News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by bmcusick on Monday August 07, 2017 @09:42AM (#14947344)
Bitcoin mines are in western China and Oregon precisely for the abundant and cheap hydro power. That's not so bad, ecologically speaking.

Bitcoin is only as ecologically harmful as the source of the electricity used to run the miners, and it's no more harmful than any other use of electricity. If the world switches over to solar and wind as baseload power, problem solved. If the world doesn't switch away from using coal, that's not Bitcoin's fault. It's not a problem Bitcoin can solve.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by SamBam on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:35AM (#14947734)
> and it's no more harmful than any other use of electricity

That's a tautological statement. My 50,000 watt bulb that I shine inside a closed box is also "no more harmful than any other use of electricity," but the question is whether I should be using that electricity in the first place.

You can argue whether the "wealth" generated is worth carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere, but you can't deny that more carbon dioxide has been released because of BitCoin.

Back to my lightbulb in a box: "If the world switches over to solar and wind my 50,000 watt useless bulb's problem is solved. If the world doesn't switch away from using coal, that's not my fault. It's not a problem I can solve."

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nine_k on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:55AM (#14947901)
I'd love a fact-based comparison of bitcoin mining vs gold / nickel / aluminum production, in kWh spent per $1000 of value mined. I suspect bitcoin would look relatively favorably, especially if you factor in no space being taken to store the waste, and nearly no water consumed / contaminated.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by ajross on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:37PM (#14948832)
Gold, nickel and aluminum aren't money, they're resources that get used to produce things in the economy. If you mine a bunch of gold in a new and efficient way you make PCBs and cable connectors cheaper to manufacture and improve life for everyone by a little bit. If you mine a bitcoin in a similarly innovative way we get nothing we didn't have before.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nine_k on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:22PM (#14951382)
There is a price for a kg of raw gold, and other metals (and not only metals). There is a price for 1 raw bitcoin. Either has energy costs attached; it is quite possible to compare the (market) value created per kWh spent.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by ajross on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:05PM (#14953668)
You're missing the point. Your flaw is a semantic glitch with the word "value". You're saying in this post that bitcoin has "value" in the sense of exchange, that you can trade it for other stuff. But in the previous post you were describing the "value" of natural resources, which are being created when they are produced and cause economic activity, thus making us all wealthier.

Not the same kind of value. You can mine a billion coins tomorrow and society will still be stuck with the same junk it has today. You could mine a billion tons of cobalt tomorrow and give us all nearly free batteries in perpetuity.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by tigershark on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:31AM (#14948216)
Absolutely not, it has been posted several times in the past the comparison with the world money and bitcoin power waste was simply outrageous compared to the world monetary base. Aluminium, nichel and gold have other real uses other than minting coins.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by danharaj on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:30AM (#14948213)
How about comparing it to fiat currency?
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nine_k on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:19PM (#14951361)
The problem with fiat currencies is that they are not normally mined, but printed.

Printing a $25 or a $100 note must be an involved process, though.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by russdpale on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:16AM (#14948100)
I think for any crypto to have long term (100+ year) life, it must be powered with free, or close to free energy. So solar, wind, etc.

I don't see any way around this limitation. Eventually the difficulties will be so high, and finding blocks gets harder and harder, keeping it on a traditional power source would not be prudent.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by bmcusick on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:59AM (#14947943)
>> and it's no more harmful than any other use of electricity > That's a tautological statement.

Sure, if you take it out of the context of the rest of my comment. But OP asked if Bitcoin would stop being an ecological disaster, and my point is was that Bitcoin's ecological costs are primarily about the source of the electricity, not the amount of electricity.

Bitcoin mining uses about 170 MWe, continuously. That's really not very much in the grand picture of things. A few medium-sized fields of solar panels isn't an "ecological disaster".

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by vanderZwan on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:12AM (#14948066)
> That's really not very much in the grand picture of things.

And how does that claim hold up when you compare current level cryptocurrency adoption to the scale of money worldwide?

How does energy usage scale with the number of users in general? Linearly?

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by bmcusick on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:31PM (#14948772)
> How does energy usage scale with the number of users in general?

You're confusing Bitcoin miners and Bitcoin nodes.

Bitcoin nodes verify transactions. You can run a Bitcoin node off your home PC. It doesn't use much energy.

Bitcoin miners are what use all the energy, and their energy use is driven by the size of the mining rewards not the number of users.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by vanderZwan on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:12AM (#14955937)
> Bitcoin nodes verify transactions. You can run a Bitcoin node off your home PC. It doesn't use much energy.

You basically answered a different question, because this doesn't tell me how it scales

I'm sure I'm off a little bit in my understanding, but I thought part of the idea whole blockchain thing was being a decentralised ledger. How does that scale if everyone is on it? Is the energy use better or worse than a centralised bank, by how much, and is it significant?

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by leereeves on Monday August 07, 2017 @02:33PM (#14949981)
But the size of the mining rewards scales with the value of Bitcoin which roughly scales with the number of users.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by tigershark on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:29AM (#14948201)
It is not very much? How many tons of co2 are produced in 1 hour to get 170MWh?
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nicpottier on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:53AM (#14948437)
As others have pointed out, bitcoin mining doesn't tend to happen in places where fossil fuels are used for electricity generation, simply because it isn't profitable to do so.

Instead it tends to gravitate fairly quickly to places that currently have an surplus of energy and therefore extremely cheap power generation.

In the US that is Washington state, near Wenatchee, where the power is the cheapest in the nation: http://www.electricitylocal.com/states/washington/wenatchee/

The reason for that price is that it is all hydro, so no co2 produced. (though depending on how fungible you view power it could be argued otherwise) http://www.wenatcheeworld.com/news/2011/jun/01/cheapest-elec...

But ya, though I agree the amount of power that goes into mining and keeping the blockchain safe is absurd, the crazy competition and economies there have driven most of that to green sources. So yay I guess?

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by tigershark on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:24PM (#14948710)
If the power was not wasted in mining it could have been used for something useful therefore reducing the carbon footprint in other places that don't rely so heavily on hydroelectric.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nicpottier on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:42PM (#14948865)
Maybe. See my comment about fungibility. I don't think power transmission costs are insignificant at a distance, and I suspect if it were the case for Wenatchee, Seattle and other large urban centers would happily buy up their cheap power instead of producing their own.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by the8472 on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:11AM (#14947549)
If the world's economies ran on bitcoin we would need a stupendous amount of energy to keep the miners running. That energy not being spent on something else is a huge opportunity cost since many problems could be solved if there were just enough spare energy..
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by bmcusick on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:56AM (#14947911)
> If the world's economies ran on bitcoin we would need a stupendous amount of energy to keep the miners running.

You've misunderstood something about Bitcoin if you think this is true. Bitcoin miners use resources based on the logic of competing with each other for the value of the mining reward, not based on the number of transactions they process. If Bitcoin solved all its scaling problems so that everyone in the world could use Bitcoin, but mining rewards remained constant, the resources the miners expend to collect the reward wouldn't be any different from today.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by Nursie on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:43AM (#14948340)
I think you're underestimating the issue with attackers, if the world ran on bitcoin, attacking it becomes much more attractive, so use must indeed use more energy. It must use enough to make attacking bitcoin very unattractive.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by bmcusick on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:27PM (#14948740)
No, sorry, that's not how Bitcoin works either. If the whole world used Bitcoin and the market cap of Bitcoin was over a trillion dollars, a 51% attacker could still only double-spend its own transactions. As long a public key crypto is secure, you cannot just re-write arbitrary Bitcoin balances into your own wallet even if you had 100% of the mining power. Therefore the incentive to attack Bitcoin is only as big as your own Bitcoin holdings, not the value of the entire market cap.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by Nursie on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:49PM (#14948945)
>> Therefore the incentive to attack Bitcoin is only as big as your own Bitcoin holdings, not the value of the entire market cap.

That's not quite true though is it? They could certainly (for instance) block transactions and generally hold the whole thing to ransom.

You're right, it doesn't have the financial incentive that you could (for instance) steal coin, but you could potentially block all transactions that don't have a considerable fee, for you, or just break stuff. Motives to do that will become more pressing the higher value the network is to nation states.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by Shorel on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @12:00PM (#14959209)
It is already attractive enough for all the hackers in the world to try. And they do. The underlying technology is secure.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by Nursie on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @05:49AM (#14967002)
As it grows it becomes more attractive for more powerful and richer actors, and even state actors.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by Shorel on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:58AM (#14959190)
Bitcoin uses a fixed amount on energy correlated to the number of miners and their hash capacity.

As more miners join, more power is used. But at the same time, miners could be removed, and hash capacity lowered, and the number of transactions per hour would be still the same.

So: energy used: number of miners. Transaction capacity: block size.

Both things are orthogonal. One number is independent of the other.

Right now the protocol is being updated to increase transactions per hour, and this has little to do with the number of miners.

To resume: if the world's economies ran on Bitcoin, because of some big transaction capacity increase, then the energy used would be about the same, because miners would be about the same.

Energy use in Bitcoin has no correlation with number of transactions processed.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by russdpale on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:18AM (#14948114)
There is enough spare energy! An infinite supply a few millions of miles away.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by tigershark on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:33AM (#14948234)
The sun has no infinite supply of energy.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by woah on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:23PM (#14948701)
Solar Bitcoin mining has already decreased the sun's brightness by ~2 lumens
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by Nursie on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:42AM (#14948326)
>> If the world's economies ran on bitcoin we would need a stupendous amount of energy to keep the miners running.

And we'd have to, to keep bad actors from doing similar. It's a terrible idea!