News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by WalterBright on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:11PM (#14981109)
In the 80's IBM was an unstoppable juggernaut. In the 90's it was Microsoft. Then Apple. Now Google/Amazon.

Conventional wisdom is that, in a free market, a single corporation will grow to rule everything. But that never seems to pan out.

Part of the reason is that the larger an organization gets, the more inefficient and bureaucratic it gets, the less it is able to adapt. See "The Innovator's Dilemma", a book everyone interested in business should read.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by notfromhere on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:28PM (#14981979)
The main reason is that corporations run like command economies internally, and have to compete(ish) in a market externally. So resource allocation in a corporation is a bureaucratic, political task. This is why big companies notoriously suck at everything after a while, since internal management just starts pillaging business divisions for resources and pet projects
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by programmarchy on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:05PM (#14986101)
Large firm sizes are encouraged by state protections like patent law, regulatory capture, and other monopolistic advantages granted by anti free market practices.

The economic calculation problem, described my Mises in his criticism of centrally planned state economies, starts rearing its head in large firms as well [1], leading to the inefficiencies you mentioned.

[1] https://fee.org/articles/economic-calculation-in-the-corpora...

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by aphextron on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:51PM (#14981616)
Oddly enough Microsoft is the only company I can see bucking this trend right now. The other big guys youve mentioned have essentially slumped down into their respective markets and drawn up battle lines, whereas MS really seems to be pushing into new territory. I wouldnt be surprised to see them come back into mobile with a Surface phone that gives Apple a run for their money.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by slackingoff2017 on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:00PM (#14981707)
I think people don't give leadership the value it deserves. Baller made MS what it was, and Satya is largely responsible for turning the ship around.

I've concluded that the leadership of IBM is what blows, and the C level offices should be gutted and replaced with whatever good engineers remain.

I've seen leadership make or break every organization I've been a part of

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by gchokov on Friday August 11, 2017 @02:26AM (#14987093)
Satya is largely responsible indeed, but he is just executing on the foundations laid out before him. The foundations were shaky, but they were still the right ones. I think too much credit is given to Satya. Maybe people just wanted to see someone better than the previous CEO.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by pwthornton on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:05PM (#14981768)
Windows Phone, once they got over to the Metro UI, was quite good. I would say from a design, UI and system perspective, it was significantly superior to Android and within striking distance of Apple and iOS.

The issue with MS isn't whether or not they can build a quality mobile OS (they can), but rather it's whether or not MS can build an ecosystem with enough buy-in from companies to build apps and services.

I'm sad to see MS do so poorly with their mobile OS, considering how good it is.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by yourapostasy on Thursday August 10, 2017 @10:32PM (#14986183)
> ...it's whether or not MS can build an ecosystem with enough buy-in from companies to build apps and services.

I think there might be a titanic fight shaping up in the economy to build out and secure ecosystems in a more Net-centric future. The WalMart diktats to truckers to not drive Amazon loads are just opening salvos in this war, for example.

I see healthy, vibrant ecosystems with a bidirectional value exchange as a way for very large companies to mitigate much of the damage inflicted by their own size. Unfortunately, most large companies are trying their damnedest to build out ecosystems as command and control bot networks, and see it only as a profit source to unidirectionally squeeze. That's tempting because it's so easy, but it means your command and control decisions must be better and more timely than the ecosystem's wisdom of crowds, or you'll suffer the consequences.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by wvenable on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:47PM (#14982211)
The way I see it, MS had a great product for the corporate/business market and could have put a nail in the coffin of Blackberry a few years sooner.

But instead they wanted a piece of the consumer app market so badly that they rebooted their platform 3-4 times chasing an impossible dream.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by pwthornton on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:30PM (#14982684)
The thing is there really isn't a corporate/business market anymore. The company I worked for stopped buying corporate phones and plans and just gives us money every month to put to a BYOD solution. We just need to use a phone with certain security requirements. We also have started procuring software and services to fit into this world.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by wvenable on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:01PM (#14982965)
We still have people buying Blackberries on their own. There are plenty of people who want a phone that's good for work.

A phone that works great with corporate networks, allows for editing Word and Excel documents, could have gone very far a few years ago. Even getting corporate app developers to port their apps to Windows phone would have been easier than chasing Zynga down.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by chucksmash on Friday August 11, 2017 @01:07PM (#14992006)
> We still have people buying Blackberries on their own. There are plenty of people who want a phone that's good for work.

This article[1] seems to run counter to your intuition:

> In the fourth quarter of 2016, more than 432 million smartphones were sold, according to a report published on Wednesday by the research firm Gartner. Of those, just 207,900 were BlackBerry devices running its own operating system.

> That gives the Canadian smartphone company a share of the overall phone market of less than a single percentage point. To be precise, it's 0.0481%.

> Even when you include BlackBerry's devices running Android, its numbers are still incredibly low. Last year, CEO John Chen said the company sold only about 400,000 devices in the second quarter.

Blackberry's market share is much nearer my own (i.e. 0 phones manufactured or sold) than it is Apple's or Google's.

[1]: http://www.businessinsider.com/blackberry-smartphone-markets...

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by WalterBright on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:12PM (#14981838)
I used to have a piece of paper with the top 10 US companies by market cap, decade by decade. You didn't have to go very far back in time to find companies you don't recognize :-)
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by dredmorbius on Friday August 11, 2017 @01:17AM (#14986743)
Tenancy on that list has dropped tremendously.

The list of Dow components is a particularly compelling study. It firms up in the 1920s and 1930s, and is relatively stable through the 1950s, then starts turning over at an accelerating pace.

See also Deloitte's "Shift Index". A Forbes writer has covered this for years. A long-term secular decline dating to the mid-1960s. Measuring return on invested capital.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by gaius on Thursday August 10, 2017 @03:48PM (#14983433)
Oddly enough Microsoft is the only company I can see bucking this trend right now.

I'll second that - both Azure and Surface are best-in-class.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by tomrod on Friday August 11, 2017 @12:12AM (#14986527)
Eh, Azure is not that great. It's okay.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by MandieD on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:02AM (#14987540)
Azure is an absolute joy to use and administer compared to IBM Bluemix.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by antod on Friday August 11, 2017 @07:22AM (#14988477)
>> Eh, Azure is not that great. It's okay.

> Azure is an absolute joy to use and administer compared to IBM Bluemix.

Note to other readers: although slightly tangential, these two comments do not actually disagree or contradict each other.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by tomrod on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:02PM (#14998395)
I have no doubt.

I spent some time recently diving into Azure ML Studio. It's a rough product still, with a lot of opportunity for optimizations/better UX.

I reckon the administration is much nicer, and probably closer to the designers/architects' UX understanding.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by jtmcmc on Saturday August 12, 2017 @09:49AM (#14997875)
very low bar there...
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by Angostura on Friday August 11, 2017 @01:52AM (#14986913)
Surface has just been turned into a meaningless marketing term, like Watson. See the Surface laptop as an example.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by baursak on Thursday August 10, 2017 @01:53PM (#14982277)
With existence of antitrust laws, or government regulations in general, it's not really a free market. Both IBM and Microsoft were hit with antitrust issues. Standard Oil or even AT&T are some examples that come to mind. I bet there are countless other examples where consolidation was either prohibited by regulators, or not even attempted in the first place due to antitrust issues.

E.g.:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_IBM#1969:_Antitrust...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCR_Corporation#Expansion

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by WalterBright on Thursday August 10, 2017 @02:17PM (#14982533)
Standard Oil steadily lost market share throughout the years of the anti-trust trial, long before there was a verdict.

See "Titan" by Chernow.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by forapurpose on Friday August 11, 2017 @12:42AM (#14986625)
> Conventional wisdom is that, in a free market, a single corporation will grow to rule everything. But that never seems to pan out.

The extreme scenario doesn't pan out - we don't end up with one eternal corporation that owns all capital. But certainly it pans out in a more realistic scale of size and time; there are and have been plenty of monopolies in many industries, and the overwhelming power and influence of large corporations, and the damage that power and influence does, is well documented.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by duncan_bayne on Friday August 11, 2017 @04:53AM (#14987782)
That's only conventional wisdom amongst people opposed to laissez faire capitalism. It is not an opinion held, for example, by the Austrian School.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by PhasmaFelis on Thursday August 10, 2017 @09:15PM (#14985881)
> *Part of the reason is that the larger an organization gets, the more inefficient and bureaucratic it gets, the less it is able to adapt."

Which is a symptom of publicly traded companies, right? It creates this weird system where finding a niche and serving it reliably year in and year out is considered failure; you're only succeeding if you're constantly growing, which means you inevitably collapse under your own weight.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by ethbro on Thursday August 10, 2017 @12:28PM (#14981315)
+Baidu/Alibaba
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by pducks32 on Friday August 11, 2017 @03:51AM (#14987493)
I’ve never used either in my life and have spent a ton of time in Africa, the US, Ireland, and England. 3 continents.
Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by paganel on Friday August 11, 2017 @09:52AM (#14989631)
>3 continents.

Just today I had a 10-minute chat with one of my colleagues from marketing about AliExpress. I live and work in Eastern Europe, and almost all the people who do online sales rely on a Chinese company like AliExpress. Some of those people were using the UK as their source of buying merchandise until a couple of years ago, not anymore, it's all China now. The US (and the UK&Ireland) are losing big on this because Amazon's stock-price is blinding them. IMHO Amazon is going to hit a wall in terms of online sales sooner rather than later and the only thing that will be left to save them will be AWS.

Re:A rising sentiment that IBM’s Watson can’t deliver on its... by solotronics on Sunday August 13, 2017 @11:49PM (#15006481)
if you work or visit China you basically must use WeChat, Alipay, and Baidu. the great firewall blocks the competition and everyone in China uses the homegrown equivalents.