News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by pgodzin on Saturday August 19, 2017 @08:39PM (#15056366)
Any insight on why his failures innovating at GE that caused him to resign aren't a red flag for an innovative company like Uber? Just because they're looking for a grown up?
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:06PM (#15056453)
Because they desperately need a grown up. Uber doesn't need to be innovative, it needs to execute without continuing to shooting off it's toes.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by revelation on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:37PM (#15056547)
What exactly does it need to execute on? It's valued at $60B and is losing money with every. single. fricking. ride.

It doesn't need someone to "execute" some sort of plan, it needs a miracle only innovation can provide.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:53PM (#15056595)
It needs to re-focus on it's core ride-sharing business and substantially reduce it's burn rate. There is little doubt that ride-sharing will be a massively profitable business, they get paid dollars per ride and their booking costs should only be pennies.

The myth that their rides are unprofitable is because they spend money like drunken sailors in a whorehouse. Anyone analyzing their financials has no insight into whether ride sharing is profitable in the US, or other countries because the needed information is not broken out in those reports

They have up to 100 side businesses like UberEats. They've spent a ton trying to design autonomous vehicles they don't need now and likely never will need (given they'll be freely available for purchase from Tesla, GM, etc when created). Lastly, they spend huge amounts opening new markets, basically paying drivers to sign up with such lucrative bonuses that Uber gets scammed constantly by them.

The plan is pretty simple 1) Kill almost every side business, and do a substantial headcount reduction. 2) Dump the autonomous driving development group and cheaply settle the Waymo lawsuit. 3) Focus everyone left on ride-sharing, improving the brand, and efficiently expanding internationally. 4) Clean house in the HR department and of every remaining harasser. 5) Raise another round to ensure Uber's long term financial stability.

Thats a plan that gives Uber a very long runway to achieve full profitability, even without an IPO.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by ImSkeptical on Sunday August 20, 2017 @12:47AM (#15056989)
If Uber just focuses on ride-sharing, without innovation, it's unclear to me how they could survive.

They seem to scale in reverse. That is, an Uber that runs in the US and the UK will cost more to operate than an Uber that runs in just the US. An Uber that runs in one state will cost less than an Uber that runs in a whole country, and so on. The more diverse an area you serve, the more legislation and markets you have to deal with, more hours you'll have high customer support load, and the less well you will be able to analyze and react to trends in individual markets.

What stops me, then, in an era where Uber isn't fueled by investor money every trip, from being a competitor with Uber? Raise a few million dollars, get a simple app together with a few friends, and then convince drivers to try (take a lot of short Uber rides and pitch good drivers) and riders to ride. I'd have less staff, less overhead, and therefore less costs. The savings could be passed on equally to the drivers and riders. I could give discounts on nights when there was a big game, I could advertise in local areas, I could poach good drivers from Uber, etc.

It seems to me there is no way for Uber to be competitive if they aren't using investor to subsidize the price of rides. There is nothing, that I am aware of, that is impossible or expensive to replicate in their tech.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Sunday August 20, 2017 @01:53PM (#15059400)
I don't think you understand their business. The code that supports the US market also supports the UK market, it needs changes for currency/regulations, but it's not being entirely rewritten. Providing the booking service for a ride can't cost more than a few cents, and they get paid a few dollars.

And Uber has hundreds of competitors, and it's crushing all of them because of brand. I have Uber on my phone. I will never have your app. Getting app installs is hugely expensive and they have a huge lead. Even if you pay for installs, people will delete your app as soon as they realize you don't have as many drivers.

They have a huge lead in a big market. They need to not lose that.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by ImSkeptical on Sunday August 20, 2017 @08:58PM (#15061172)
When I say that they need more people, I mean that they need customer service that can handle the new market, legal people for the new laws, finance people for the taxes, etc. I'm aware they can largely reuse the code that underlies their service.

People do switch their ride solution. For example, I used to use taxis when I needed to hire a ride. I switched to uber because it was easier and cheaper. If something was as easy and cheaper, I'd use that instead (For example, I use lyft whenever it has a better price and I have the time to check).

Building a competitor for a single city seems plausible. I don't think there is a technology related hurdle. All you need is the capital to build the brand and to be competitive on price.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by joejerryronnie on Sunday August 20, 2017 @10:19AM (#15058483)
I wonder if Uber should explore some type of franchise model. I don't think I've seen anything like this in tech but it would allow them to offload some of the local costs/complexities to a presumably more locally dialed in franchisee, while maintaining a focus on their core tech & brand marketing. Despite the spate of HR/PR disasters, the Uber brand is still extremely strong.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by yeukhon on Sunday August 20, 2017 @02:34AM (#15057232)
I think we need to make peace with the word innovation sometimes. Innovation should be realistic in the right timing. Surely autonomous car is a really interesting future, but Uber has plenty of organizational problems require urgent and decisive surgery.

Abandon the auto project and UberEats (I don't even know if UberEats is even profitable or how many people actually use it) will allow the company to focus on core problems. How can you clean your house if your kids constantly go around the house making a mess? Let's get the house cleaned first then we worry about how to correct the kids' behaviors. Basically, do one thing well enough before moving to another.

They really need to focus on growing in cities and countries where they face competitions but already have a strong root. I understand the awesomeness to be the bigges, but look at Uber China, Uber had to parnter with Di Di instead (Uber doesn't run its business in mainland China anymore). Uber also recently shut down its business in Marcu because the drivers were fined so much no one would work for Uber.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by xyzzy_plugh on Sunday August 20, 2017 @04:36AM (#15057533)
For what it's worth, my understanding is that Uber eats is more profitable than the core ride-sharing business.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Sunday August 20, 2017 @01:49PM (#15059387)
You must mean less unprofitable.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by codeisawesome on Sunday August 20, 2017 @06:36AM (#15057842)
Not really disagreeing with the rest of this comment, but a couple of points:

> given they'll be freely available for purchase from Tesla, GM, etc when created

Tesla has a built-in "feature" in their cars, to make OTA updates to the software running the car. One part of the vision of buying a Tesla, is supposed to be the day when customers let their autonomous car "work" for them while they are not using it.

I don't think it's a huge stretch of imagination for Tesla to come out with it's own version of the ride sharing parts of Uber when autonomous driving becomes a full reality with their cars. They could eat Uber at this point.

> Thats a plan that gives Uber a very long runway to achieve full profitability, even without an IPO.

Points 3, 4 & 5 of the plan are likely going to be very difficult! Why?

> 3) Focus everyone left on ride-sharing, improving the brand, and efficiently expanding internationally.

I'm fairly certain there are very smart, well-paid people already trying to do each of things at Uber, not sure how reducing headcount will magically improve the state of affairs here. Mythical man month like arguments come to mind.

> 4) Clean house in the HR department and of every remaining harasser.

If the company was built on a foundation of sexist and abrasive culture, rooting every one out will take a long time, not to mention disruptive as it involves disentangling the fiefdoms built by these people (who may even be doing a "good job", causing damage to raw business metrics in removing them). I'm not saying this shouldn't be done, I'm just saying "birds of a feather flock together", so if I may dare say, wholesale pest removal might unfortunately be low on the priority of any new exec. They would be more focussed on other matters and just treat the symptoms. Human nature.

> 5) Raise another round to ensure Uber's long term financial stability.

If Points 1 & 2 are followed, without the silver-talk of "constant innovation" and projections of "taking over global transportation with our technology" - raising private funds might get extremely challenging and may not have the expected results. At that point, an IPO might provide better success as public investors are interested in "business that execute" as well, as opposed to the private investment folks who look for returns in the Order(s) of Magnitude scale.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Sunday August 20, 2017 @02:01PM (#15059456)
Let me address your points

1) It's possible Tesla could enter the ride-sharing market. And it's possible they could win. But I won't download a Tesla app until their service is as good a Ubers, and that's a huge barrier to overcome.

Uber's advantage is their massive lead in installed apps and available drivers. If they lose that, then they'll be at risk. Some autonomous company may pull it off, but the far more likely route is that Uber adds autonomous fast enough that none can catch them.

3) I'm not arguing to add headcount to ride-share, I'm arguing to add focus to it. Having a CEO 100% focused on ride-share instead of CEO 50% focused on ride-share and 50% focused on autonomous/uberEats/100 other side hustles will trickled down through exec staff, directors, etc.

4) Starting over in HR is your first start. You can't have a culture where people were allowed to hide problems or protect bad employees. It starts in HR.

5) An IPO is fine. It's all about financing the business over the long term, so the new CEO will pick the best possible financing path. And reducing burn rate might be enough alone to do it, since Uber should still have billions left in the bank.

Let's be fair, the $60B valuation was really dumb and won't be seen again for a long time if ever. You can't count on having investors as dumb as the Saudi's again.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by tedmiston on Sunday August 20, 2017 @09:59PM (#15061404)
I hope they don't do all of this. UberEATS is best in class. Seriously an order of magnitude better experience than all of the other food delivery apps.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by jnwatson on Saturday August 19, 2017 @11:03PM (#15056800)
Well put. I hope the new CEO reads this.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by origami777 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:55PM (#15056602)
How do you know it looses money on every ride (genuine question)? Is there proof?

Could it be that there are profitable rides in some of its markets that inspire investors that it would eventually be able to make every ride profitable at some point?

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by slouch on Saturday August 19, 2017 @11:00PM (#15056793)
> Uber passengers were paying only 41% of the actual cost of their trips https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-delive...
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Saturday August 19, 2017 @11:40PM (#15056874)
That analysis is speculative at best. It ignores all of the costs that aren't part of providing Uber ride-sharing, including a large number of side businesses, and it's massive investment in international growth. The financials simply don't provide detail to break down the actual costs of ride-sharing when it's mixed in with so many incidental operations and costs.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by Spooky23 on Sunday August 20, 2017 @12:59AM (#15057015)
Sure it does. Uber is like Dropbox for cars. WTF are they doing?

If you fired 75% of the people, and focused on selling rides and selling cars to drivers, the company would probably coast and make money for years.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by QAPereo on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:50PM (#15056586)
What it needs is a time machine to bring the necessary automotive tech back from 2050.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by tootie on Saturday August 19, 2017 @08:49PM (#15056394)
Uber is an international brand for taxis. I'm not even sure why they are considered a tech company.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by Lazare on Saturday August 19, 2017 @11:05PM (#15056808)
It's a mystery. They do have a nice app for hailing their taxis, but so does my local "legacy" taxi company.

Similarly: Why is Blue Apron a tech company? Their business model is putting food in a box, and then shipping it to people. That's great, but my local grocery chain does that too?

And then there's Juicero, who's only claim to being a tech company seems to be they printed QR codes on the packaging, despite the QR codes being entirely unnecessary to their core business. If Kraft puts a QR code on a box of mac and cheese so you can scan it and get a cooking instruction video on your phone, do they become a tech company too?

It's just branding.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by fma on Saturday August 19, 2017 @11:18PM (#15056835)
My guess is that it's "cool" to be a tech company. It gives an excuse to not be profitable. Get wider range of talent.

My current and my previous company is a traditional business, both more than 20 years old. They sell a product or service that has existed for decades. But damn they both tried to say we are a startup, we are a tech company, etc etc.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by tedmiston on Sunday August 20, 2017 @10:07PM (#15061431)
After the slashed IPO pricing and the continued downward trend since, besides the fact that Blue Apron's unit economics are dubious, the market has been crystal clear that they don't value Blue Apron as a tech company.

https://hackernoon.com/blue-apron-is-not-a-tech-company-neit...

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by svdsojfjkss on Sunday August 20, 2017 @01:31AM (#15057084)
I see you've read Matt Levine's newsletter:

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-08-09/yogurt-li...

They're virtual-reality companies.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by moxious on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:38PM (#15056551)
This always blew my mind: a smartphone app for a cab company that doesn't even own any cabs raised $16 billion.

It simply can't be that they spent even a small fraction of that writing software, smartphone apps just aren't that expensive. But they've got one helluva marketing engine and investor relations group...

That, and a lot of their money is buying market share, effectively subsidizing people's rides.

I've never understood how that's going to work, beyond vague handwavey arguments about potential future driverless cabs and other complex arguments that don't seem backed by data.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by origami777 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:42PM (#15056564)
I think the lesson here is that kickstarting new markets (entering new countries) is not easy. They basically have a local or regional team that needs to find a way to drive user adoption. They also spend a lot of money on promotions to change user and driver behavior.

IMO it doesn't do them just when we say "it's just an app". It's a complex operation that they've simplified to appear as that way.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by moxious on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:47PM (#15056576)
It's fine to spend money driving a new market but you eventually have to capitalize on it. How will that work? Large price increases, or just betting that driverless tech will eliminate costs and get them to profitability?

Also, they already have substantial scale. When would one reasonably expect them to stop losing so much money?

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by fstuff on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:57PM (#15056609)
Just take a look at Didi. They won the market in China and now prices are up, driven incentive pay is cut, wait times are up because drivers are leaving the platform because pay is down.

https://www.google.com/amp/amp.timeinc.net/fortune/2016/09/1...

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Saturday August 19, 2017 @10:00PM (#15056618)
When they stop expanding worldwide. The world is an extremely large place. Paying drivers hundreds of dollars to sign up with Uber in hundreds of countries is a massive startup expense.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by origami777 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @10:29PM (#15056721)
I agree with you. I was simply trying to address the comment that it's "just an app".
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by tootie on Sunday August 20, 2017 @09:39AM (#15058364)
Well, it's clearly a very successful business. But to your point, their success if their ability to break into new markets. Striking a deal with the Taxi and Limousine Commission in NYC was probably their single most valuable innovation and it was lawyers, not programmers who pulled it off.
Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by OzzyB on Saturday August 19, 2017 @08:46PM (#15056384)
Hush now the money men are in charge, it's time for grown ups to run things.

Like that Pepsi guy that ran Apple (into the ground).

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by valuearb on Saturday August 19, 2017 @09:18PM (#15056489)
The parallels are actually pretty interesting.

You can argue that Sculley saved Apple. At the time Jobs was a terrible leader and manager, and he had way over-forecast Macintosh sales. And because of it, Apple was hemorrhaging. After booting Jobs, Sculley cut head-count, refocused Apple on it's bread and butter product, the Apple II and led Apple to a massive turnaround. Sculley did so well he lasted 10 years as CEO.

Uber is a company that was a great idea, got off to a great start, but then management started to constantly sabotage themselves. Travis has acted as irrationally as Jobs 1.0 did. Bringing in a Sculley type is exactly the type of leader they need now. Clean out all the dumb side business ideas, refocus on the car sharing service, and work hard to rebuild it's brand.

Ten years from now they might need someone more creative (and Immelt is so old there is no way he's going to run it for that long). But right now they need to survive and get back on track.

Re:Former GE CEO Jeff Immelt Close to Becoming Uber’s CEO by pocketsquare2 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @08:59PM (#15056425)
John Sculley.

"Jeff [Immelt], do you want to sell planned-obsolescence dryers and weather derivatives the rest of your life?"