What the strategy ignores is that it gets eaten alive in ranges, when the market isn't trending, this strategy buys high and sells low over and over until you're broke. Works great when the market is trending though.
Bitcoin for example last crossed its 10 month moving average around $246, it's now trading over 4k; $246 would have been a hell of a price to get in at. So yes, buying the "high" works well in a trending market. It's have to drop to $1827 to trigger that same sell signal so you'd lose well over half the floating profit, and then it'd probably cross back and forth a few times when it's near the average trigger many failed entries and exits eating up all the profit you just made.
Moving average strategies don't work except in hindsight when you can see the trend and decide which MA would have worked (something you can't know beforehand), but they're great teaching aids in understanding and learning about trading strategies because they're nearly as simple as a strategy can get.
- Buy as the asset is rising above 10 month MA (and likely will continue to rise, maybe for weeks, months, years)
- Sell as the asset is cooling off (falling below 10 month MA). Don't get "back in" until the asset is heating back up.
With something like bitcoin, this idea would be to ride up a large market bull, but then get out until it looks like it is happening again. If you play with the Moving Average[0], you can see that this strategy would basically have you enter in late 2013, sell in mid 2014, and not enter again until late 2015, then hold all the way. Not exactly a riveting strategy, but OP didn't claim as much.[0] https://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg1460zigDailyz...
No one regrets buying AAPL high in 2010, or selling LEH low in early 2008.
This is clearly survivorship bias.
I get 715 days of a trend continuing (down->down or up->up), and 739 days of the "trend" reversing: down->up OR up->down.
That pretty much points at a random walk. "Momentum", and any other patterns people see, are imagined.
I want this so bad.
Bitcoin spot market is going to get SPAN margining instead of Reg-T, so the options leverage is going to be amazing, way better than the ridiculous margin requirements for equity options, it is almost unfathomable.
With the CFTC loving it, CBOE and CME Group gearing up for futures and options, and the Winklevoss Twins pushing them hard because they want that ETF, thats how I know bitcoin is just getting started.
This is one of my bullish cases. The entire "but muh volatility" argument goes completely out of the window, after they reinvent hedging.
In this case ,this is assuming that when the market shifts from bull to bear you can see it with a 30 day average-- or put another way, it's assuming it moves at a certain speed.
When you claim that this "significantly outperforms" is that based on measurements of bitcoin or of some other assets?
No. The system is only updated once a month, e.g., on the first day of the month. Daily price fluctuations are totally ignored.
Unless you've got a crystal ball, market timing isn't something you can count on for investment returns.
If yes, then I must say that black swans are just around the corner waiting for you.
But it would lose all it's value if it just swings up and down slightly over time, as it buys high and sells low.
If you hold for less than a year it's income, if you hold for more than a year it's capital gains. So buy and hold would possibly be advantageous in the US at least (35% vs 15% tax rates.)
But it's the profits specifically that are taxed as income, not the whole sale value, right? If I buy and sell one Bitcoin a hundred times in a day and make $1 of profit in total, is the tax is a percentage of $1 or a percentage of 100 times the bitcoin price?
For example, the following system significantly outperforms both buy-and-hold and dollar-cost averaging strategies.
That's it. Market timing improves the risk-adjusted returns with minimally increased transaction costs versus a buy-and-hold strategy.