News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nine_k on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:55AM (#14947901)
I'd love a fact-based comparison of bitcoin mining vs gold / nickel / aluminum production, in kWh spent per $1000 of value mined. I suspect bitcoin would look relatively favorably, especially if you factor in no space being taken to store the waste, and nearly no water consumed / contaminated.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by ajross on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:37PM (#14948832)
Gold, nickel and aluminum aren't money, they're resources that get used to produce things in the economy. If you mine a bunch of gold in a new and efficient way you make PCBs and cable connectors cheaper to manufacture and improve life for everyone by a little bit. If you mine a bitcoin in a similarly innovative way we get nothing we didn't have before.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nine_k on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:22PM (#14951382)
There is a price for a kg of raw gold, and other metals (and not only metals). There is a price for 1 raw bitcoin. Either has energy costs attached; it is quite possible to compare the (market) value created per kWh spent.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by ajross on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:05PM (#14953668)
You're missing the point. Your flaw is a semantic glitch with the word "value". You're saying in this post that bitcoin has "value" in the sense of exchange, that you can trade it for other stuff. But in the previous post you were describing the "value" of natural resources, which are being created when they are produced and cause economic activity, thus making us all wealthier.

Not the same kind of value. You can mine a billion coins tomorrow and society will still be stuck with the same junk it has today. You could mine a billion tons of cobalt tomorrow and give us all nearly free batteries in perpetuity.

Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by tigershark on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:31AM (#14948216)
Absolutely not, it has been posted several times in the past the comparison with the world money and bitcoin power waste was simply outrageous compared to the world monetary base. Aluminium, nichel and gold have other real uses other than minting coins.
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by danharaj on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:30AM (#14948213)
How about comparing it to fiat currency?
Re:Proof of Work Without All the Work by nine_k on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:19PM (#14951361)
The problem with fiat currencies is that they are not normally mined, but printed.

Printing a $25 or a $100 note must be an involved process, though.