News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android Oreo by maxsilver on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:24PM (#15067014)
Or even if just gets the chip manufacturers out of the equation, that alone fixes most of the problems.

The OEM side is usually pretty easy / trivial in comparison. And there are a number of OEMs who would happily push updates but can't, because they can't get hardware packages from Qualcomm / Amlogic / Freescale / etc.

That, more than anything else, holds back new Android releases on lots of hardware.

Re:Android Oreo by Karunamon on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:26PM (#15067043)
Supposedly the carriers are real pains as well. I've heard horror stories of months-long approvals processes on Verizon and AT&T ROMs.

It's a game I wish they'd get out of entirely. There's no such thing as a useful carrier overlay.

Re:Android Oreo by AdmiralAsshat on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:34PM (#15067128)
> I've heard horror stories of months-long approvals processes on Verizon and AT&T ROMs.

Six months and counting, waiting for Verizon to approve the Nougat update on my HTC One M9. It has literally hit everyone else:

[0]http://www.androidpolice.com/2016/12/09/unlocked-htc-one-m9-...

[1]http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/02/23/android-7-0-nougat-o...

[2]http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/03/21/t-mobile-variant-htc...

[3]http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/04/12/htc-one-m9-sprint-ge...

[4]http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/05/16/atts-htc-one-m9-upda...

Re:Android Oreo by metalliqaz on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:39PM (#15067175)
Verizon is the Comcast of wireless. The next omen of the apocalypse will be when the Trump administration approves their merger.
Re:Android Oreo by seanp2k2 on Monday August 21, 2017 @10:42PM (#15069339)
Good thing their lawyer literally runs the FCC. They also have the best coverage, also like Comcast. Unlike Comcast, however, you don't have to get Verizon depending on where you live.
Re:Android Oreo by thanksgiving on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @03:40AM (#15070417)
Verizon wireless being evil is exactly why I stuck with T-Mobile for such a long time even as they keep making billing "mistakes" to the tune of about ten dollars every month for a while. (I believe they're just supremely incompetent but the errors somehow always are to their benefit.) With Verizon or Cingular, I assume it is just pure malice.

I've talked to people about how Verizon is trying to use its network as an advantage for advertising with supercookies and such on one end and Yahoo!/Aol on the other end but it seems to alarm nobody.

Re:Android Oreo by throwaway613834 on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @03:52AM (#15070457)
Can I ask what some examples of these "mistakes" are?

P.S. also, was Cingular a joke about AT&T? I think I missed what the joke is...

Re:Android Oreo by thanksgiving on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @05:42AM (#15070880)
Two in particular.

1. Cramming https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/12/t-mobile-gives-u...

2. They had a "free for life" 200MB? data plan for the Nexus 7 tablet kept billing me every month. It was a monthly ritual for about six months. Call, explain, get adjusted.

Re:Android Oreo by throwaway613834 on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @05:46AM (#15070895)
Huh, I see, thanks for mentioning this! I'll have to let people know to watch out...
Re:Android Oreo by Zee2 on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:39PM (#15067169)
Honestly, even after years of following Android, I still don't understand what the carriers even do to the ROMs. It's not like it needs special proprietary software tweaks just to connect to an ordinary GSM band. And it's also not like I get any kind of visual voicemail, WiFi calling, etc baked directly into the system either. Those carrier features are usually still separate apps, anyway.

Honestly, what are they doing, and why does it take them multiple months to do it?

Re:Android Oreo by klondike_ on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:46PM (#15067233)
Carriers generally have deals with other companies for preinstalled apps which may or may not still be active by the time it comes around for an update. Also they have to test the devices, but considering the sheer number of Android devices they probably prioritize new high end devices first.

This problem is made worse on Verizon and Sprint which use CDMA 3G networks, as opposed to the worldwide GSM standard.

Also this could be a result of marketing as well. You can get the latest Android on a new device, or you can wait an indeterminate amount of time (a few months to never) to get a free update on your old device.

Re:Android Oreo by josteink on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:29AM (#15069710)
> Also they have to test the devices

Why? The whole point of GSM is that carrier and phone can (and should) be entirely disconnected, decoupled and only connected through the means of whatever SIM the user puts in his phone.

The notion that a carrier needs to be involved in the making of a phone makes about as much sense as if my ISP needed to test and "approve" what Ethernet hardware I use at home.

It's frankly none of their business.

> This problem is made worse on Verizon and Sprint which use CDMA

So don't use them, just like you wouldn't use an ISP which doesn't speak IP.

Re:Android Oreo by int_19h on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @04:49AM (#15070666)
Pretty much any argument for network/device tie-in is fallacious on its face for the simple reason that there are many countries out there which don't have that arrangement. And yet the phones there work fine, and so do the networks.
Re:Android Oreo by mmcnl on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @10:38AM (#15072808)
It is none of their business, but they desperately want a piece of the pie so they brand their phones (and probably sell them at a small discount - this is the value proposition here). Branding also results in shifting responsibilities from OEM manufacturer to carrier with regard to testing and stuff.

Also, plenty ISPs actually do sell branded wireless routers with branded firmware, so it's not uncommon practice in other neighboring industries.

Re:Android Oreo by fabrice_d on Monday August 21, 2017 @04:04PM (#15067389)
This is about cost: updates sometimes fail (incredible, I know), and carriers are the first place people go to get their phones back in working order. This kind of support is quite costly so carriers don't push too hard for updates to happen.
Re:Android Oreo by ethbro on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:32PM (#15068317)
Every fifth security vulnerability in Android should cause the radio to spam reconnect attempts or similarly onorous behavior.

I imagine carrier responses would look a lot different then.

Re:Android Oreo by josteink on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:36AM (#15069743)
> carriers are the first place people go to get their phones back in working order

That only applies to phone bought from carriers.

Most people buy them in electronic shops where they buy tvs and laptops and stuff (since that allows you to get the best deal any carrier can offer, and not just be restricted to one).

Re:Android Oreo by csydas on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @06:17AM (#15071025)
This is half true and I think it falls neatly along generational lines, with exceptions for "really good deals". Most iPhone owners became first time AT&T customers when the iPhone came out. When Android hit the market, people went to their carrier because before this more or less was how you had to do it.

More people are just buying whatever phone and sticking a simcard in it but there is still a huge number who live by what their carrier gives them.

Re:Android Oreo by josteink on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @07:13AM (#15071286)
> More people are just buying whatever phone and sticking a simcard in it but there is still a huge number who live by what their carrier gives them.

Interestingly enough I see that as the wrong way around.

Going to a carrier specific-store is also guaranteed to offered me inferior choice both in phones and subscriptions. What's in it for me as a customer?

My electronic store is giving me the phone and carrier which provides me with the best deal. I have no reason to give a carrier, a transparent transport network, any sort of loyalty.

I don't have a "my carrier" which I care about. I do however have a "my phone", and I care about that deeply.

Re:Android Oreo by kevin_thibedeau on Monday August 21, 2017 @09:14PM (#15069016)
They want you renting a new phone from them every year. Dragging their feet on updates shifts sales to their newer lineup.
Re:Android Oreo by josteink on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:40AM (#15069763)
But if a carrier has the nerve to actually block updates to my phone and I find out, I'll switch my phone to another carrier the next day.

What's in it for them?

Re:Android Oreo by snoyberg on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @03:02AM (#15070317)
Most people don't think about such things when buying (renting) a new phone. If you do consider it, you're an exception to the rule.
Re:Android Oreo by josteink on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @04:22AM (#15070562)
What do you mean rent?

I buy my phone. It's mine. I can put it on any network I like.

Re:Android Oreo by Karunamon on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @10:36AM (#15081826)
You certainly can't put whatever software on it that you like. They go well out of their way to ensure that.
Re:Android Oreo by xorcist on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:26PM (#15068289)
Carriers are a red herring. The world at large couldn't care less about how the customers of AT&T can supposedly only install AT&T-approved firmware. Most people can, but they're not seeing any updates.

Google needs to fix their upgrade story. Even if the North American customers continued to run old vulnerable versions forever, updating everyone else's systems would be a tremendous improvement. (It would also make it difficult for the US carriers to continue those particular business shenanigans.)

Re:Android Oreo by rubyn00bie on Monday August 21, 2017 @08:16PM (#15068819)
Do you have any facts to back this up?

Prior to the iPhone changing how phones were sold-- carriers meddled with everything so they could get their hands in media playback, app sales, feature upgrades etc. I don't think much has changed in this where anyone gives them an inch (which is nearly everyone but Apple).

Note: I worked for T-Mobile for four years prior and a little after the originals iphone came out.

Re:Android Oreo by xorcist on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @05:17AM (#15070785)
Facts to backup what? That most mobile phone users are outside the US? Or that most of the world buys phones in home electronics stores, not from their carrier?

The iPhone brought a bit of the outside world to the US telco market. This was only a matter of time, as the market becomes more globalized there is increasing competition in the consumer market, and carrier bound phones are less flexible and more expensive in the long run. Everybody knows this.

(I believe that even the US broadband market sooner or later will transformed in much the same way. For a long time it looked like Google was about to do it, but with that seemingly stalled for the time being we might have to wait a few more years.)

It is not reasonable to describe the iPhone as changing how phones were sold outside of a select few countries. Therefore we should not accept that explanation as to why Android phones do not receieve updates either. Those markets are small on a global scale, especially for Android which clearly dominates the lower end of the market, which is predominantly deregulated.

Re:Android Oreo by digi_owl on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @07:09AM (#15071267)
Funny, i felt that the iPhone brought the US mobile market crapfest to the world. Especially when i watched Apple play favorites with what operator in my country, down to dictating the style of plans the iPhone could be combined with.
Re:Android Oreo by kalleboo on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:21AM (#15069675)
Where I lived it was common before the iPhone for people to go to electronics stores or carrier-agnostic "phone stores" to buy their phones. You could get an unmolested phone on subsidy/contract and everything. This was in Europe though, where cheap prepaid SIMs for young people and MVNOs were already very popular.
Re:Android Oreo by digi_owl on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @07:17AM (#15071297)
Indeed.

You would walk in, and find a wall of phones, alongside a list of carrier plans.

Then you could pretty much mix and match plan and phone to find some price you were comfortable with.

Come the iPhone's "worldwide" launch however Apple sat down and insisted that only one carrier would get the iPhone, and defined in detail the kinds of plans that said carrier could offer.

Re:Android Oreo by Tehnix on Monday August 21, 2017 @11:31PM (#15069501)
Before the iPhone, how prevalent were software updates to phones? I know of no one who ever got had an update.

There is absolutely no reason for carriers to need to do anything at all, else it would not make sense that I can change the SIM card out and voila I’m on a new carrier. The manufacturer is the one doing the testing, and the carrier simply provides the infrastructure.

I feel US perhaps has a different experience, because of their ridiculous CDMA infrastructure. Is it Verizon or what, where it’s not a SIM card but the phone itself that’s setup to a specific carrier?

Re:Android Oreo by pjmlp on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:45AM (#15069778)
Nokia had firmware updates, but only technically savy people would do them.

It was done via the desktop application to manage the phone.

However one would ususally only get bug fixes on the Series 30 and 40.

On Symbian towards the end of it, there were some OS updates still, but usually only once.

Re:Android Oreo by digi_owl on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @07:07AM (#15071257)
By the time iPhone hit, Nokia were doing over the air updating on their more recent models.

And Nokia was not alone, my Sony Ericsson C702 were capable of being getting new firmware OTA as well.

Keep in mind that this was back with the original iPhone that needed to be wired to a computer with iTunes installed.

Frankly the iPhone introduction feels more of a rollback than a upgrade from non-American point of view.

Re:Android Oreo by pjmlp on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @08:41AM (#15071758)
I only started using around Android 2.3 time frame, because I held to my trusty Symbian until it died on me, by then Nokia was already showing signs of not being sure what to do after Belle.

Belle already had lots of features that took Android and iPhone years to catch up with.

Re:Android Oreo by digi_owl on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @09:12AM (#15072003)
Nokia were sadly caught in a innovators dilemma.

they had Maemo, they had Symbian. But they were afraid that focusing on Maemo would lead to Symbian dying before they could get Maemo to the same level.

And then boardroom meddling was added, and they went much the same way as HP...

Re:Android Oreo by fpgeek on Monday August 21, 2017 @11:46PM (#15069551)
It's not just just Verizon. AT&T, in particular, has a habit of locking important features (VoLTE, Wi-Fi Calling) to phones running AT&T-branded and certified software. So unless the device you want is sold by AT&T and you get the AT&T-branded version, you're SoL. They even do IMEI blocking, so even if your device could otherwise work...
Re:Android Oreo by digi_owl on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @07:14AM (#15071290)
I have the impression that Nokia had trouble getting into the US market because they refused to let US carriers modify phone firmware to disable features.

In particular when Nokia tried to introduce SIP support.

Re:Android Oreo by ptx on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @02:38AM (#15070238)
Sony Ericsson's non-smart phones (e.g. K800) had OTA software updates. They would pop up a dialog from time to remind you to check for updates, then download them and update, all on the phone. (Carriers would often hold them back, though, if you had a carrier-customized model.)

I'm pretty sure I got an actual update at least once.

Re:Android Oreo by kalleboo on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:25AM (#15069688)
Near the end of the dumbphone era I remember getting an OTA update to mine that added a chat-style view to SMS text messaging. I don't think the iPhone would even get OTA updates for years, it was all purely through iTunes.
Re:Android Oreo by digi_owl on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @07:10AM (#15071278)
Bingo.

Both Nokia and Sony Ericsson were doing OTA firmware updates at that point, for "featurephones" no less.

iPhone didn't get that ability until iOS5, in 2011.

Re:Android Oreo by Nullabillity on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @10:26AM (#15081754)
My Nokia 5800 went through several UI redesigns via OTA updates.
Re:Android Oreo by maxsilver on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:29PM (#15067075)
True. That's a totally different problem that Treble isn't intended to address, as far as I'm aware.
Re:Android Oreo by ksk on Monday August 21, 2017 @03:57PM (#15067342)
Probably because they have to test the ROMs on their network in different regions, with different frequency bands, with roaming, etc. That work is tedious given all of the phones they support.
Re:Android Oreo by josteink on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:48AM (#15069797)
Do they do all this testing for all GSM phones in the world? All new and old? All GSM phones ever sold?

I guess not. I guess instead they rely on the GSM specification to allow seamless independence between the phone and the carrier for 99.999% of the phones out there (if not more).

So why do they need to "test" the remaining 0.001% when they have a update in user-facing functionality the carrier will never see or interoperate against?

No carrier in Europe does this.

Does your ISP control what OS updates you can download? No. And why should they?

That carriers needs to do testing is a lie perpetuated to allow for customer-hostile business-practices. Stop repeating it.

Re:Android Oreo by Mindwipe on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @06:18AM (#15071035)
Err... all carriers in Europe do this.

It happens with Apple OS updates too, Apple just have sufficient market clout to tell networks they must complete the testing in the week between the gold master release and the public release.

GSM isn't some magic specification. It's entirely possible for a crappy radio firmware to cause significant disruption to a network it connects to (indeed, I've seen a pre-release firmware from a mid-tier Android manufacturer that managed to cause a reboot in every cell tower it connected to from one of the UK's networks). That's an extreme example, but carriers frequently do testing on that basis, and it often holds up the European releases of Android software updates.

Re:Android Oreo by ksk on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @04:07PM (#15075927)
Resources are finite. I don't know what your point is? That they should simply give up and do nothing?

>That carriers needs to do testing is a lie perpetuated to allow for customer-hostile business-practices. Stop repeating it.

Other than your opinion, what evidence do you have that this is a lie?

Re:Android Oreo by josteink on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @12:35AM (#15078551)
All of Europe? Where GSM was invented?

This kind of bullshit only happens in the US where carriers are free to bullshit as they like due to absolutely lacking regulation.

In Europe we know better, we do better.

I'd rather say the burden of evidence is on the other side of the argument: prove to me why do you need to do testing as a carrier.

Re:Android Oreo by ksk on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @12:36PM (#15082916)
>I'd rather say the burden of evidence is on the other side of the argument: prove to me why do you need to do testing as a carrier.

And yet you make absurd claims without evidence yourself. So because you're confused as to the reason, that makes them a liar.. Nice.

Re:Android Oreo by ClassyJacket on Monday August 21, 2017 @08:08PM (#15068790)
The iPhone doesn't suffer from this problem. It should be up to the phone manufacturer (HTC, Samsung, etc.) to test their product.

The carrier can still, of course, test the new firmware all they like - they just shouldn't be able to interfere with its release.

Re:Android Oreo by danieldk on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @01:14AM (#15069892)
The iPhone doesn't suffer from this problem. It should be up to the phone manufacturer (HTC, Samsung, etc.) to test their product.

Moreover, in some European countries it is normal to buy a phone and a subscription separately. In some countries bundling is even illegal. I have never had a carrier-branded phone since I switched to smartphones, including my Android excursion (Nexus 4, Moto X 2013, Moto G, Moto X 2014) and some Windows Phones that I played with (Lumia 710/920/640). They all worked on multiple carriers.

Everyone should stop perpetuating the carrier testing myth. For this we have the GSM standards and in many parts of the world a large number of phones are not carrier-branded.

Re:Android Oreo by kalleboo on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @12:19AM (#15069658)
TBF, Apple did release one update that caused issues with the radio on the Verizon network[0]. Carrier testing should have caught that.

[0] https://www.theverge.com/2016/10/17/13306776/apple-iphone-7-...

Re:Android Oreo by ksk on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @04:02PM (#15075883)
Apple makes products available to carriers pre-launch for testing IIRC. I don't think they skip the line.
Re:Android Oreo by Mindwipe on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @05:08AM (#15079791)
They certainly have the market power to skip the line, but they still go in the line, unlike some suggestions here.
Re:Android Oreo by tinus_hn on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:07PM (#15068208)
Good thing they don't have to test these iPhones!
Re:Android Oreo by ksk on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @04:01PM (#15075870)
They do. Apple makes them available to carriers pre-launch IIRC.
Re:Android Oreo by tinus_hn on Thursday August 24, 2017 @03:10PM (#15093058)
Probably, but they won't delay the launch for months if the carriers drag their feet
Re:Android Oreo by IshKebab on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @04:31AM (#15070607)
The carriers are not the problem. They may be an additional problem but even when they aren't involved (i.e. outside America) Android updates still suck.