News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by dalbasal on Thursday August 24, 2017 @04:15AM (#15088434)
A lot of conversations about expanding rights, end up with a distinction between positive and negative rights. A right to water, is different to free speech. For everyone to have a right to water, someone needs to provide the water or be held accountable for not providing it. A default, state culprit needs to be designated.

Privacy though, privacy is like speech or equality before the law or presumption of innocence. You have it by default and if it’s denied there is a culprit.

Even in this case, we seem to have a hard time expanding rights. I say expanding, but privacy is a right in many places, formally. But, the interpretation of that right is very weak.

Anyway… if we’re to make privacy a right with serious intent then there needs to be a willingness to break eggs, bear a cost. The right to free speech, conscience, affiliation , assembly and other political freedoms mean we need to tolerate and protect the proverbial nazis’ rights to try and spread their politics. Bitter pill for anyone scared of a proverbial nazi takeover.

Are we willing to bear the (fear-based, mostly) costs in the fight against the terrorism demon. The economic costs that will be claimed by companies relying on data? If we have a strong yes, I think we can start building the real framework of laws and conventions that will secure a right to privacy for the next few generations.

Absolute principles require some sacrifice.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by coldtea on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:35AM (#15088725)
>The right to free speech, conscience, affiliation , assembly and other political freedoms mean we need to tolerate and protect the proverbial nazis’ rights to try and spread their politics. Bitter pill for anyone scared of a proverbial nazi takeover.

Nazi's are an easy target. The problem starts when things are not as clean cut -- when actual politics are involved, as opposed to crude stuff like "exterminate all jews" and "blacks are inferior", etc that Nazi's might say.

Let's say a team wants to overthrow the presidency and bring something like another parliamentary system in the US. Or rewrite the constitution and remove the BS ideas from 3 centuries ago.

Should they be allowed to express their ideas? If they get somewhat popular and other people worry about their influence?

And what's stopping disagreeing people from considering them the same, or worse, as they'd have more current influence, than Nazis, and asking to ban their speeches etc?

(Many people considered the CPUSA like that in the 30s and up to the 60s)

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by kerkeslager on Thursday August 24, 2017 @04:07PM (#15093601)
This is exemplary of a tendency organizations have: prioritizing existence of the organization over the values the organization was formed to uphold.

The US was ostensibly formed to preserve the rights of its citizens. If we let people exercise those rights, they may dissolve the union. But if we don't let them exercise those rights in order to preserve the union, the union loses its entire purpose; the union as it was intended is destroyed just as surely as if it were dissolved.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by wojt_eu on Friday August 25, 2017 @05:27AM (#15097181)
> Nazi's are an easy target. The problem starts when things are not as clean cut -- when actual politics are involved, as opposed to crude stuff like "exterminate all jews" and "blacks are inferior", etc that Nazi's might say.

It wasn't so clean cut back in Germany in the 30s either, there was always some other rhetoric: being "stabbed in the back" in WW1 by internal forces, using emergency powers to deal with effects of Great Depression and threat of Marxism.

[Update]

I encourage watching snippets of Hitler's speeches (with translations): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnpTWKKWQ1o. Strip away swastikas and heils and these could be used by populist politicians today.

Even if we succeed in prosecuting hate speech there will still be plenty room for fanatics to come to power.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by carradjm on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:31AM (#15090383)
They absolutely should be able to express their ideas, as long as they do so in a peaceful and non-threatening way.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by bluGill on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:38AM (#15090974)
If the idea is not peaceful though, even though the expression is? "We should change the law to make murder legal" is a peaceful statement, but if it catches on...
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by ameister14 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @01:38PM (#15092214)
What about burning or hanging someone in effigy? That's pretty threatening, but doesn't actively display intent.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by gnaritas on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:38AM (#15090429)
I don't see why any of those are problematic, all should be protected as free speech. Speech is not violence, it does not have victims and thus should not be in any way a crime no matter how repugnant. No speech should ever be banned.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by coldtea on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:38AM (#15090976)
>I don't see why any of those are problematic, all should be protected as free speech.

Well, the CPUSA wasn't.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by gnaritas on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:30PM (#15091508)
It should have been, but people get irrational when they're afraid.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by damnfine on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:38AM (#15090977)
Who would downvote this without explaining themselves?
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by rmc on Thursday August 24, 2017 @04:51AM (#15088558)
> A lot of conversations about expanding rights, end up with a distinction between positive and negative rights.

Correct. Right to a fair trail is also a positive right. To uphold it, the state must pay for a lawyer if you don't have one, the state must pay for enough judges (& associated costs) to ensure your trail isn't delayed ("Justice delayed is justice denied" and all that).

> The right to free speech, conscience, affiliation , assembly and other political freedoms mean we need to tolerate and protect the proverbial nazis’ rights to try and spread their politics.

Plenty of legal systems have those rights, and also ban nazis or similar groups. It's not an either/or.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by icebraining on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:18AM (#15088669)
Right to a fair trail is also a positive right.

Ehh, I'm not sure. The actual right is better described as the right not to be unfairly tried, which is clearly negative. The distinction is more than semantic: if the State launches an investigation and then drops it, leaving suspicion in the public's mind, you can't force them to go to trial to present your case and clear your name.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by frgtpsswrdlame on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:31AM (#15089913)
What you're running into is the fuzzy distinction between positive and negative rights. Actually, in my mind there probably is no distinction and the classification of some rights as positive and others as negative is just a matter of wording, take this from James Sterba:

What is at stake is the liberty of the poor not to be interfered with in taking from the surplus possessions of the rich what is necessary to satisfy their basic needs. Needless to say, libertarians would want to deny that the poor have this liberty. But how could they justify such a denial? As this liberty of the poor has been specified, it is not a positive right to receive something, but a negative right of non-interference.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by dieterrams on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:47AM (#15088778)
The right not to be unfairly tried is easily satisfied by not having a trial at all.

The right to a fair trial is about two things: you must be tried before being found guilty and punishment/sentencing is administered, and that trial must be executed fairly. In effect, you have the right to a (fair) trial.

A trial and especially a fair trial are undeniably interventions on how things would otherwise proceed. But I agree with moomin that the positive/negative distinction is not really meaningful.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by icebraining on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:59AM (#15089072)
A trial and especially a fair trial are undeniably interventions on how things would otherwise proceed

No, because otherwise it would just be aggression. A trial is a method for the accusers to be able to show that their subsequent aggression (imprisonment, removal of property, etc) is justified.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by dieterrams on Thursday August 24, 2017 @02:21PM (#15092614)
No, it is to prevent the defendant from being unjustly blamed and punished.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by icebraining on Thursday August 24, 2017 @03:30PM (#15093244)
Unjustly blaming and punishing someone is defamation and aggression. You don't need extra rights to be protected from that.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by dieterrams on Thursday August 24, 2017 @04:07PM (#15093597)
How about you read declarations of rights to a fair trial and point out where they imply that they are principally about ensuring the accusers' application of aggression is justified, as opposed to protecting the accused?

Whether or not you think an "extra right" is necessary has no bearing on why that right is provided.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by Qantourisc on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:28AM (#15088927)
There is still the option to mandate both. (No unfair tried, and a fair trial.)
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by rsync on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:55AM (#15091153)
"Plenty of legal systems have those rights, and also ban nazis or similar groups. It's not an either/or."

They are mistaken. Free speech and free association are not extant when books are banned or ideas are outlawed.

It is an either/or and all historical evidence serves to confirm this.

If you want blowfish source to not be a munition you need to put up with the Westboro Baptists.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by andrewla on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:45PM (#15091683)
> Free speech and free association are not extant when books are banned or ideas are outlawed.

I mean, is this just arguing about the definition of the term "free speech"? It's not hard to think of easy examples, like the "shouting fire in a crowded theater" or "revealing military secrets to the enemy at times of war" or "libel" or "slander". By necessity, we accept that there are restrictions.

In general I favor a generous standard, where to disallow certain types of speech you need to carve out a compelling case -- the default should be that speech (and speech-like things) should not be forbidden. But stating it as a naked tautology is not helpful because it acknowledges none of the nuance.

> all historical evidence serves to confirm this

Once again, if we're just talking definitions, then sure, any place or time where books are banned or ideas are outlawed is not practicing free speech. But I think you'd be hard-pressed, given the exceptions above, to ever find a place in history where this was practiced.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by rlpb on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:50AM (#15089026)
> Right to a fair trail is also a positive right. To uphold it, the state must pay for a lawyer...

Nope. The state could just choose not to prosecute.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by matt4077 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:13AM (#15089131)
The definition of something as a right doesn't imply that it is absolute. Incarceration, for example, almost certainly infringes on most rights you can think of (assembly, property, association, speech, privacy, pursuit of happiness). Yet it's routinely practiced.

So, no: personal rights don't have to come with costs to be meaningful. Example: "You have the right to peacefully assemble and protest for your beliefs. Yeah, no, not in my living room." Religious liberties, as another example, also seem to be doing just fine, even though it seriously cramps my style that people apparently belief virgin sacrifices are no longer included in that freedom.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:01AM (#15088606)
> The right to free speech, conscience, affiliation , assembly and other political freedoms mean we need to tolerate and protect the proverbial nazis’ rights to try and spread their politics.

I'm not convinced I know how I feel about this. I want to believe this is a false dichotomy. Can we have limits in polite society?

I keep thinking of the paradox of tolerance[1], which states, in brief, that if a society is tolerant without limit, their ability to be tolerant will eventually be seized or destroyed by the intolerant.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by moduspol on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:29AM (#15089187)
Are we really to the point where Nazi ideologies are spreading like wildfire, to the point that their "intolerance" will be seized by our "tolerance?"

To me it seems like the opposite is happening. Nazi ideologies are marginalized and meaningless, yet propped up like some huge threat to us... like they might take over. And this is being used as justification for limiting free speech, in a hyper-politically correct society where even micro-aggressions could be categorized as "hate speech."

Perhaps we could just recognize and acknowledge that, while reprehensible, it's not like Nazi believers are anything more than a rounding error in normal society. And then move on with our days.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by bluGill on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:41AM (#15091007)
I would argue we have gone the other way: we are so busy stomping down Nazi like ideologies that the stomping it down has become as bad of hate speech as the Nazis were.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by bashinator on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:05PM (#15094060)
Until the government begins a mass extermination program for haters, I can't help but feel this is a hyperbolic argument. Not granting permits to march is totally incomparable with genocide.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday August 24, 2017 @02:26PM (#15092663)
I'm not convinced.

If we're going to tolerate Nazi and Nazi-like speech, don't we also have to tolerate those who would should them down?

Until we start rounding up Nazis, and Nazi sympathisers, and politely asking them to reside in this here concentration camp and eat this rotten-fish-head-with-cabbage soup, shouting them down seems quite reasonable.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by rsync on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:05PM (#15091243)
"Are we really to the point where Nazi ideologies are spreading like wildfire, to the point that their "intolerance" will be seized by our "tolerance?""

You're thinking about it a little backwards - here's a fascinating example of the paradox of tolerance:

Proposition 8, in California (2008)[1] was a ballet initiative that proposed that "only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California".

Proposition 8 passed and the post mortem indicated that black and latino/hispanic voters (who are not politically progressive in the manner of coastal californians) voted (overwhelmingly, in the case of blacks) in favor of the proposition - so much so as to be a deciding factor in its passage.[2][3][4]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_8_(2008...

[2] http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2008/11/70-of-african-...

[3] http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/nov/8/blacks-hispan...

[4] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2013/03/26/ho...

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by ameister14 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @01:41PM (#15092256)
I don't understand how that is the paradox of intolerance.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by sqeaky on Thursday August 24, 2017 @02:36PM (#15092757)
It is not, but it is still interesting and closely related.

The minorities in question were welcomed into society and empowered with votes then promptly voted to oppress another minority. There are clearly problems with this.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by kenjackson on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:52AM (#15090089)
I suspect actually Nazis may be a rounding error, but Nazi believers are probably much more. And in some regions maybe even approaching double digit percentages.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday August 24, 2017 @02:17PM (#15092583)
If we have data let's go with the data. If all we have is opinions, let's go with mine.

What are we to do? One way of dealing with the problem would be to ask the question at census time: Do you believe in Nazi or Nazi like ideologies? and then round those people up and put them to death. This has it's own problems.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by sqeaky on Thursday August 24, 2017 @02:43PM (#15092812)
I agree that we shouldn't tolerate intolerance, right up until you said "round those people up and put them to death". Any state run mechanism for this will be abused and infringes on a whole bunch of other rights.

Doing things like clamping down speech that incites violence or otherwise directly harms people is working. More options are open for almost all members of minorities than ever before (in terms of jobs, opportunities, legal recourse, etc... ). The nazis are just being loud about it now because they think trump will somehow protect them.

Convict and arrest people advocating for the death's of others, financially fine those empowering that one specific kind of speech and the people will continue to get smaller. Without the violence hate speech cannot grow.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday August 24, 2017 @03:36PM (#15093295)
I meant to highlight that some people are saying free speech is a binary issue, as though we either have free speech or the end of civilisation.

There are other options, reasonable limits, as you've pointed out.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by kenjackson on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:25PM (#15095189)
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by bckygldstn on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:21AM (#15088686)
Many countries have limitations to free speech (e.g., Germany banning holocaust denial, Sweden banning hate speech) but have a free and open culture in spite of this. It's a hard balance to strike, but freedom of speech doesn't have to be all or nothing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by humanrebar on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:36AM (#15088958)
If dissenting speech is stopped, how will the public ever know when an argument is illegitimate and when it is merely dangerous to the ruling class?

People don't find this to be convincing: "Don't worry, the ruling class makes sure only the dangerous speech is stopped". Especially with free speech rules, we have a "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?" situation.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday August 24, 2017 @02:38PM (#15092772)
> how will the public ever know

Because the public isn't stupid.

Does the slippery slope argument work here?

I'm sure German's have their own opinions about it all, in private, and in public to the extent allowed under their laws, and they seem to have a relatively coherent sense of how to go about having a society. Perhaps even more coherent than the US.

In 2015 Germany rated higher (aggregate score 95) than the US (aggregate score 90) for freedom of the press.[1]

1. Refer chart commencing page 20 - https://freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/FH_FITW_Report_...

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by gnaritas on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:42AM (#15090462)
Then it's not free speech. If you're not free to speak about certain things, you do not have freedom of speech, it is very much all or nothing. Freedom is a binary condition, you either have it, or you don't.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by pmyteh on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:59AM (#15090617)
It may be that having 'full' freedom is correct in some senses, but it seems fairly clear that it's non-binary.

A government which firmly censors newspapers writing restaurant reviews but allows anything else is fairly clearly more free than one which also forbids discussion of politics, religion, and the football results. I don't think anybody would say they are indifferent to which of the two they would prefer, on the grounds that neither are wholly free.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by gnaritas on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:29AM (#15090880)
It's an abuse of language to call either of them free, neither are free, one is simply less authoritarian than the other. Yes, authoritarianism is not binary, there are many levels, but freedom of speech is binary, if you can be jailed for speaking, you do not have freedom of speech, you have an authoritarian government that may be less worse than others, but don't confuse it or label it as less free, it's simply not free. What you're doing is newspeak.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by dalbasal on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:25AM (#15088909)
We can certainly have limits in polite society, just not in public life.

Tolerating intolerance is indeed an issue, but I don’t think there’s anything inevitable about their eventual success. For liberal democracy to survive, the electorate need to choose it. If 51% of the public is non democratic in their political preferences, we can’t have democracy.

They have a right to speak, not rule.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by sametmax on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:21AM (#15088684)
The limit is action. Words are not important.

But a lot of words are mixed with actions: harassments, segregation, etc. Those should be clearly identified so that free speech don't protect them.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by matt4077 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:20AM (#15089150)
If freedom of speech is important, speech must have the power to have real consequences. If something has real consequences, those can be either bad, good, or neutral.

If all consequences of speech were neutral or positive, we could make the world a better place by connecting a source of randomness with a text-to-speech synthesiser. But that's absurd.

Therefore, speech has the ability to harm. The distinction between "words" and "actions" is meaningless, as is already obvious from your inclusion of harassment in your list of actions. Because harassment is also just speech.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by sametmax on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:36AM (#15089546)
No, harassment is the action of repeatedly crafting then using deliberately harmful speech toward a specific target. It's not about the speech at all. The speech can change. The combination of repetition, intention of harm, and specific target can not.

And you speak about consequences, but those consequences are the one that should be punished. Because you can assess consequences. You can evaluate damages. You can't evaluate the value of words.

If you say "kill the xx" one time, it really doesn't matter.

If you say "kill the xx" and that it leads to attempt to kill, then the problem is the intent to kill.

Otherwise South park / Rick and Morty could not exist.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by matt4077 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:31AM (#15090386)
> deliberately harmful speech

So there is harmful speech. Thanks.

> Otherwise South park / Rick and Morty could not exist.

South Park is freely shown on TV stations in basically any country that has enough of an audience to make economic sense. Every single one of those countries has more restrictive laws regarding hate speech, yet they also seem to have the capability to distinguish between a TV show and and armed mob with swastikas.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by noufalibrahim on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:46AM (#15088770)
This is tricky. I think a workable solution is to create zones where free speech is unrestricted and where new ideas can be incubated. They themselves would have some restrictions (e.g. you can't physically hurt the person you lost a debate to) but would, by and large, be free speech zones. The idea was described in this speech https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJktQiZRa5A

The rest of society can have different rules which can be more nuanced.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by matt4077 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:26AM (#15089174)
Yeah, that's an incredibly stupid idea–and I say that as a big fan of reasonable limits on free speech.

Creating "free speech zones" seems like a surefire way to start telling everyone to "take it to the free speech zone" and stop annoying "normal people" with your ideas. It's like the wet dream of these people that have started calling citizens consumers, even in a political context, and advocate the criminal prosecution of peaceful protesters when they don't all stay on the sidewalks.

FWIW, I first remember hearing the term in the context of the Beijing Olympics, which should tell you everything you need to know about that idea.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by cuckcuckspruce on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:39AM (#15089992)
It's not just a Beijing Olympics idea.

I went to university in the United States. The university I attended instituted "free speech zones" in the wake of the (second) Iraq War. They were initially protest zones, but by the time I was there they had turned into what you basically said - places where students were told to go to express unpopular ideas instead of being allowed to express them in class.

I took a sociology course during my studies, and the topic of abortion came up. Instead of having a nuanced discussion about the topic, students objecting to the professor's view were cut off or ridiculed. One student, trying to articulate their position was yelled at, by the professor, to shut up and if they felt strongly enough to take their position "to the free speech zone with the other Christian fascists and religious weirdos". Every year I was there, the bounds of the free speech zone got smaller and smaller, so there was even less room where unpopular ideas were officially tolerated on campus.

This is part of why I got out of academia. Not because of any institutional bias, but the authoritarian bent of the administration. All of campus should be a free speech zone. (No, disrupting class is not "free speech", there is a difference.)

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by cokernel on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:34AM (#15089534)
The term "free-speech zone" is older than that. It goes back at least to 2004, and a similar concept under a different name ("protest zone") is even older.

Example from 2004: https://www.acslaw.org/acsblog/free-speech-zones-balancing-f...

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by noufalibrahim on Friday August 25, 2017 @07:23AM (#15097640)
That makes sense. It's not something I'd considered. However, this is not exactly what I had in mind. My thought was that society should have, as you've put it, "reasonable limits on free speech" but these zones should be "free speech absolutist" places. So the scale is from absolutist in the zones to regular in normal society rather than normal in the zones and restricted in normal society. Whether the former will collapse into the latter and how to prevent that are serious problems though.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday August 24, 2017 @03:24PM (#15093184)
It's worth noting that "kill all the Jews" isn't a new idea.

Edited to add: But, okay, I suppose "kill all the Jews with Zyklon B"[1] was a novel form.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zyklon_B

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by gnaritas on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:45AM (#15090490)
That's an absolutely awful idea. It's great if you want to live in a totalitarian regime, otherwise awful.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by sametmax on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:03AM (#15088841)
Or maybe time periods. Like in the purge :)
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by moomin on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:18AM (#15088671)
In practice I think the positive negative distinction is somewhat pointless. All rights, regardless of their "nature" require enforcement and consistent interpretation and neither of those things come for free.

Part of the problem for Americans is that they have two definitions of rights. There's the ones in the Bill of Rights, which are phrased in a negative way. And there's those in the Declaration of Independence, which are provided by the creator and that governments must implement. And those rights are extremely broad. Heck, just the right to life could reasonably be argued to ban the death penalty. (Luckily for jurists everywhere, the Declaration of Independence isn't actually on the statute book.)

In practice, I think the distinction (and to be quite honest, pretty much the entire minimalist/constitutionalist approach) is mostly used to justify path dependence. The founding fathers believed that later generations would have enhanced understanding of the world. Fetishising their every decision just makes for a worse America.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by dalbasal on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:19AM (#15088888)
I’m not opposed to positive rights, but I’d rather we call them something else so as not to erode the special nature of regular rights.

In Europe/UK, the right to housing is often mentioned. That is a completely different can of worms. A state can try and fail to provide everyone access to housing. This is different to free speech. There is no such thing as well intentioned failure to protect speech.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by chongli on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:51AM (#15089292)
special nature of regular rights

They aren't special, though. The distinction between "positive" and "negative" rights completely melts away when you ask yourself who has substantive access and who merely has formal access to their rights.

For example, free speech. You can't exercise your right to free speech when you're dead. Everybody may have formal access (access on paper) to free speech but some people have far greater substantive access due to their socioeconomic status. A poor person will suppress their right to free speech in exchange for a job so they can buy food. Their employer, on the other hand, can say whatever they want without the risk of being fired. Same formal access, different substantive access.

This exercise works for any right. Perhaps the most obvious one is the right to a fair trial. It would be laughable if it weren't so horrific. Every day, countless people have their lives ruined by the criminal "justice" system because they cannot afford the best lawyer. Wealthy people simply do not have this problem. A person with a lot of wealth has far greater substantive access to a fair trial than the average person.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by phiskk on Thursday August 24, 2017 @05:34AM (#15088722)
For an admittedly artificial example of positive vs negative rights.

If you consider, say, a person living in the middle of a desert.

A right to privacy amounts to just being left alone, and enforcing that would only be required if another party were actively violating that right. <- It's easy to argue for this.

A right to water, on the other hand, might require that some other party be forced to provide water to this person in the desert. <- Here many people might quite reasonably argue; why should others put themselves out to facilitate this persons life choices.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by humanrebar on Thursday August 24, 2017 @06:26AM (#15088920)
> All rights, regardless of their "nature" require enforcement and consistent interpretation and neither of those things come for free.

You start to hit on the distinction a bit when comparing the Bill of Rights and the Declaration of Independence, but you seem to think the ones in the Declaration are less important.

The Declaration talks of "inalienable rights". These are rights that cannot be legitimately violated. That's not to say they can't be violated (slavery was obviously a thing), but that people and governments who violate them are wrong (tyrants, in the language of the Declaration).

So the lack of an enforced legal framework doesn't mean something isn't a right. It can mean that some organization or person is failing to be decent, though.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by moomin on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:27AM (#15089497)
To be clear, I don't think they're less important. I think they're unenforced. But in my experience most people don't seem to really believe in the rights in the DoI if it would cost them anything. For instance, just the right to life would _definitely_ include a right to water, which is an example given elsewhere.
Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by humanrebar on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:36AM (#15089545)
There's an inalienable right to water to the extent that a government would be tyrannical because people didn't have water. I can imagine a few different scenarios where that would be the case.

The "right to life" was more broadly talking about who owns a life (the individual, nature's creator, not the government). It wasn't talking about the right to be free of all death.

Re:Right to Privacy a Fundamental Right, Says Indian Supreme... by DarkKomunalec on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:23AM (#15089158)
> A right to water, is different to free speech.

Not entirely. Consider the case of water privatization, where there's a real risk of extortionate pricing of what used to be a common good. If carefully written, right to water laws can ensure that such resources are used for the benefit of the people, instead of being just another market good that gets slowly monopolized.

Edit: In other words, you may already have the right to free speech, while water must be provided, but both can be denied.