News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by jjgreen on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:49AM (#15008231)
I would normally sigh and move on seeing such a claim, but this guy is an established senior researcher at the University of Bonn. A career-ending disaster or instant and eternal fame, that's some serious cahunas.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by WhitneyLand on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:29PM (#15011923)
It shouldn't be career ending unless there's been malfeasance or some kind of sloppy work. The people who go down hard usually have some crime beyond audacity.

It could easily cause some painful embarrassment, but hopefully that would pass with time.

Maybe embarrassment similar to that faced by researchers who's results suggested FTL communication, but it turned out to be a bad fiber-optic cable. I didn't follow up but I assume that team is doing OK.

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by nieve on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:16PM (#15012989)
I wouldn't be surprised if they gained a bit of respect. If I recall correctly they did everything right - they had an apparently impossible result, they spent a lot of time trying to disprove it, and when they announced they made it clear that they doubted the result. Hiding it because they were sure it was false, but couldn't disprove would have been poor science. It had to be pretty scary to make that announcement knowing there was almost no chance it wasn't going to turn out to be a problem in their setup and I admire the guts it took to do it.

Sometimes the courage of your convictions means trusting the process to get it right when you're sure you're wrong.

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by kevinnk on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:21PM (#15014584)
Actually, there was a bunch of blow back and the main researchers behind the result stepped down.

https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn21656-leaders-of-cont...

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by sulam on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @10:17AM (#15018360)
Reading that, it seems more like they went back to doing research full time instead of being part time administrators -- and probably happier for it.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by davesque on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:26PM (#15014317)
Agreed. Even in the event of the discovery of work which would qualify as minimally sloppy, I'd think his reputation (if not wanting of some polish) would still be intact after a quick retraction.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by Blaisorblade0 on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @12:45PM (#15028969)
I mostly agree but there is a small effect: "Claims spectacular proofs with flawed arguments" might still be reason to doubt his future proofs more until verified. And mathematicians do use such criterions before reading unverified claimed proofs of hundreds of pages (not uncommon). And since some proofs target tens or hundreds of persons, that can be a problem. I've read such stories, though I don't have a reference at hand.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by jordigh on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:25PM (#15011894)
> serious cahunas

I think you mean "cojones" (which btw is a very rude word in Spanish). A kahuna is a kind of Hawai'ian shaman.

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by jjgreen on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:48PM (#15013719)
I stand corrected, thank you. I would normally have said "serious bollocks", but this forum is mostly left-ponders who would probably not have caught my drift.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by liberte82 on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:08PM (#15013847)
North American here, we hear enough Brits speak to get the expression :)
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by Myrmornis on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @05:00AM (#15016552)
"serious bollocks" means "very questionable statement" in the British English I'm familiar with. Perhaps GP's idiom is from elsewhere. If the reference is to bravery/daring one would use "balls" as in US English, I believe.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by IronSean on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @10:05AM (#15018250)
"Bollocks" in Britain and "Balls" in North America both refer to the Testes, as does "cojones". So all three statements are actually the exact same slang in regional dialects.

Bollocks, like many slang words, have multiple meanings in different contexts. It can be used as you stated as well, but "What you said is bollocks" and "You have bollocks for saying it" are very different statements.

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by duncan_bayne on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:56PM (#15013361)
I'm sitting here chuckling to myself about the "why not both?" possibilities.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by zimpenfish on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @04:08AM (#15016349)
It's a common mistake - http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003526.h... - and you could imagine a big kahuna would have to have serious cojones.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by js8 on Monday August 14, 2017 @12:32PM (#15009977)
> A career-ending disaster

Why? Why should posting a stab at a complicated problem should be considered career-killing?

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by adrianmonk on Monday August 14, 2017 @02:20PM (#15011067)
Some people will hold it against him because some people are too stupid to see things in context. Rather than respecting him for taking a smart risk in pursuit of an important goal, they will just remember that he was once wrong about something and in a big way.

There are people who point at others' failures to bolster their own image by comparison. And there are people with fragile egos who are eager to see others in a negative way.

It shouldn't be that way, but it sometimes is, so I wouldn't say the career risk is zero. But I'm still glad he's doing it regardless of the outcome.

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by acchow on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:30PM (#15013125)
Is this really how the academic community is?
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by __jal on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:48PM (#15013308)
That's really how humanity is.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by demonshalo on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @01:59AM (#15015881)
Goes to show that even the even the so called "experts" are humans after all.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by dfabulich on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:21PM (#15011839)
It's career "damaging" (I wouldn't say killing) because so many crackpots have attempted this problem that making a wrong attempt makes you look a bit like a crackpot.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by shurcooL on Monday August 14, 2017 @01:48PM (#15010729)
I think he means if the stab is not serious but a troll. Of course, if it's a genuine and serious attempt, I don't think it should be frowned upon at all.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by ianai on Monday August 14, 2017 @12:53PM (#15010220)
Seriously, best way to ensure people stop trying is to persecute attempts.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by openloop on Monday August 14, 2017 @01:38PM (#15010635)
What he said.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by zitterbewegung on Monday August 14, 2017 @12:50PM (#15010183)
I don't think thats true. See Vinay Deolalikar.

https://en.wikinews.org/wiki/Researcher_claims_solution_to_P...

https://arxiv.org/find/all/1/all:+AND+Vinay+Deolalikar/0/1/0...

He is still publishing papers. Seems to be doing fine.

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by lisper on Monday August 14, 2017 @02:48PM (#15011371)
There's a third possibility: there's a flaw in the proof, but one that is hard to find, and the discovery of the flaw actually advances the field in interesting ways.

If I were a betting man that's actually where I'd put my money because the paper passes by bogometer test (but I am nowhere near qualified to assess whether it's actually correct).

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by liberte82 on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:10PM (#15013861)
Wasn't that the first possibility?
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by mmarx on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:25PM (#15012523)
> A career-ending disaster

He is a tenured professor in Germany, there is very little that could end his career (essentially refusing to honour his teaching obligations or being convicted of a felony). At worst, this will be immensely embarrassing, but you can't kick professors out just because they make a fool of themselves.

Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by StavrosK on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:51PM (#15013738)
And professors don't just make a fool of themselves because one of their papers had a flaw in it.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by wolfgke on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @08:04AM (#15017381)
You have no idea...
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by Radle on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @05:14AM (#15016610)
If you think this is career ending you probably have no idea on how hiring and promoting decisions are made in German universities.
Re:A Solution of the P versus NP Problem? by kurtisc on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @09:23AM (#15017941)
Please can you enlighten me?