News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by ryandvm on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @07:32AM (#14956680)
The moral of the story is something most adults figure out by their mid 20s: if you like your job, keep your mouth shut about your political/religious beliefs.

And despite what any employer will tell you about their workplace being an open forum, they are full of shit. What they mean is, it's an open forum to agree with management.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by tedmiston on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @09:43AM (#14957709)
> At the same time, there are co-workers who are questioning whether they can safely express their views in the workplace (especially those with a minority viewpoint).

Minority viewpoints in tech become silenced and their author(s) ostracized by the biases of a mob mentality. It doesn't even matter what you write because most people won't even read the original source, instead floating by on derivative tweets and extremely biased summaries (in whatever direction agrees with their existing views).

Irrespective of the original memo, and this is something I've felt more strongly in the past couple years, it's just not safe to share dissenting viewpoints in tech anymore.

We used to be the industry where anything could be discussed critically and the most objectively correct answer could win (logic! science!). Nowadays it's so political and heated, I've found it best to just stay out of the discussion and not share dissenting views anymore. I think the real problem we need to fix is being able to have rational critical discussion around topics we disagree with.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by uncletaco on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:45AM (#14958269)
> Irrespective of the original memo, and this is something I've felt more strongly in the past couple years, it's just not safe to share dissenting viewpoints in tech anymore.

It is not safe to share your viewpoints anywhere where it is not considered germane: and the workplace is high on that list. A firm will fire someone who becomes annoyingly political or who makes a public ass out of themselves on social media. I work for a medium sized tech firm in the American South and we had one engineer that was very open and sometimes combative about her progressive viewpoints and people stopped wanting to talk to her, even those who agreed with her. She didn't last a quarter.

Expecting firms to give their employees a forum to speak openly about anything not work related is a recent phenomenon across the board, and many still hold onto the view that if you want to engage in political discussions then do so outside of the workplace.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by Caveman_Coder on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:24PM (#14964376)
> Expecting firms to give their employees a forum to speak openly about anything not work related is a recent phenomenon across the board, and many still hold onto the view that if you want to engage in political discussions then do so outside of the workplace.

But Google does this (Memegen and eng-misc), the problem is that you're only able to speak about certain things and entertain certain opinions...so naturally, conservatives will feel muzzled and want to not go against the dominant culture/power structures

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by beaconstudios on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @01:13PM (#14959976)
part of the problem is that the organisations themselves have become extremely political. Google is known to be a very left-leaning company and I can imagine that working inside such a political organisation, especially one that talks a big talk about being logic and reason-driven, would cause one to want to express their views.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by uncletaco on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:15PM (#14963435)
> organisations themselves have become extremely political

This is not true if only for the fact that organizations have always engaged in politics. In one of the worst cases, the United Fruit Company lobbied the US President to overthrow the elected government of Guatemala. In one of the most benign cases, Subaru sponsored gay pride events and publicly supported LGBT groups in the 1990s.

Besides that, everything else you've said is useless hyperbole. Get your history together before you go spouting nonsense.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by beaconstudios on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @06:22PM (#14963488)
organisations have always been political, but the current political environment inside tech is at what I would consider to be an extremely high point. Politics right now are extremely divisive (I think much more so than say 10 years ago) and many tech companies have openly picked a side. Yes I am familiar with the UFC, and have read about their involvement in various Caribbean nations and the whole "banana republic" concept.

> Besides that, everything else you've said is useless hyperbole. Get your history together before you go spouting nonsense.

Why be so hostile? If you want to be a dick to strangers on the internet then piss off back to reddit.

Feel free to point out which of these two statements is useless hyperbole:

> Google is known to be a very left-leaning company

> [Google] talks a big talk about being logic and reason-driven

Everything else I said was conjecture.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by slantyyz on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:05AM (#14958521)
>> It doesn't even matter what you write because most people won't even read the original source

I have to wonder if the artificial urgency that social media has created doesn't have something to do with this. Everyone these days wants to be the first to respond, which results in a "shoot first, ask questions later" mentality. You end up with a giant, unstoppable snowball of knee jerk reactions to other knee jerk reactions rolling down a bottomless hill.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by darioush on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:50AM (#14959082)
It doesn't have to even be a politically charged opinion btw. Holding opinions like "let's not refactor this module right now" when everyone else thinks it's a great idea can quickly get you marginalized.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by StephenMelon on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:49AM (#14959063)
Unfortunately, not everything has an objectively correct answer (aesthetics! ethics!) and so what you are saying kind of reinforces the point that diversity of viewpoints is vital to group problem solving. A group with the same blindspots will all make the same mistakes.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by ryandvm on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @03:37PM (#14961681)
That is so beautifully ironic.

"All hail diversity! But if don't think like we do, GTFO."

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by xenadu02 on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:00AM (#14958467)
This was only ever true in online discussion forums, Usenet, etc.

I agree that there is a lot of mob mentality going on, it’s just difficult to get upset about this case because the original author was spouting debunked “biotruth” arguments. Twitter replies are mostly full of men who didn’t read the original memo or who are willfully pretending it didn’t claim women are less biologically suited to being engineers.

I like Pichai’s memo and I think it sets the right tone: the offending employee could have raised these same arguments without falling back to debunked stereotypes. He could have done an hour of Googling on the topic and educated himself. Instead he trusted his own feelings in an area he had no experience or knowledge in.

This seems to be a trait relatively common among really smart people: doctors who think they’re good at politics, mechanical engineers who think they’ve discovered a theory that overturns all of physics, or in this case a software engineer that thinks he knows better than thousands of scientists doing experiments and crunching the actual data.

As far as I can tell we can have rational critical discussions in tech - we just can’t get away with spouting nonsense. If that nonsense reinforces old sexist or racist stereotypes then we can expect a backlash.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by TeMPOraL on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:07AM (#14958550)
> the original author was spouting debunked “biotruth” arguments

C.f. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14956592, where an actual scientist is quoted to say "The author of the Google essay on issues related to diversity gets nearly all of the science and its implications exactly right."

See also http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exagger... for plenty of good references on the topic.

But generally, I mean, ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. I don't expect to see peace over this topic any time soon.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by joshuamorton on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @12:50PM (#14959721)
I think the best way to summarize the memo is that he quotes a bunch of science, which is true.

He also makes a bunch of unfounded claims that aren't really related to the science. And people argue that because he said a bunch of sciency things that scientists agree are correct, that everything he said was true.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by dyarosla on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:37AM (#14958924)
Please provide a quote from the article that is a 'debunked biotruth', just one will suffice.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by xiaosun on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @12:53PM (#14959760)
The guy did have a degree in the sciences...
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by geodel on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:54AM (#14958374)
I agree. This kind of righteousness has no place in modern corporates. I will add even CEOs/management is not safe from getting fired. The difference could possibly be huge severance in case of such incidence.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by puranjay on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:17AM (#14957942)
Which is how it should be.

The owners of any business are free to create whatever business environment they want to create. The market is supposed to punish or reward them accordingly.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by MichaelGG on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:21AM (#14957991)
By that logic, we should let companies have explicit policies against certain races cause the market will sort it out... I don't think I've ever heard that "the market" will deal with unfair internal HR policies.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by TeMPOraL on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:27AM (#14958043)
Of course the market will sort it out. Just not in the way you (or anyone) would consider "sorted out". The mistake here is assuming that the market promotes fairness and humanist values.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by fullshark on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:04AM (#14958517)
> don't think I've ever heard that "the market" will deal with unfair internal HR policies.

Really cause that's a boilerplate libertarian argument.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by puranjay on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:29AM (#14958068)
What tech company would be able to attract top workers if it had an explicit policy against a certain race?

The job market, too, is a market.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by TeMPOraL on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:37AM (#14958153)
There's enough "top workers" available in pretty much any kind of social/racial/gender-based group you could delineate, that even companies with explicit discrimination policies can find the talent they need.

The market won't give you the solution you seek; the issue does not impact profitability enough.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by puranjay on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @12:02PM (#14959222)
A company staffed by racists will by boycotted by the majority of consumers. Its only customers will be other racists.

Plus, most other companies will refuse to supply goods and services to it lest they feel the backlash of catering to racists.

Not exactly a feasible venture.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by TeMPOraL on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @12:21PM (#14959413)
Like today majority of soft drink consumers boycott Coca Cola?

See e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Coca-Cola#Investm...

Actual experience has proven beyond doubt that boycotts don't work, and even if a company has blood on its hand, their deeds are quickly forgotten.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by puranjay on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @03:08PM (#14961400)
Your own link talks about how the drink was boycotted across campuses.

But you can't bring up the Apartheid and not dig through a huge history of companies, countries and people explicity or implicitly supporting it.

Doesn't justify anything of course but Coca-Cola wasn't the only company doing it

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by TeMPOraL on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @04:24AM (#14966569)
> Your own link talks about how the drink was boycotted across campuses.

Didn't change much.

> Doesn't justify anything of course but Coca-Cola wasn't the only company doing it

That's my point, though. Plenty of companies have engaged in abhorrent acts, with little meaningful consequences to them. The market is not good at solving these types of problems.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by xanon on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:48AM (#14958303)
One doesn't get a fat paycheck just because they are intrinsically awesome. One gets a fat paycheck because turnover costs, especially opportunity costs, are higher.
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by sol_remmy on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:37AM (#14958154)
Government regulation is actually the culprit here.

Google is being sued by the Department of Labor for violating a gender discrimination regulation: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/apr/07/google-pa...

These companies behavior has nothing to do with the free market. It is a response to government regulation.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by TeMPOraL on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:25AM (#14958029)
People being up in arms about this issue is exactly 'the market punishing or rewarding Google accordingly'.

That said, don't expect the market to give you a solution that's fair to people - the only one you'll get is the one of maximum profitability under implicit rules of the current culture. Those are very much not the same things.

Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by aeorgnoieang on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:37AM (#14958151)
To be fair, 'the market' is much less strictly economic now – the phrase or even the idea itself, not the network of economic activity (which remains as 'economic' as ever).
Re:Note to Google Employees from CEO Sundar Pichai by TeMPOraL on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:41AM (#14958210)
Ultimately, the fate of businesses is mostly decided by the economical part of "the market". Looking at how the companies live and die, both in tech industry and outside, I don't believe this issue is significant enough to affect a big organization in a meaningful way.

People get easily outraged - which can and does end up with individuals getting hurt - but they also quickly forget and move to next issue. See also the arguments why boycotts generally don't work.