When Toyota talks about "full autonomous driving", they really mean fully autonomous in a safe and predictable manner. When Uber or Tesla says the same, the implication is that a "good enough" level will be good enough - and that level can be achieved much sooner than whatever Toyota is talking about.
They might do better with hardware than software ...
The argument he puts forth is that pedal error on the drivers part is an explanation for the unintended acceleration.
To be clear, I believe that most cases of unintended acceleration are caused by pedal confusion/floormats. Just because that's true of most accidents, that does not mean it's true of all of them.
Maybe it's because I work in the embedded space, but I've seen code written as indicated and terrible code like that is not reliable. It might work 99.999% of the time, but given 100,000 units, and a problem might occur every couple weeks. There is nothing magical about automotive software.
Sounds a lot like what people were saying about Nokia in 2007. It had near monopoly and was really good at executing pre-iphone smartphones, however they were never as invested in software as Apple or Google were and we all know how this ended.
Your sentiment here is like saying Samsung is great at making phones so they must be great at Mobile OS's. They're fundamentally separate things, and we frequently see that proficiency in one area doesn't necessarily translate to proficiency in another.
No Toyota is fantastic at designing, building, marketing, managing logistics, integrating credit systems etc...for cars.
Selling a Level 5 automated car is as much marketing as it is software. It could work perfectly but if nobody trusts it enough to buy, at a low enough price point, then it won't matter.
Arguing that they will be a leader in self driving cars because they are leader is selling legacy cars very much smacks of the "PC guys aren't going to just walk in" comment regarding smartphones.
There's an old saying that goes something like:
X + computer = computer
So
Teletype + computer = computer
VDU + computer = computer
Phone + computer = computer
Computers and IT driven companies are eating whole industries.
For desktops, Apple's sales barely register.
Servers? Nope.
Laptops? Sure. But Chromebooks have outsold them.
The only realm that Apple dominates is smartphones. They're great. I enjoy my iPhone. It also happens that iPhone sales are enough to be the biggest publicly-traded company in the world.
Anyway, when is the last time software alone got someone from point A to point B? It’s a hell of a lot easier to license software from a provider than it is to outsource the building and shipping of reliable vehicles.
They produced and delivered a popular, well received electric car and have been selling them since 2010.
I assumed we would, after a few years, see electric Jukes and 350z and an Infiniti model. Maybe a electric GT-R as a "halo" model. Something ? Anything ?
Instead, seven years went by and they have managed to (almost) release a second-generation Leaf.
This is, basically, the Leaf setup but with a much smaller battery and a range extending generator. Currently you can't even plug it in, but it does give higher mpg and better driving experience around urban areas compared with an ICE car.
They've been selling partial-electric cars since at least 2014. The Prius Prime allows for electric-only driving up to about 30 miles per charge. That's enough for my commute. I got 3500 miles on my first tank of gas.
Toyota has put a small battery and electric motor in their cars for 20 years now capable of propelling the vehicle at low speeds.
But if you're trying to build an actual electric vehicle, you don't want a small battery as that puts you on the worst part of the discharge rate and battery life curve. A larger battery in the same vehicle reduces the "C" rate and is much kinder on the battery plus gives you much more power to work with and ability to handle a much higher charge rate.
Big battery wins, long-term. Small battery is a false economy except on hybrids.
I think the lack of appreciation of this (and lack of availability of inexpensive batteries) has hampered a lot of carmakers. Address that (super cheap batteries so you can put a 500 mile battery in if you want), and virtually every "problem" with electric cars goes away or is dramatically reduced.
They've hired other folks, too, who have real-world autonomous vehicle experience.
Google/Waymo are definitely leading the pack, but I don't think we'll see Level 5 in a production vehicle for at least five years, probably closer to 10.
I read the recent article about their test facility (https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/08/insid...), but 1. It's still California weather and 2. I've routinely seen worse intersections. What do you do in a rotary where you have to cut across multiple lanes of traffic to exit? If the autonomous vehicle waits for another car to give way, it will be there forever.
What do you do in a multi-lane rotary roundabout with trams going through it, and construction happening? (an actual use case from Bremen, Germany).
There’s so many situations they’re not even considering.
Google/Waymo is building a Schönwetterauto, in the metaphorical and literal meaning.
i really dont see autonomous driving as much of a race when the "race" is going to take 20-30 years to complete. cycles that long give everyone a chance to catch up and leapfrog each other
Also, as electricity demand and price goes up, and gas demand and price goes down, oil companies will quickly pivot to producing H2 by steam methane reforming with carbon capture and storage, to continue the returns on their billions of dollars of investments.
I can't speak to their autonomous technology, but Toyota has always been a leader in electric vehicles, from the early hybrids, to partnering with Tesla, to impressive long term improvements in fuel cells even after the U.S. Gov. Moved on to batteries. Arguably Toyota has more electric vehicle prowess than any other company. It is relatively small potatoes to change the source from open system cells to closed cells, especially when many of battery manufactures are also Japanese.
2022 is a good year if they come up with good tech. At the moment the market for EV's is small, tech is new and only Tesla really shows of something (they have to, because EV's are their only business). All big car makers are researching, from new diesels (double injector SCR's) to EV's & autonomus driving. And if they don't (or go too slow for some), then 1st tier suppliers like Bosch & Continental are doing it.
[0] https://www.fastcompany.com/40406052/this-sensor-technology-...
It's clear that autonomous driving can be made to work, because Google/Waymo is doing it. It's hard and expensive and it takes a lot of sensors. It also takes extensive testing. Waymo drives 25,000 autonomous miles a week. Volvo has level 3 working on some freeways in Sweden; their 100 users are not required to watch the road while in auto mode.
There are other startups trying to do it. There's the "fake it til you make it" crowd - Otto and Cruise. (Otto's highly publicized Budweiser truck delivery demo was on a nearly deserted freeway surrounded by chase cars.) There's the "it's just a small matter of software" Tesla approach. There's the "throw machine learning at vision and hope" crowd, some small startups. That's what you get if you take the Udacity course and start coding. 43 companies have California DMV licenses for autonomous vehicle testing.
Toyota has been making some bad business decisions lately. They don't make battery electric cars. (They're fixing that, but won't be shipping until 2022.[1]) Instead, they've been pushing cars that run on hydrogen. Toyota sells the Mirai in California, and has a few hydrogen stations so it can be refueled. They sell about a hundred cars a month.[2]
[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-toyota-electric-cars-idUS... [2] http://carsalesbase.com/us-car-sales-data/toyota/toyota-mira...