News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:42PM (#14897299)
Original Author here. Happy to answer questions about this piece or coding interviews in general!

And eager to receive any feedback.

Thanks for the post!

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by numbsafari on Monday July 31, 2017 @11:44PM (#14897744)
I gave up reading your site because of the obnoxious popovers. It's super annoying.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Monday July 31, 2017 @11:46PM (#14897753)
:(

Ok, time to rethink the email opt-ins.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by Y7ZCQtNo39 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:22AM (#14898088)
The opt-out button: "I don't need more coding interview practice".

My first thought: Whoever designed this is super salty for me not wanting to provide my e-mail.

Out of all of the problems in my life, too much e-mail is certainly one of them. I like to keep it to a minimum. And as an adult, a weekly coding problem falls so down far on the priority list compared to all the other e-mail I'd get.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by ing33k on Monday July 31, 2017 @11:51PM (#14897770)
I would have ignored that advice if your target audience were non tech users.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by numbsafari on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:51AM (#14897960)
My wife is a non-technical user. She has just about given up on using the internet because of the prevalence of these annoyances.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by virtualized on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @05:09AM (#14898911)
Because "non tech users" like bad web design? Why would they?
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by throwawaybbq1 on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:37PM (#14897525)
You've got a cool site and I appreciate all the hard work creating high quality content (I've looked at the free questions and considered subscribing a few times in the past). I think your business model/pricing could use work. Unless I'm mistaken and things are going well .. in that case, I'll withdraw to my cave :-p

My suggestion would be to have a slightly cheaper tier (probably no more than a hundred bucks). This mirrors the cost of two-to-three interview books. You could add a custom grading or personalized tutoring option for the full 500, or heck, even more (this is sort of like the GRE/GMAT prep option). Come to think of it .. I wonder why the GRE/GMAT prep crowd hasn't tackled programming interviews?

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:45PM (#14897554)
Thanks for the note. Definitely a great point. Not sure yet how we tier out our product, but tiered pricing is definitely the state of the art.

We've been working on some /tech/ to enable tiered pricing in the meantime. The Site's all custom, and so far there's no notion of a "product" yet...just "paid" and "unpaid."

Share your question re: where's Kaplan on this stuff!

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by neerkumar on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:31AM (#14897882)
Price seems expensive to me as well. In data science there is a similar site which has become pretty popular if you are interviewing in those top tech companies, but it is cheaper.

As the guy above was suggesting, that data science site does personalized feedback and that justifies the high price. Otherwise, the way it is now, it feels like it should be priced similarly to CTCI.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by fspear on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @06:24AM (#14899251)
Agree I would have signed up if it wasn't for the pricing...as it stands now it's totally not worth it.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:47AM (#14897944)
What's the data science site!
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by neerkumar on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:57AM (#14897981)
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gaius on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @05:47AM (#14899086)
It's crazy that there is a whole industry dedicated to cheating ahem gaming job interviews in software/IT. Imagine if doctors or lawyers or real engineers did this. No wonder we can't get taken seriously as a profession.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @11:17AM (#14901556)
Imagine if docs could be rejected from a new job because they failed to repeat the obscure diagnosis that was featured on the last episode of House, that really has nothing at all to do with the job they wanted to do.

Imagine if lawyers could be rejected for not being able to explain the minority opinion in Foobar v. Bazquux, which again, has absolutely nothing to do with their expected duties as prosecutor of poor people with small amounts of marijuana.

Imagine if real engineers were asked to build a suspension bridge out of silly putty, table salt, and carbon fiber.

The interviewees are simply doing their jobs, which is to analyze a problem and implement the most cost-effective solution. The interviewers are the ones causing the problem. Granted, it isn't always because they are non-technical people trying to gauge the value of skills they don't understand. A lot of times, it is because the interviewer is a tech person that still can't effectively gauge the value of skills they do understand, and also wants to look clever in front of a stranger, subtly discriminate to preserve "culture", and do the same stuff to others that had been previously done to them in their interviews.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gaius on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:44PM (#14902663)
subtly discriminate to preserve "culture"

Indeed; this is a point I make over and over. HR departments aren't smart enough to detect ageism being openly practiced right under their noses...

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by southphillyman on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @09:55AM (#14900584)
Is it cheating or gaming the system if the vast majority of QUALIFIED engineers would not pass an interview without preparation? Reviewing these cheat sheets every couple of years is essentially part of the job.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by soham on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:47AM (#14898174)
We are definitely on to tackling the prep thing. Been around for 3 years actually: http://interviewkickstart.com

Looks like Kaplan is not going to be interested in these things after the recent shutdown of DBC.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by sanderjd on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:44PM (#14897549)
Nice graphics! I really like from-the-bits-up explanations of things like this.

I found the newsletter upsell in the sidebar very distracting. I know you're considered a fool if you fail to bash people over the head with newsletter sign-up requests these days, but maybe just keep the ones interspersed in the text and get rid of the one I have to see all the time? Or I guess AB test it or whatever the cool kids are doing for this stuff. I dunno, but it really detracted from what I otherwise thought was great content.

Best of luck to you!

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:48PM (#14897562)
Really helpful to hear. We were worried about it but thought "once you get into reading the piece you'll probably just forget it's there, right?"

We're really focused on trying to "twist the knobs" only up to the point right /before/ it starts getting annoying.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by nafizh on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:19AM (#14897846)
It is a good site. I actually bought the product a year ago. But then I had to do something else which made me to not focus on getting an internship/job, and only recently I noticed it has a one year timeline. I think a one year time limit is too little for a 100 dollar product.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by Silhouette on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @05:47AM (#14899087)
Honest feedback (short version): Very nice presentation, but for me the content loses credibility thanks partly to some silly mistakes but also to glossing over a few too many details.

Some examples:

The integer overflow part has incorrect binary/decimal conversions all over the place.

The example hash function used (summing elements modulo number of buckets) could be dangerous. I'm not generally a fan of showing bad practice or incorrect examples when teaching, even at an early stage when the student isn't ready for the real deal yet, but if you must then you could warn the reader that it's a simplistic example for demonstration and shouldn't be used in reality. It would not make a good impression if a candidate said they knew about hash tables but then produced that function as an example of hashing.

Similar comments apply to the treatment of big O notation. I understand that your style is to try to avoid being scary and complicated, but big O is useful because it has a specific meaning. Even in the longer explanation, you hardly mention that fundamentally it is about scalability and bounds, and you mention the danger of overlooking the constant factor only briefly right at the end. Also, the casual initial characterisation as being relative to the size of the input sets up traps when dealing with more sophisticated data structures, such as graphs where you often need to refer to the number of nodes and/or edges when specifying complexities.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @09:29AM (#14900382)
Fixed the bugs in the integer overflow section!
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by biocomputation on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:14AM (#14897833)
Cool site. C++ graphics programmer here. I would like to add that knowing one thing extremely well - even a fairly small thing - can have amazing results in interviews. I can write just about anything, on command, in GLSL.

This has gotten me more interview offers and job offers than I can count, and it really didn't take me all that long to learn.

I hate to promote memorization, but honestly, it works. Some people argue that memorization isn't the same as learning, and it's not. But it definitely helps you learn and increases understanding.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by curiousDog on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:26AM (#14897867)
Nice site but your questions are pretty run of the mill these days. Would be nice to see some new, original questions :-). Also an option to schedule some mock interviews would be great!
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:30AM (#14897879)
Thanks! Have a few new questions in the pipeline :)

For mock interviews, definitely check out:

- http://interviewing.io/

- http://www.byte-by-byte.com/practice-coding-interviews/

- https://www.pramp.com/

- https://www.funnel.la/

- http://interviewkickstart.com/ (email 'em to ask about mock interviews over Skype)

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by thaumasiotes on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:10AM (#14898033)
> For mock interviews, definitely check out:

> http://interviewing.io/

I got this recommendation about a year ago and tried. The site stated that I couldn't register, but I could sign up for a place in the registration queue.

So I did that. I have yet to hear back from them. I don't quite understand how people keep recommending them, as if it was possible to use the site.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by leeny on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:14AM (#14898053)
Hey, I'm the founder of interviewing.io. We're coming out of private beta soon, which means we'll be sending out invites to folks on the waiting list shortly. A year is a long time though, and I'm sorry you had to wait that long, so I figured least I could do was kick you an invite (check your email). Thanks for being patient with us while we figured things out.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by thaumasiotes on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:33AM (#14898127)
I guess it's a nice gesture, but this does nothing to address my point that, as far as I can tell, recommending interviewing.io to anyone is wildly inappropriate, and I can't see how it happens at all. (Not that you're the proper person to address that; it's more of a question for gameguy43 et al.) Are the people giving interviewing advice not actually even attempting to do the things they're recommending?
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by leeny on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:37AM (#14898136)
IIRC, folks who've recommended us on HN have used it (we get notified when people post about us bc it's obviously something we care about a lot). Sorry again about the delay, and I hope you like the product.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by jaredsohn on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @03:44AM (#14898600)
In the past, interviewing.io was free for anybody to try (it was when I looked at it three years ago) and if somebody hasn't looked at it recently they might not know when the situation has changed.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by leeny on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:01PM (#14902132)
We're still free, and we always will be.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by jaredsohn on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:05PM (#14902891)
Sorry; I meant 'free' as in there wasn't a waiting list but checking my email I see that I was on the waiting list at first, too. I guess I'll just testify that people have used it. :)
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by RafiZ on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @11:37PM (#14907732)
Pramp provides you the ability to schedule same-day mock interviews.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by esfandia on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:19AM (#14897844)
Your explanations were excellent. I especially liked the way you introduced hash tables using a simple array where the indices had special meaning.

The diagrams are clear and helpful.

Only nitpick: not sure how somebody who is supposed to learn what an array is by reading this is supposed to already know the meaning of Big O notation. So maybe a little intro to Big O complexity somewhere in there would help as well.

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:27AM (#14897871)
Eep! Did you notice that the first time we mention big O notation, you can click on it and an inline explanation slides down? Probably not, based on the question! We should make that part louder.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by esfandia on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:41AM (#14897921)
The problem with links is that you don't know where they are going to take you. When I have such a nice piece of text to read I don't want to click and potentially land in a completely different site, have to click "back" and all that distracting stuff. That's probably why your link didn't "register" with me. In your case in turns out the link nicely expands in place, so that's pretty cool. I'd still just inline that little explanation on Big O, since you keep referring to it in the rest of the text. It's more than a mere footnote.

Now this is all my own experience, and others may disagree, so don't necessarily go changing things just on my account!

Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by justinpombrio on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:36AM (#14897902)
As another data point, I thought the big O inline expansion was pretty clear, and clicked on it.
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by auston on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:42AM (#14897926)
What is your best email address?
Re:Data Structures for Coding Interviews by gameguy43 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:47AM (#14897942)