What Coinbase should have done is this:
1. Stood their ground on not supporting trading for the cryptocurrency, because they are under no obligation to develop new features.
2. Implemented a system to disburse the forked currency to customers if needed.
3. Implemented an explicit trigger price for acknowledging the new currency, which would function for potential forks of currencies already supported on the platform. If the currency does not pass a specific (very low, far lower than $700) mark, they don't disburse it, but if it does, they immediately support disbursal to anyone who requests it.
The organic state of a cryptocurrency fork is that all extant holders receive a new asset, which may or may not be worth anything. A company cannot seize that asset without consideration. If the price of the currency subsequently crashes, then it crashes; that does not change the rights of a customer to their assets, which cannot be signed away with an email sent out 10 days before the event.
This is not a hypothetical question. I particpated in two airdrops this year, Stellar and Byteball. I immediately sold the airdropped tokens and increased my bitcoin holdings by 3%. But I don't think Coinbase should be required to support Stellar or Byteball just because they did airdrops to Bitcoin holders.
Byteball in particular seems like just some guy's random project and only has value because of the current investment bubble in anything that looks like a cryptocurrency. I wouldn't trust it to be secure or work properly. What if Byteball is just a huge scam, and the creator can secretly mint tokens at will? Now Coinbase is participating in a scam!
It's like depositing a dollar to a bank, and then finding out that it had been signed by Andy Warhol in invisible ink and asking for the specific dollar back. Sorry, you shouldn't have deposited in a bank. You can get a dollar back, but not the same one you deposited.
What you're looking for is more like a safety deposit box for Bitcoins. That's a whole separate product, with a different fee structure.
In the other fork in this discussion thread, the banking analogy: we're talking about an exotic interest payment of sorts. Again here, banking regulations require banks to disclose interest rates and payment details and management fees up front for accounts. But banks in the real world are largely allowed to reap the majority of profits from an investment that goes well, and doesn't have to apply much if any of that back to the savings accounts from which it utilized stored funds to fund that investment.
Which is to say that Coinbase may be doing nothing wrong according to either real world analogy, with the big difference being the "wild frontier" of existing in an under-regulated space with fewer up-front disclosure guarantees.
The only argument you can make is Coinbase not givint a "reasonable" amount of foresight to users (who would pressumble have the right of advanced time/knowledge to convert to USD, etc and then back to BTC (on another "exchange").
I have no idea is this is true or not, but this is the only criticism of Coinbase you can have here.
Perhaps, but the legal question is whether a protocol fork as a matter of law creates a new asset owned by the customer, creates a new asset owned by whoever controls the wallet keys, or merely creates an opportunity which someone who controls wallet keys may exploit to generate a new asset by participating in the ecosystem on the new side of the fork.
(Fundamentally, this also lays near the question of legal ownership of Bitcoin or similar cryptocurrency in general and what specifically is “owned” when one owns them.)
A) The marina owner had entered into a fiduciary relationship with you regarding the possession of your boat to your benefit, and
B) The DVDs were sent to the fiduciary with instructions to be given to the boat owners, and
C) A reasonable person would believe that the boat owner would regard the DVD to have enough value to care about,
Then the marina owner would be obligated to at least ensure that the boat owners can access their DVD, if they wish to, for some reasonable period (say, 60 days). For example, by leaving it with the boat or dropping it in the boat owners' locker at the harbor office, or informing them of their property with the next scheduled communication (in a way that leaves them 60 days etc).
[1] I know "comparing a comparison", but here ya go: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14913261
You have a shed to store valuables. Because that's inconvenient for selling your stuff as you live far outside the city, you get a storage unit in the city and move some of your belongings there. There is a big government grant for all storage buildings based on the current value they store. Your shed at home is pretty empty, so you don't get much. The owner of your storage unit gets a lot of money. Does he owe you?
But when you buy a certain amount of BTC on coinbase, you will just buy that abstract amount, there is no wallet tied to you, in the same way that when you have money in a bank you don't own any specific bill. The bank may not even have that amount, at least not in the form of physical cash.
To continue the analogy, let's say that the Central Bank says "in order to fight fake bills, whoever brings old 20 USD bills will get back a new 20 USD bill PLUS a 20 EUR bill." If you have 1000 USD in a bank, are you automatically entitled to 1000 EUR, or are you supposed to get first the bills from the bank ? And if you do, should the bank give you old bills or can it give you the new bills ?
Dealing with this on a case-by case basis (as they seem to be doing) makes more sense.
It might have been nice if they gave more advanced notice, but in my opinion they shouldn't be expected to give ANY notice of this type of thing.
I think they're handling it well.
So even if Coinbase did allow people to withdraw BCH, they currently couldn't use it for anything (Because Coinbase is not trading BCH), and they'd be waiting hours or more likely days to reach enough confirmations to have any sense of security over the coins. So doing something about it now vs. considering doing something about it in a couple days after the dust settles makes little difference.
https://blog.coinbase.com/update-for-customers-with-bitcoin-...
They do not own you Clams or Stellars or Byteball or any other token that you did not buy.
Keep in mind that this is the fourth coin to be initally distributed to the Bitcoin UTXO set this year alone. If anything, supporting one but not the other would increase their risk exposure, legally as well as support wise. Every token carries risk.
So if I fork Bitcoin into Billycoin, this demands action by Coinbase?
(And as I stated in the comment - with a proviso that the price or adoption of the cryptocurrency pass a very low but nontrivial bar.)
I've also just sold 0.000001% equity in my startup to my dad for $10. Does anyone want to invest in my billion dollar idea? Am I a unicorn?
Their only obligation is to maintain your BTC balance with BTC defined as the longest chain. It doesn't matter how popular a fork is, it's not their problem.
Because there is greatly reduced liquidity of BCH (most exchanges don't support, hard/slow to deposit into exchanges that do), supply of BCH is artificially limited at the moment. Proponents of BCH can trade their BTC for BCH at a rate greater than they believe it is worth to easily pump the value and 'market cap' (most market cap stats have no measure of this 'locked supply') to make BCH appear more popular than it is at a fraction of the price that would be necessary if selling was easy. This could sway more miners to choose to mine BCH over BTC, and in doing so, actually increase the real value of BCH.
From: https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/6ooorn/small_blockers_...
It's much more than that. The exchanges that list support do not accept deposits. They won't even show you a deposit address. So you can't sell anywhere at the moment, unless you are one of the few who were awarded BCH by your exchange.
The only thing you seem to be able to do right now is to buy it for Bitcoins, not move it. There have been rumors of two Chinese exchanges accepting it, and they do indeed list deposit addresses, but it does not seem to work.
Yet at the same time, media everywhere (including this very thread), hype up the great market cap. I guess at least someone got what they came for.
That's absolutely clear to me, and I was dying to find a way to short it. I just found out that plus500 allows that... I don't like that platform, but I just placed my shorts (even if now it's "only" $500)
So let's say Coinbase allows BCH withdrawals. Unless they enabled trading it (which they didn't with ETC when ETH forked), all those Coinbasers wouldn't be able to sell anyways. They'd be waiting like everyone else, so that $700 price wouldn't matter.