natural production is over a wide spectrum, it becomes difficult to say what the threshold is. From their perspective, it maay seem unfair that they are limited while people like Arnold Schwarzenegger naturally produce large amounts.

Kobe Bryant used plasma therapy to quickly heal his Achilles tear. NFL teams use hyperbaric chambers to improve injury recovery speeds. Robin van Persie uses horse placenta to recover from muscle injuries.

It doesnt matter if the sport is based on skill(pool), pure strength/speed, or mental acuity(chess, go). Your genetics can confer advantages in all 3.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by aetherson on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:08PM (#15120090)
It doesn't "challenge the concept of heat," but it does make pretty ridiculous a line on one side of which is "hot" and on another side of which is "cold" and "cold" is bad and wrong and immoral and "hot" is awesome.

(And "pathology" has all the same bright-line-distinction problems that performance-enhancing-substances do, so your proposal to clear up the problem actually makes things even less clear.)

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by matt4077 on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:36PM (#15120283)
Nobody is saying that one side of that divide is uniformly "bad" and the other is "awesome". There's obviously no "morally awesome" in doping–only "not doping". And nobody is denying that there is a grey area. But the existence of a grey area doesn't mean that the extremes don't exist.

To try another example: within the infinity of possible human actions, you can probably find something for every nuanced level of morality from "saving a hundred babies" all the way to genocide, with parking in a handicapped spot slightly on the "bad" side of average, and "looking at the watch" somewhere really close to neutral.

But just because we can't always draw a bright line between "good" and "bad" actions doesn't mean we should abolish all criminal law, does it?

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by KGIII on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:06PM (#15120495)
To beat your analogy into the ground, go to a car show and see what happens if you flick a single grain of sand onto some of the cars.

My only point is to draw attention to there being wildly different views on where the line should be drawn.

I am way over on the permissive side, if you're curious. I do think it needs to be disclosed and separate records kept/established.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by matt4077 on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:15PM (#15121648)
I think your examples actually proves my point: even though there are wildly different views on where the line should be drawn, we don't consider that to be a reason not to draw any lines.

So there's disagreement over the damage inflicted on a car by various actions: the car aficionado will consider it an assault on himself if you look at his car the wrong way, whereas the hippie will shrug his shoulders and bemoan the spelling mistake if someone tagged his VW Camper van with "I sukk". But even though these differences exist, nobody is arguing that setting someone's car on fire should be a criminal offence.

To get back to doping: you can reasonably argue that caffeine in huge doses is doping, and you can reasonably argue the opposite. But that's no reason not to limit EPO or genetic doping.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by aetherson on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:55PM (#15120409)
You're trying very hard to create analogies to explain something that I already understand, have said I understood, and don't disagree with you on.

And if this article were about someone taking a shit-ton of steroids and attaching a cybernetic device that super-oxygenated her blood during the match, then we could reasonably say that it doesn't matter where the line is, she's way over it.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by praneshp on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:48PM (#15119924)
Simple. Look up what the WTA/<insert authority of sport you play> regulations ban; everything else is fine.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by aetherson on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:02PM (#15120037)
Cool. The authority of the sport that the author played was the USTA, not the WTA. The author says, "For the record, meldonium is not illegal (or “scheduled”) in America, nor is it banned specifically by the USTA." I presume you have now 100% flipped your opinion on whether the author cheated, based on your not having read the article carefully.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by praneshp on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:06PM (#15120077)
Oh I don't think the author cheated, at all. My takeaway from the article was that he felt good on moldonium, and played in a(n?) USTA tournament where it isn't banned.

I thought your contact lenses nonsense was about your OPs 'roots for cheaters'

Edit: Thinking back, I think I'll support Sharapova too, but there is no question in my mind that she was on illegal (acc to WTA) drugs for 26 days.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by aetherson on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:11PM (#15120109)
I thought that you were the person who kicked off this thread, and you weren't, so snark on the subject of careful readings is fully deserved! My apologies.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by praneshp on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:14PM (#15120127)
Hey I actually thought I was rude and edited out the snark. No worries.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by tristor on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:55PM (#15119975)
Help, help, I'm stuck in a tautology factory.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by taeric on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:49PM (#15119935)
I think the argument was to build a logical rationale for this. Appeal to authority is somewhat weak, in that regard.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by praneshp on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:57PM (#15119989)
I'm not trying to appeal to authority. When you play a WTA tournament, it's only fair that you have to abide by their rules. Playing tennis, or playing in another tour that doesn't ban your drug of choice shouldn't be banned.

This has nothing to do with my opinion on general drug use, which I agree has been demonized.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by taeric on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:18PM (#15120159)
It was pretty clear that the post you responded to is looking for "why has the governing body chosen this particular set of rules."

Otherwise, it is a pretty boring discussion. Yes, the authority on whether or not this substance is banned has (or has not) banned this substance. :)

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by rocqua on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:54PM (#15119965)
I think OP tried to make the point that anyone participating in a competition should stick to the rules of that competition.

That doesn't preclude discussion about whether those rules make sense, but "Yes, I broke the rules to get an advantage, but the rule really shouldn't be there because of these reasons" is never a good defence. It might help to further the cause of rule change, but it never makes a result from cheating fair.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by taeric on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:17PM (#15120146)
Right, I took that too. I took the post they were responding to as a request to build a logical rationale.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by TylerE on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:53PM (#15119959)
Drugs are bad.

Why?

Because they're illegal.

Why are they illegal?

Because they're bad.

Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by baddox on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:59PM (#15120014)
To be fair, the original commenter only mentioned "cheating," not "bad." It's pretty reasonably to claim that using drugs that are banned by the governing body of your sport qualifies as cheating.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by praneshp on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:58PM (#15120001)
Who said drugs are bad? I'm pretty sure they are great, from the vast literature out here.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by danielharrison on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:49PM (#15119941)
The author did not cheat.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by matz1 on Monday August 28, 2017 @04:47PM (#15119920)
It's cheats only if you get caught.
Re:Taking meldonium for performance enhancement by r00fus on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:21PM (#15120175)
According to the coach of my middle-school friend (anecdotally, possible apocryphally), "if you're not cheating, you're not trying".

Was a shocking concept to me at the time that people thought that.