News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by DanielBMarkham on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:01AM (#1507639)
At first I thought the author might be poking fun at the war -- then I realized that he was actually poking fun at himself. People have high standards for fiction, yet some of the strangest things are real-life stories from history.

A couple of my favorites from the Pacific Theater: 1) Radar detected the Japanese strike force approaching Pearl Harbor, but the guy in charge said it was a glitch. 2) The Japanese planned to declare war before attacking, but mix-ups in the way coded messages were processed kept the Japanese delegation from delivering the declaration of war until after the attack, and 3) On several occasions Yamamoto made battle plans that stood some chance of success -- only to have Army guys muck around with the details. That had to get pretty frustrating.

You really can't make some of this shit up.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by stcredzero on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:12AM (#1507664)
As I mentioned before, not only do the Nazis have an urgent plan to conquer the world ASAP, but they also have super science weapons research. Stealth bombers, cruise missiles, ballistic missiles, and jet planes. Yet, at the beginning of the war, they faced cavalry charges! There are real life super-scientists engaged in real-life super-science intrigue to keep nuclear secrets out of Nazi hands. And on top of that, these guys are worse or on a par for atrocities with anyone ever, real or imagined. And to cap it all off, they're running around doing this stuff while wearing outfits designed by Hugo Boss.

It's like the Nazis escaped from the pages of fiction and invaded reality using a time machine.

EDIT: Turns out Hugo Boss didn't design the uniforms. Still, they were quite stylish.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by sedachv on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:28PM (#1508425)
"And on top of that, these guys are worse or on a par for atrocities with anyone ever, real or imagined."

This is a Euro-centric perspective. The Germans did not do anything different than any of the colonial powers in their own colonies. The difference with the Germans is that they decided to colonize Europe.

In terms of excess mortality, the man-made British famines in India are worse. The genocide of Native Americans by the Spanish, English and French colonists is unparalleled in human history for its duration, brutality and number of casualties. In Africa it is much the same - forget Belgians in the Congo, the British had death camps in Kenya in the 1950s!

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by grandalf on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:22PM (#1508610)
Also the Irish potato famine was likely caused by the British.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by stcredzero on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:38PM (#1508464)
I was thinking in terms of quality, not quantity.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by sedachv on Monday July 12, 2010 @02:55PM (#1508985)
Technological innovations do make a big difference. I'm sure the Mongols or Ottomans would have implemented similar methods of mass execution if they had the tools. But OTOH the living conditions on European and American slaving ships actually make German death camps seem humane in comparison.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by MarkPNeyer on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:00AM (#1507771)
"these guys are worse or on a par for atrocities with anyone ever, real or imagined"

If you look at the total number of people killed, hitler's atrocities pale in comparison with those of Stalin and Mao.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by arethuza on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:25AM (#1507870)
Another big difference was that in Stalin's Soviet Union or Mao's China just about everyone was under potential threat - being a member of the party or close to the leader wasn't really any help.

Whereas in Nazi Germany it was a much colder clinical decision to systematically remove "undesirable" elements from society. I think it is the systematic element of their terror, rather than the sheer lunatic barbarity of the communist regimes, that makes them so scary.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by riffraff on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:45AM (#1508252)
isn't this a reductionist view? the night of the long knives is just the first example I can think of, but I'm pretty sure there were more examples of people _becoming_ undesirable.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by arethuza on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:33PM (#1508444)
But in the Soviet Union the arrests were made to quota to feed the slave labor camps of the gulag - not because of anything the prisoners had actually done (of course, they had to confess).

There were some courageous Germans who chose to defy the Nazis (e.g. the White Rose group http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Rose) but that to me is quite different.

The overwhelming majority of Germans, if they didn't belong to one of the racial or political categories hated by the Nazis, had nothing to fear unless they chose to defy the state. Most didn't.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by riffraff on Monday July 12, 2010 @02:15PM (#1508813)
I had not heard of a "arrest to quota" design in the USSR, could you point me to a relevant source so I can read about it?

I still disagree on the main point that to be at risk in nazi germany you had to somehow defy the regime.

Your view seem to be that in nazi germany you could simply comply with the ruling ideology and be fine, but as I said above, you can think of the killings and arrests by the thousands of the SA (which had been key to hitler's seize of power) as a glaring counter example.

Moreover, the gestapo mostly run operations based on delations from common citizens (the origin of the "gestapo=big brother" misconception), it's not hard to imagine how mundane they can be. Unless you have a much better view of humanity than I have :)

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by arethuza on Monday July 12, 2010 @04:45PM (#1509365)
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by easp on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @03:57AM (#1510705)
Whenever shit like that happens, you can be sure that there are people taking advantage of the situation to settle old scores. Wherever the official reason for depriving people of life or liberty, corrupt functionaries will trump up accusations to suit their personal agendas.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by Yzupnick on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:17AM (#1507831)
True but if you look at the manner in which it was done then the Nazis are up there. What was horrible was the systematic way it was done. It wasn't a city gassed on a whim, or a population shot because they where rebelling. Those are terrible, but what is terrible about what the Nazis did was in the planning and efficiency of it all.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by stcredzero on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:37PM (#1508460)
And you can combine that with guards picking up children by the ankles and dashing their brains out on the nearest building.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by varjag on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:35PM (#1508454)
Sorry, but those two didn't made lanterns and mattresses out of people. Hitler very much one-upped everyone in 20th century in terms of atrocities.

As for the count, there are reasons to believe that Hitler was direct cause for WW2 in Europe. That one took quite a bit more people than 6M Jews you seem to imply.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by sedachv on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:13PM (#1508369)
The total numbers pulled from Reagan's imagination?

edit: I'll post some sources when I get home

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by sedachv on Monday July 12, 2010 @07:02PM (#1509749)
As promised:

This includes the best available numbers on the people imprisoned and executed for counter-revolutionary (political, kulaks, etc.) crimes from 1921 to 1954 in the entire Soviet Union (includes republics annexed in 1939) from a report ordered by Khruschev (ie - the real numbers, not speculation), as well as an analysis of the commonly published speculative numbers:

http://www.thewalls.ru/truth/repress.htm (Russian)

http://translate.google.com/translate?js=y&prev=_t&h... (Google English translation)

642,980 executed, 2,369,220 imprisoned, 765,180 internally exiled over a 30-year period. That is 21,433 people receiving capital punishment each year, and 78,974 imprisoned per year. To put it in perspective, 89,000 people were sentenced (up to a maximum term of 5 years) for cannabis possession in the UK in 1998.

If you include the number of excess deaths from the Ukrainian and Kazakh famines of 1932, the direct and excess deaths from the civil war and the civil war famines, there's still no comparison to the Third Reich.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by dgordon on Monday July 12, 2010 @08:04PM (#1509891)
According to Solzhenitsyn a quarter of the population of Leningrad were arrested in and around 1937. Apparently this turned out to be a conservative estimate.

If this is so, your numbers cannot be correct.

And yes, the Holodomor counts too.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by sedachv on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:38PM (#1510087)
I'm so glad this article was posted on HN recently:

http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2010/07/11/...

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by pfedor on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @01:45AM (#1510483)
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by js2 on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:51PM (#1508511)
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by hack_edu on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:52AM (#1508007)
What kind of asshole draws historical conclusions based on /numbers/ dead? Reducing the dead to numbers and comparing a lost life to another an atrocity in itself.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by JoeAltmaier on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:29PM (#1508427)
Classic morality problem: sacrifice 1 you know for 10 you don't. Have you solved it? Enlighten us.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by arethuza on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:35PM (#1508452)
"One death is a tragedy; one million is a statistic"

Stalin

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by 10ren on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:38AM (#1507725)
I had to check out that Hugo Boss one: they were one of thousands of manufacturers; they didn't appear to have "designed" the uniforms (they manufactured police and postal uniforms back then). They didn't do suits til the 50's http://www.nytimes.com/1997/08/15/business/hugo-boss-acknowl...

tschild's two comments here summarize my thinking: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=257389#...

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by stcredzero on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:41AM (#1507729)
I stand corrected. Still, the Nazis were pretty stylin.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by chloraphil on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:04PM (#1508338)
By "cavalry charges" I assume you are referring to the Polish cavalry who did not, in fact, charge.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polish_cavalry#World_War_II

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by cema on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:23PM (#1508403)
I have read about Soviet cavalry charges as late as 1942, but in memoirs, not history books.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by sliverstorm on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @07:11AM (#1514223)
Speaking of the intrigue to keep secrets out of the hands of the Nazis, there were some truly inspired espionage that would make Bond look like an unimaginative phony.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by patio11 on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:06AM (#1507649)
Not to mention the aircraft carriers made out of ice, the campaign to firebomb Japanese cities using bats with incendiaries tied to them, or the brilliant idea to starve out Japanese island garrisons by airdropping pigs onto them in the hope that the pigs would eat the grains before the Japanese ate the pigs (failed).
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by btilly on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:42AM (#1508241)
My favorite messed up weapons from WW II.

The Americans came up with an anti-tank grenade that was really sticky so that it would stay to the tank it was thrown at. Discontinued due to an unfortunate tendency to remain in the thrower's hand.

The Russians (land of Pavlov and all that) came up with the idea of dogs with bombs strapped to their backs that had learned to associate the under side of tanks with food. Great idea, and it might have worked, if the Russian trainers had access to German tanks for the training. Unfortunately when first deployed the dogs proved able to tell Russian tanks apart from German ones, and immediately put the Russians in full retreat.

(I found these in a book of world's worsts that I read many, many years ago.)

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by martey on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @04:06AM (#1510721)
The wikipedia article about the sticky bomb - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sticky_bomb - notes that it was made by the British for use in the event of a German invasion, and so only saw limited front-line use in North Africa and by the French Resistance.

There is also info about the Soviet anti-tank dog program at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-tank_dog#Deployment_by_the...

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by AndrewO on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:23PM (#1508405)
(You meant "The Russians (land of Pavlov...", right?)
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by btilly on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:33PM (#1508443)
Thanks, corrected.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by rudyfink on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:40PM (#1508473)
You missed my favorite one. B.F. Skinner had a WWII weapons program that trained pigeons for use as the guidance system of bombs ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Pigeon ). From a video I saw (but now cannot find) the pigeons were trained to peck at the shape of a warship. Then they would peck at video of a ship which worked to keep the bomb centered on the warship as it fell by directing the fins to where the pigeon pecked.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by arethuza on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:33AM (#1507898)
What about bombs bouncing on water or giant weaponized Catherine Wheels:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panjandrum

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:43AM (#1508243)
There were actually successful attacks with water-skipping bombs. In some cases it was the only way to get the bombs to the target due to the low angle needed.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by mturmon on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:16PM (#1508593)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Chastise

The technology was innovative, but the results were mixed. Almost half the aircrews died, and the main casualties of the resulting floods were forced laborers and POWs.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by pavel_lishin on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:32AM (#1508192)
Wow, never heard about that one. Did they never duct-tape bottle rockets together as kids? Might have taught them a little humility and saved some time.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by pozorvlak on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @08:50AM (#1514398)
Duct tape, IIRC, was only invented in World War II, so no :-)
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by whyenot on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:25PM (#1508622)
Developed largely by engineer (and later famous novelist) Nevil Shute.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by neilk on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:42PM (#1508688)
The history of the Directorate of Miscellaneous Weapons Development is incredible. Their exploits make an episode of the A-Team look plausible.

http://www.uboat.net/books/reviews.html/title/2349

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by viggity on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:00PM (#1508317)
If anyone is interested in the "aircraft carrier made out of ice", you can find out more here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pykrete

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by avolkov on Monday July 12, 2010 @01:20PM (#1508605)
Mythbusters had an episode about it http://mythbustersresults.com/alaska-special-2
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by DaveChild on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:37AM (#1507914)
> aircraft carriers made out of ice

Pykrete, really - a combination of wood and ice. And the idea had merit - see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Habakkuk for lots of interesting details.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by stcredzero on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:50AM (#1507749)
Someone should do a post or web comic about pig projectiles in warfare.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by arethuza on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:55AM (#1508019)
Pig projectiles?

What about nukes kept warm by live chickens:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Peacock

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by ju2tin on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:23AM (#1507854)
Also bats with firebombs attached to them. Surely that's almost as good as sharks with laser beams on their heads.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by stcredzero on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:35PM (#1508450)
"Bats with frickin Napalm!"
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by JoeAltmaier on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:24AM (#1507692)
And Shakespear is just a bunch of cliche's strung together.

Every think this stuff is cliche BECAUSE of WWII? Or am I just dense?

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by rmc on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:32AM (#1507705)
Well the main point is that the history of WW2 is full of 'plot holes' and hard to believe stories (if it was a TV show)
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by JoeAltmaier on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:34AM (#1507712)
Only because we believe, because of the movies, that largescale event SHOULD behave as if orchestrated by a logical, sane author.

History is just, all of us, doing things selfishly.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by dimitar on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:05AM (#1508059)
That is actually why Hitler had an incursion in the USSR while waging war in North Africa and the Atlantic, creating an anti-Hitler coalition and thus having no chance of an outcome that isn't a catastrophe for Germany. Surely an unwise decision.

The Soviets knew in advance of the invasion of the USSR but Stalin could not believe that the Germany could do such thing. Not because he trusted Hitler, but because such a decision would be stupid - Hitler himself claimed that war on two fronts was unwinnable for Germany since WWI and because he didn't see an adequate preparation for an invasion - sure you have troops near the border, but they were in no way prepared for Russian roads, Russian winter or the Russian distances. There was no way Germany could defeat the USSR before winter sets in with no planning.

Stalin planned an invasion of Nazi-controlled Europe, before the Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union. But the Germans had their invasion a few weeks before the planned. But since the troops and materiel were prepared for an offensive war they could react adequately in the beginning. The Russians had only bombers and a million trained paratroops - this is definitely a preparation for an offensive war.

The Germans couldn't achieve any major objective in the USSR anyway:

* they didn't destroy the Russian industrial capability: Moscow and Leningrad weren't taken and behind them you have the Volga and Ural areas, which produced materiel and provided manpower which let the USSR win the war and conquer for itself half of Europe. Plus even much of the plants that were in Ukraine and Belarus were evacuated of their skilled workers and expensive machinery and new ones quickly were formed deep behind the lines of combat and the ranges of Wehrmacht air power.

* no major resource was lacking in the USSR - certainly not oil, which was one of the critical ones. Germany barely had enough from Romania for its own needs. France, the Balkans, Northern Europe, North Africa were invaded with Soviet provided oil, thanks to the Ribbentrop-Molotov pact.

* they didn't isolate Russia politically - they couldn't convince the Japanese to attack them in the back while Soviets had instant allies - Britain and United States which generously provided even more materials and technology.

And this was exactly because the war was started by a logical, sane author.

Stalin overestimated Hitler, thinking he wouldn't do such a thing. Germany had no realistic way of winning a war against the USSR with those conditions. I am not saying that USSR was unbeatable. Just that the Germans didn't have a feasible plan to do it and it was obvious to Stalin.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by btilly on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:54AM (#1508286)
I disbelieve. When Hitler invaded, he immediately put his plan from Mein Kampf into action, and tried to consolidate control and create Lebensraum (aka "living space") for the German people. He had made his desire for that invasion clear many years earlier.

If Hitler hadn't been a deranged fool he would have not sent the SS into Czechoslovakia (which turned the initially rejoicing population hostile), and would have immediately drove right for Moscow. Had he done that the Russians would have had no communication lines, which would have made it massively harder for them to organize a resistance.

Hitler in some sense was the best friend the Allied forces had. Every time he made a major military decision (eg "let the English rescue all of their troops at Dunkirk") it turned out to be really stupid. And the conduct of the Russian war shows lots of examples of that.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by btilly on Monday July 12, 2010 @08:34PM (#1509950)
Oops, I picked the wrong area. I was misremembering a reference to the Ukraine. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Barbarossa for more details.

In particular note that the claim that the Nazis were attacking first to head off a counter-attack is a claim the Germans made during WW II. However there is little evidence for this, and Stalin's instructions to his generals in December of 1940 suggests that the Soviet Union knew it would eventually be invaded, thought it would easily be ready in 4 years, and was trying to put the invasion off for at least 2. When the invasion came in May they were caught unprepared and by surprise.

Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by dkarl on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:22AM (#1508145)
Not just large-scale events. Many people make the mistake of reading their own lives as literature, even though as far as I know, even the ones who believe in God do not believe he is an Author who imposes a literary aesthetic on his creation.
Re:World War II was totally unrealistic by bruceboughton on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:38AM (#1507920)
This is one of the central themes of The Black Swan: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Black-Swan-Impact-Highly-Improbable/...