News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by nippples on Monday August 07, 2017 @05:12AM (#14946194)
I really thought it was corrupt politicians giving away public resources to private mega corporations, irresponsible financing systems, wall street selling lel bonds, the undermining of the national working class, bogus copyright laws that are designed to squish small and upcoming competition, and people purchasing garbage degrees instead of useful ones with money they don't have guaranteeing they'll be indebted for at least two or three decades.

But no, it's just IT. How wrong I was.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrs95 on Monday August 07, 2017 @07:43AM (#14946759)
There does seem to be a hostility towards people who work in tech on the left. To me this feels like pandering to that by Clintonian types who don't actually have any interest in dealing with class issues.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by tetraca on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:13AM (#14947562)
From what I've seen, I don't believe it's universal. The hostility is toward certain kinds of people who encourage and enable centralization or crystallization of power. People like Richard Stallman are generally liked, but people like Peter Thiel or Mark Zuckerberg are not. Mind you I don't know what the Tankie side of things really says because I loathe them.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrs95 on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:25AM (#14947650)
It's definitely not universal. But in my opinion, it's more like there are people who think they're better than us that are upset that we're as successful as we are. And being predominantly white men doesn't help, even if we do tend to lean left. That shitty documentary Nancy Pelosi's daughter made is probably a good example of that. The premise is basically that tech workers are terrible and are destroying San Francisco. I'm sure there's similar sentiments on the right as well, but theirs seem to be more of "these rich tech liberals want to tell us how to live" or something along those lines.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by charlesdm on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:57AM (#14947917)
Do software engineers predominantly lean left? I think the left / right debate is quite outdated, with both sides having equally good (but also bad) ideas about certain subjects.

Why can't you lean left on healthcare and LGBT rights, yet more right on certain economic policies and tax issues?

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrs95 on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:09AM (#14948036)
I think both are true. Software engineers tend to vote Democrat, but they're also much more likely to be libertarians than the average person. Or even "alt-right" to be honest. Outside of a general leftward bias, I think we seem to be more prone to exploring ideological extremes.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jhawk28 on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:34AM (#14948241)
It depends more on the industry. Software Engineers for Google and Facebook are probably more left leaning. Software engineers for a defense contractor are probably more right leaning.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by cmurf on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:03PM (#14948539)
Alt-right is white nationalism. So you've gone from libertarian which is not really left or right (depends on issue but revolves mainly around a weak central government except as it relates to protecting civil liberties and national defense), completely skipped moderate conservatives, conservatives, and right wing, and even hard right, and landed on a blatantly racist movement that has no f'n idea how the economy even works which is why they keep thinking tax cuts for people who make over $10 million a year creates jobs, but bank deregulation is good, but the banks f'd them over in 20008, but for sure stop importing brown people, legal and illegal, and especially if they're Muslim.

Most alt-right are just deeply ignorant people. But some are malevolent. The base ideology requires people believe vicious things about "the other" who happen to be merely different. They refer to liberals as libtards, and prefer strong leaders like Putin, Kim, Duerte, Erdogan, and even weaker autocrats, as compared to "vile libtards" like say Clinton (who is something like a cross between Woodrow Wilson and Margaret Thatcher). No doubt they'd prefer Putin as president of the United States than a Clinton.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrs95 on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:59PM (#14949042)
I skipped those other things because there's actually less of your typical conservatives in this industry than average, but there's a disturbingly high number of alt-right software engineers. Like 10% of the last company I worked for!

Plus, people have been referring to liberals as libtards since way before the alt right was a thing, and the alt right doesn't really tend to advocate for tax cuts for the rich. They are overwhelmingly racist and white nationalist but not exclusively. And really the root of the ideology is fear of what could happen to whites as a minority group, which is very paranoid and not something I'm personally concerned about, but it's not the same thing as hate. A lot of these people are also mentally ill. The "basket of deplorables" approach to dealing with them clearly did not work. We can be against everything they stand for and still be aware that they're human beings that on the whole are probably more confused than sociopathic or evil.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by cmurf on Monday August 07, 2017 @03:39PM (#14950569)
I follow. And I agree there is a distinction to be made even in the alt-right between the ignorant and violent, even if both come with dangerous consequences.

In another conversation on HN about the social benefits of shaming people, I'd say a possible reason "basket of deplorables" approach didn't work is because it was quickly followed by milquetoast apology. If you want an invidious recipe for political fallout, that would be it. If you're going to try and shame people effectively as a bully you have to stick with it (see Trump).

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by yellowapple on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:31PM (#14948771)
"The base ideology requires people believe vicious things about 'the other' who happen to be merely different."

The "alt-right" are not the only ones who are guilty of this, unfortunately. This is a characteristic of the extremes of pretty much every political position or ideology.

Personally, the whole "if you're not with us you're against us" mentality of both of the mainstream political parties is what drove me to vote Libertarian last election. Johnson's campaign seemed a lot more focused on welcoming folks with differing political views (which is unsurprising, given the rather long range of libertarianism from libertarian socialism to anarcho-capitalism, and given the fact that the Libertarian Party is in no position to be alienating voters), which was very refreshing amid both Clinton and Trump basing their campaigns on how bad the other candidate is (and further on how bad the other candidate's supporters are).

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by cmurf on Monday August 07, 2017 @03:30PM (#14950479)
The American political system punishes general election voters for not compromising on one of the two major parties. It lacks runoff elections, as well as range or preferential voting strategies so that voters are not so harshly punished by deviating from consensus candidates.

The ensuing dissonance upon understanding this punishment is what encourages our low voter participation rates, as well as hyper-partisan politics, tribalism. In addition, there's a pervasive "government sucks" that contemplating a state by state change in voting law, and it would have to be state by state, seems like dark comedy. It would take a lot of political committment way beyond that of voting 3rd party to fix the problem we have in the American political system. Americans are politically lazy, content to not vote, or vote 3rd party, and suffer the inevitable result, engage in political denialism, than the critical thinking required to fix it.

The effect of closed primary elections also enhances this tribalism and discourse problem. It's maybe 8-12% of the total eligible electorate that get a presidential primary candidate the nomination for the two major parties.

Both major political parties sabotaged the Electoral College by stacking it with party loyalists rather than, you know, smart people or even contemplative people or even randomly selected citizens. We could hardly do worse choosing dead people for Electors.

A case to watch is Gill vs Whitford before the Supreme Court next year.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by fundabulousrIII on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:00AM (#14947954)
Recently run into this in uni. God save me from the highly educated minority who are always right and love to argue (with tenure). Basic fact: You don't know anything except what you are told by what I design.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by KirinDave on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:43AM (#14947796)
Maybe, but be careful here though.

It's possible for both the parent post and the article to be on the right track. Wealth enables action and technology obviously enables and creates wealth.

It's also difficult to assign this to "Clintonian types" when in general the centrist side of the Democrats has been such an ardent supporter of the growth of the tech industry. They're eager to own the eneconic growth.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrs95 on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:30AM (#14948211)
From what I've seen, they have been more than capable to support the industry and take credit for it's successes and simultaneously demonize tech workers as unempathetic racists, sexists, and gentrifiers. A specific examples being Alexandra Pelosi's documentary San Francisco 2.0. Bill Maher has also made similar anti "tech bro" statements from time to time. While he's not the perfect centrist, he was pretty much behind the Obama administration 100%, and I would definitely consider him to be part of the Democratic establishment.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by KirinDave on Monday August 07, 2017 @11:45AM (#14948352)
> they have been more than capable to support the industry and take credit for it's successes

Well let's face it, we're all getting a huge break from the government right now in a ton of different ways, so they do get some credit for making the laws incredibly lax around here.

Even Trump's government gets credit until it screws up this sweet deal we're on. And if you wanna see how sweet it really gets, go into fintech. All your opponents with lots of cash on hand are basically operating blindfolded with both hands tied behind their back.

Regulators literally have no idea what to make of us in that space. They largely leave us alone so long as you have even semi-competent legal advice. If you have good legal advice? Well you end up recreating financial institutions in all but name and without any regulation (e.g., Digit).

> simultaneously demonize tech workers as unempathetic racists, sexists, and gentrifiers

I wanna get to the rest of your post, but I just can't leave this alone. I'm sorry to shift the focus here, but we really don't need any external help on this though, do we?

The racist part of the story has legs because folks like the "unnamed" google engineer writing screeds about how no, actually, it's the rich conservatives in the majority who are unsafe. Because tech conferences argue they're a safe space for men who's primary ideological focus for their publications is proving black people thrive under slavery. Because a constant dribble of stories like Kixeye exist to support population statistics that are... statistically unlikely by pure chance..

The sexist part of the story? Gosh maybe if our industry stopped doing so many things that enable abuse of women, the narrative might not be that we enable the abuse of women. Similarly, if we paid women more or less equally within rank and gave them equal opportunity in the workforce... This problem might exist to a much lesser degree. Uber's ripping itself apart not because some women choose to speak out; it's because the public is discovering obviously unethical and probably illegal behavior.

Tech gets special attention, I grant. It's outsized, growing fast, and is consuming and reformatting other INDUSTRIES as its primary fuel source rather than more traditional business models.

> I would definitely consider him to be part of the Democratic establishment.

This is an excellent example of a perception gap. See, I've always seen him as fringe because of his views on transgenderism, his decision that racial slurs are free speech he should exercise, etc.

Unlike, say, Clinton or Obama who've obviously changed their opinions on this subject (or decided to portray an image largely indistinguishable from someone having changed their image) Maher has continue to expand upon it. Maybe he was center-left when he started, but it's difficult to say he's on the left side of the cultural equation these days.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrs95 on Monday August 07, 2017 @01:35PM (#14949350)
But that guy at Google is very much in the minority, as are all of the people causing problems with various *isms. But that doesn't stop people from continuing to paint us specifically with too broad a brush, and I don't think that's just an accident, I think it's because they have an issue with us personally, and that's probably due to negative stereotypes about "geeks".
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by KirinDave on Monday August 07, 2017 @01:55PM (#14949565)
> But that guy at Google is very much in the minority, as are all of the people causing problems with various -isms.

Can you prove this? I'm curious. I don't entirely disagree, but I sure would love verification.

I think that whole thing about "unconscious bias" is very real, and it's quite fair to rigorously examine our biases and accept constructive criticism of them. There's also a matter of perception lagging behind reality, and reality being difficult to assess because of availability biases.

> But that doesn't stop people from continuing to paint us specifically with too broad a brush,

Deep apologies for going so far on a tangent here, but I'd like to encourage you to step back from these for a moment.

Firstly, don't be that person and allegations aimed at said people don't really apply to you? If you accidentally behave in a way that lines up with these allegations, then own it, accept the censure, identify what steps you'll take to correct yourself then execute on them.

> I think it's because they have an issue with us personally, and that's probably due to negative stereotypes about "geeks".

I'm sure that there is a bit of this still lingering in the world, but by-and-large the stereotyping about "geeks" has ended. Geeks rule the damn world. Geeks dominate the news cycle. In terms of combating anti-intellectualism? We're winning that handily.

Here's the part where I sorta agree with your previous statement, even if I wouldn't bet the whole farm on it:

One of the reasons that the extreme-conservative-and-extreme-liberal rhetoric is amplifying so much lately is that fact-and-experiment-driven flexibility is actually gaining so much cultural mindshare from more dogmatic methods of thinking. This empirical method is decried by both sides of the aisle as "centrism" or painted as anti-humanist. I don't believe it is, but such is the defense mechanism of those those thoughts. Examine the rhetoric of a "nationalist" or a "monarchist" or even a "communist"; exclusion is baked into their doctrine. It's why these ideas are so tenacious.

As these more dogmatic groups get backed further and further into corners, they seem outsized cultural impact more and more desperately to avoid the perception that they are in decline.

To this end, enduring slings and arrows while focusing on doing the right and fair thing, with an eye towards incremental improvement, is exactly what folks attacking our community hate us doing. Part of the reason they're eager to amplify our failures at self-policing is because they're flustered by the fact that for the most part the valley has calmly agreed that the current situation is in fact illegal and untenable and started taking steps to correct it.

These steps can't happen overnight, nor can they be "one simple thing." We both know that. But dogmatic thought thrives on the notion that if you just listen and do whatever they say (often without any pre-planning at all) then it'll all go away.

Looping this all back around to the topic, it's up to us to figure out how to use the power-disparity we're developing (and that's precisely what a difference is technology is) to make the world a better place. Criticism needs to be in our lives to remind us that we're shaping things that can affect generations and generations to come.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrochkind1 on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:23AM (#14947639)
I think there's hostility to the rich in general on the left. Not all people who work in tech are rich, but many of the, oh, top 10% of income earners, especially those someone else might come into contact with regularly, are in tech. And human nature to express more ire towards those you come into contact with regularly than those you never do.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrs95 on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:35AM (#14947743)
I think that's partially true, but I also think it's because of negative stereotypes of people in tech being "nerds" who are to be looked down upon. It's more of a mismatch between what they think our social and economic class ought to be and what it actually is.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by jrochkind1 on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @02:12AM (#14954918)
I dunno, there are a lot of nerdy leftists.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by kartan on Monday August 07, 2017 @06:14AM (#14946423)
Yes. I work in IT and I'm rich, aren't you rich like the rest on engineers that read Hacker News? Not like the poor people at finance institutions, they create so much value and get so few in return...
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by empath75 on Monday August 07, 2017 @06:46AM (#14946541)
They're also enabled by IT.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by simonh on Monday August 07, 2017 @07:06AM (#14946611)
Financial institutions are all now IT companies. It's an essential core competency. Money is information.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by gizmodo59 on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:19AM (#14947614)
A core competency doesn't mean they are IT companies. Knowing how to use a computer is akin to literacy. That does not mean that being so efficient in Excel will make you Martin Shkreli (https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/4df5il/martin_shkre...) Finance is much more than knowing how to use or even excel at any software or programming. Computer is an enabler in this case IMHO.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by simonh on Monday August 07, 2017 @12:12PM (#14948608)
They're IT companies that just don't sell any of their tech. But then Facebook don't sell their tech either. Just as a computer is an enabler at Facebook to manage personal contacts and communications, at Google to manage their indexing and advertising business, at Amazon to manage their ordering and inventory systems. Banks nowadays are just as much IT companies as any of these. A typical bank employs thousands of developers. They even develop their own development and service deployment environments, their own IDEs, even their own custom languages, middleware, development frameworks and libraries and database technologies.

Some have even rolled their own internal cloud infrastructure services like mini-Azures or a mini-AWS and systems like Hadoop but using entirely custom tech, not just an instance of an open source solution. There is almost nothing going on in the big tech giants in terms of core technology development that some banks somewhere aren't also doing.

You might split hairs or come up with some technical definition to avoid classifying them in this way, but if you do you will be deluding yourself. The Banks have found that in many areas they cannot rely on external technology companies to meet their needs, so they have to meet them using internal resources and roll a lot of their own tech.

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by eternalban on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:14AM (#14947569)
And that is precisely why (imo) the finance world engineered the outsourcing strategy (and invested heavily in off shore body shops) in late 90s. At least that is how it looked to me in those days.

(The official story was that low skill IT jobs are sent off shore to help the bottom line. This, the official reason for a service and information economy to tech transfer its crown jewels, never made any sense. Consider that software craft is mostly learned on the job, thus gutting the entry level insures future deficits in higher levels. And further that by near universal account, outsourced software projects are technically subpar and subject to multiple rewrites. All this while entire floors at investment banks' IT departments were 'let go'.

You do the math.)

Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by marcosdumay on Monday August 07, 2017 @04:30PM (#14950999)
That. Let's all just dismiss that governments worldwide have been growing out of control since the 30's so we can settle on an enemy and keep the growing.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by BlackjackCF on Monday August 07, 2017 @01:31PM (#14949312)
I've always viewed IT as the new version of the middle/upper class. It's kind of weird to criticize a field that's open to people joining and paying well as the reason for wealth inequality.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by nabla9 on Monday August 07, 2017 @07:45AM (#14946769)
Common media narratives like the ones you describe are usually wrong or at least they give misguided view of relative importance of different factors.
Re:IT is the cause of rising income and wealth inequality si... by wavefunction on Monday August 07, 2017 @09:57AM (#14947445)
"Common media narratives" ... or ... "easily observed phenomena"?

You be the judge!