Hoover was the main force in the Harding administration to respond to the crisis of 1920-21 which Harding wisely ignored. The contraction in the economy was very severe but we recovered quickly and no one remembers it--except Austrian economists like Rothbard.
And considering the lengths Roosevelt was willing to go to I'm not surprised Hoover didn't like all of The New Deal. I'm not sure Hoover or anyone else saw the seizing of all gold coming. I'm not sure why history forgives him for that act of theft.
Executive Order 6102 required U.S. citizens to deliver on or before May 1, 1933 all but a small amount of gold coin, gold bullion, and gold certificates owned by them to the Federal Reserve, in exchange for $20.67 per troy ounce. Under the Trading With the Enemy Act of October 6, 1917, as amended on March 9, 1933, violation of the order was punishable by fine up to $10,000 ($166,640 if adjusted for inflation as of 2008) or up to ten years in prison, or both.
Abolishing the gold standard is not "equivalent" to "seizing of all gold". Both things just happened concurrently:
http://www.greatdepressiononline.com/gold-and-the-great-depr...
First, in 1933, at the height of the Great Depression, the U.S. Government, under the Gold Confiscation Act, confiscated gold money from its citizens and replaced it with paper Federal Reserve Notes. It became illegal for individuals to own gold, except for small quantities that coin collectors and dental practitioners could hold. This alone eliminated the public’s capacity to hold government inflation of the money supply in check; they could no longer redeem inflated paper money for gold.
War productions does not make prosperous societies simply because the allocation of resource is redirected to military purpose, not to civilian needs.
And, yes, war is NOT good for the economy or anything else, other than repelling invaders. When all your shit's blown up, you ain't got shit.
I figure that without the wars of the 20th century, we'd all have twice as much wealth, if not more.
So on the one hand, you are right, war is a destroyer of wealth. But on the other hand, the US benefitted enormously from it. The net effect was to concentrate wealth that would have existed in territories of its rivals to it.
We are told the Marshall Plan worked wonders. But interestingly, two countries that were both enemies ended up with very successful economies. And both were bombed pretty hard at the end of the war.
Which makes me think that a nation's culture and the freedom its citizens have to take risks and benefit from doing so are more important than handouts. But you could probably guess I was already pretty biased in that direction.
Killing people isn't the only thing that keeps a population in check.
I have read another book that said that the early new deals program and regulatory framework were essentially made by insider players, who wrote the rulebooks to fit their business operations. Suddenly, you would have a few entrepreneurs and businessmen, jailed because they do a few things differently.
For example, from my fallible memory, a businessman who sold tires has to compete with Goodyear, who have locations around the country. In order for his business to survive, he must sell his tries cheaper than Goodyears does. However, he got fined because Goodyear wrote the regulation rules for the tire industry.
Which one is more likely in your opinion? The image of government programs being an entirely benevolent operation put forward by FDR, or political machines benefiting some people more than others, sometime at the expenses of one another?
If I got a job with the work progress administration, I might be inclined to vote for FDR because he gave me a job, not whether or not if the work progress administration benefit the economy.
Yeah, in absence of better proof provided, I'll stick with the opinion of the majority of historians.
The rest of your points haven't had anything to do with government finances or the attitudes of both presidents towards countercyclical spending vs balanced budgets. They seem like some blindly-applied-backwards-80-years modern republican simplifications about the nature of "government programs". Some dude got screwed by Goodyear at some point in history? Huh?
There's been a lot of scholarship on this topic. You've got to do better than that if you're going to make an overarching claim like in your original point.
To start with, here's a google search for "herbert hoover balanced budget": http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=herbert+hoover+bala...
What is your rationale for sticking with whatever the majority of historians said?
The rest of your points haven't had anything to do with government finances or the attitudes of both presidents towards countercyclical spending vs balanced budgets. They seem like some blindly-applied-backwards-80-years modern republican simplifications about the nature of "government programs". Some dude got screwed by Goodyear at some point in history? Huh?
Sorry about non-sequitur here. I was talking about the effects of FDR's New Deal programs and regulations, and Goodyear was just one data-points amongst many(presumably).
Even so, why you think mine is a Republican simplification of government programs?
As far as what the majority of historians said, if it's them or you, and you're not saying something very very persuasive, I'll tend to believe them. No offense intended.
I tried to downvote your post because of this line, but I ended up mis-clicking and upvoting, so I might as well explain myself.
I am not a Republican, I am an independent. This holier-and-smarter-than-thou attitude that seems to be mestastisizing needs to stop. Please argue your point with facts and reason, not with a "it sympathizes with viewpoint [X] and is therefore invalid." Democrats, Republicans, Liberals, and Conservatives are all guilty of this, but here on the West Coast (where the Hacker News audience predominantly resides) there is a sort of reflexive superiority complex which seems to have developed especially acutely in those on the left side of the political spectrum, in which there is little hesitation, even outside of overtly political forums, to announce that certain views are wrong simply Republicans subscribe to them as well... And of course we all know that Republicans are all about the blunt-force, black-and-white simple-minded thinking, as opposed to subtle, sophisticated, and nuance-loving Democrats.
Sorry, I'll cut my rant off early. I hope my point got across without offending anyone.
Repudiate the Tea Party, Palin, Beck, Limbaugh, et al., and we can talk.
It is well past time for the Big Tent to split, because I, for one, would like to be known as a conservative again.
I do not work on whether a viewpoint is black and white or gray but if it represent the true map of the reality. Such explanations is nonsense to me.
and it's a silly oversimplification that has high correlation with modern republicans.
You'll need to expand your perimeter on political spectrum.
You'll also need to explain why my views is a silly oversimplification.(Err, I mean wrong.)
Why?
The last time I looked, nothing about history was subject to "nature". If all historians agreed that Hitler had 7 arms and flew, nothing bad would happen.
If, on the other hand, engineers decided to act as if steel was less dense than air at 1 bar, things would go wrong.
If a false understanding of history is applied in foreign relations, then there are situations where unnecessary wars can be created.
If a false understanding of history is applied to military strategy, wars can be needlessly lost.
There was a reason that the government created and spent so much on the Ministry of Truth in Orwell's 1984. If you control people's understanding of history, you can have a big impact on what they do in the future.
For example, if a country gets into an unnecessary war because of bad history, the historians aren't penalized.
> There was a reason that the government created and spent so much on the Ministry of Truth in Orwell's 1984. If you control people's understanding of history, you can have a big impact on what they do in the future.
Bingo, and it's not just govt that tries to influence history to influence the future.
Note that there's nothing in here that encourages accuracy.
If I may, when the majority of experts in a field all believe the same thing, it is referred to as consensus. The consensus of the experts in any well researched field tends to be, if not actually right, at the very least the best answer that can be arrived at with current information.
Of course, they are not always right, even in a field as well grounded as mathematics, the consensus has been wrong in the past (the consensus for a very long time was the Euclidean Geometry was the only possible geometry.....). But it is quite reasonable to demand that someone trying to say the consensus is wrong has a high bar to meet to establish that.
In general, the most reasonable thing for someone without the expertise or interest to carefully do an indpendent analysis of all available data is to believe the consensus. When someone does meet that high bar to show that the consensus is wrong, then in any reasonable academic field that consensus will change.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Debt1929-50.jpg
It is true, however, that he raised taxes on the rich. Sound like anyone we know?
But Hoover was trying to balance the budget. He saw it as a goal, an end to itself that would reassure credit markets and do a bunch of good. FDR saw stimulating demand as more important in the short term. That's the difference between them. Hoover was raising taxes to try and balance the budget, and only increased government spending very slightly considering he had 25% unemployment. FDR threw it all to the wind for a few years and massively increased deficits as a deliberate policy.
http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/publications/erp/page/3796/1208...
As one of FDR's brain trust stated, "practically the whole New Deal was extrapolated from programs that Hoover started."
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/goldengate/sfeature/sf_30s.html
But I thought the difference was more clear-cut than that as far as their actions.
Still, I find it hard to justify the statement that "they had the same view in regards to counter-cyclical spending and balanced budgets" -- FDR championed crazy deficits to stimulate the economy for a decade, Hoover seems to have been trying to move towards a balanced budget after a brief round of stimulus.
In general, I assume that a politicians views agree with what he does rather than the lies he tells to get elected.
He did attempt some spending programs near the end of his presidency which was also at a point where the depression was already around the point of its most extreme GDP contraction.
You could argue that was FDR did in terms of spending and bank reforms was similar to what Hoover started near the end of his presidency but orders of magnitude larger. In contrast debt/GDP actually remained neutral during the New Deal due to concurrent GDP expansion.
--Totally biased source, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122576077569495545.html
You got it backwards. In fact FDR campaigned against Hoover's deficit spending.
Once in office, FDR reversed course and doubled-down on Hoover's approach.
Hoover and FDR shared a belief that excess production was the problem - that's why both pushed govt programs to restrict it. That's what put the "Great" in "Great Depression". (Previous panics didn't last nearly as long.) FDR didn't back off until the approaching WWII made it obvious that an "Arsenal of Democracy" had to actually produce massive amounts of stuff.
FWIW, Congressional Repubs at the time voted overwhelmingly for Social Security.
As I understand it, Hoover was preoccupied with maintaining a balanced federal budget through budget cuts and tax increases. That's the opposite of countercyclical spending, which along with some welfare state components made up the new deal. Maybe he was on board with the welfare state and the idea of people having high wages (who isn't?), but the government doesn't cut the majority of paychecks in the country, and those it does cut, he was, well, cutting. In regards to the Depression, he was pretty diametrically opposed to what the New Deal became.
You might have a book that says otherwise, but I've read several books that disagree with you. You've got a pretty high burden of proof to make that statement.