News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by Canada on Monday July 31, 2017 @08:54AM (#14891433)
After more than a decade of security researchers raising the alarm over critical electronic voting machine vulnerability, I hope this finally causes some real demand for verifiable ballots.
Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @08:58AM (#14891463)
No one really claims that the voting machines were secure because it was technically advanced. The voting system is secure because it is irregular and physically distributed and not connected.

In other words. Hacking the election is up there with the us planned 9/11 it would require social engineering of unheard proportions.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by learc83 on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:29AM (#14891726)
In a close election it's potentially feasible to flip an election by hacking the machines in a few hundred precincts across 2 or 3 states. Still unlikey but potentially feasible given a determined, well funded adversary.

And you wouldn't have to actually flip the election to undermine it's legitimacy.

>In other words. Hacking the election is up there with the us planned 9/11

9/11 happened, so someone planned it. Very few people are worried about the US government hacking voting precincts. They're worried about a foreign government doing it.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by waqf on Monday July 31, 2017 @03:44PM (#14895270)
If an election were flipped in such a way, it would be noticeable because the candidate would lose the popular vote (since the popular vote is a robust statistic and can't be flipped without a large number of hacked machines) but would somehow happen to win by a very narrow margin in a few critical swing states.

(Of course the same is true of any other campaign technique, legitimate or illegitimate, that relies on targeting specific precincts.)

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by bpicolo on Monday July 31, 2017 @05:02PM (#14895873)
> If an election were flipped in such a way, it would be noticeable because the candidate would lose the popular vote (since the popular vote is a robust statistic and can't be flipped without a large number of hacked machines) but would somehow happen to win by a very narrow margin in a few critical swing states.

sooo exactly what happened this election, roughly?

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by jdp23 on Monday July 31, 2017 @04:20PM (#14895561)
And if an election were flipped in such a way, it would turn out to be impossible to verify the results in a recount.

http://time.com/4599886/detroit-voting-machine-failures-were...

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by learc83 on Monday July 31, 2017 @05:18PM (#14895972)
Was this sarcasm?

In case it wasn't, in the last election the candidate that won lost the popular vote by about 3 million votes. But won 3 critical swing states by about 80k votes total.

There was no widespread auditing of the voting machine code after this happened.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:50AM (#14891917)
Hacking the machines in a few hundred precincts is impossible and not more possible today than it was 10 or 20 years ago.

9/11 happened because someone outside the government planned it and it didn't need that many to work. If the US government was behind it the way the conspiracy theories are told, it would have had to involve tens of thousands of people. Hacking the election to be anything meaningful would require exactly the same thing.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by learc83 on Monday July 31, 2017 @12:54PM (#14893690)
Why would it require tens of thousands of people?

Again, if an election is close you can flip it with less than 100k votes. And even if you don't flip it, you can cast doubt on it's legitimacy if you leak some information showing what you did.

The machines are generally stored in centralized locations that aren't particularly secure.

If there are exploits that can be ran from a USB drive, one break in and you could hack machines that will be used by tens of thousands of voters.

You could potentially pay off a security guard to let a few people in or just pay someone has access to the stored machines to do it for you.

The CIA could definitely pull this off in another country, not sure why you think a foreign government couldn't do it here.

We managed to load stuxnet onto airgapped embedded computers in a high security nuclear facility. Voting machines are easy compared to that.

I have no idea why you think you need tens of thousands of people to install an exploit on a few thousand centrally stored computers, built and maintained by a few companies.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @02:15PM (#14894563)
You make it sound like those hacker movies where the bad guys have free access to networks and no security protocol around this.

Voting machines in the us isn't easy compared to that at all. Irans security protocols are easy.

As long as there is a paper trail you can't just hack the US election EVEN if you got into hacking the machine which is extremely unlikely. Unless you convinced thousands of people to be in on your scheme. It won't happen.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by learc83 on Monday July 31, 2017 @02:48PM (#14894825)
>You make it sound like those hacker movies where the bad guys have free access to networks and no security protocol around this. Voting machines in the us isn't easy compared to that at all. Irans security protocols are easy.

I'm sorry, but you have no idea what you're talking about.

>As long as there is a paper trail you can't just hack the US election

What paper trails? There is no paper backup for many of state's election machines, that's the problem.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by CydeWeys on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:21AM (#14892215)
I don't understand what makes you think some massive conspiracy would be required. With a remote exploit you wouldn't need many conspirators at all. And plenty of elections are stolen each year the old-fashioned way with a massive number of conspirators, and ... it works.
Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @11:07AM (#14892673)
Remote how? They aren't connected to the net.
Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by CydeWeys on Monday July 31, 2017 @01:12PM (#14893870)
You sure about that? Most of them have WiFi cards in them; they're connected to something, that is likely reachable from the net.

You can also imagine a single person compromising the firmware to be used in the next election to randomly flip enough votes over to a specific side to cause a win. This could be done by either an insider, or an outsider that has managed to hack the voting machine company's network.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @02:11PM (#14894517)
Yes i am sure about that.
Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by cr0sh on Monday July 31, 2017 @02:26PM (#14894650)
> 9/11 happened because someone outside the government planned it and it didn't need that many to work. If the US government was behind it the way the conspiracy theories are told, it would have had to involve tens of thousands of people.

Would it?

First off - I don't believe the evidence supports the US government doing it. I'm not saying there aren't any unanswered or uninvestigated questions, only that the evidence we do have and has been investigated doesn't support it being an "inside job". That said...

Why couldn't Bin Laden have been supplied money and plans via say the CIA or something? Obviously covertly, in such a manner that Bin Laden wasn't aware that this was being done on the behest of the CIA. If the money and such were coming from some black-ops line item in the budget, and things were kept extremely tight inside the government agency and abroad, I honestly don't think 10000+ people would be in the know, or need to be used. It could probably be done with fewer than 100 people, and if those 100 people were dedicated enough, they would likely all keep mum about it, especially if the plan succeeded.

Basically, I'm postulating on the fictional idea that there could be a group of people, high up in a government or other quasi-government agency, who are (in effect) led and acting on a hardcore fundamentalist belief system that says that (for whatever reason) the US needs to experience this attack and for it to happen in such a manner to change things. Essentially, an inside rogue terrorist cell. Perhaps it was built up over the decades since the Reagan years (or even further back), with the idea that once large enough, the plan would be carried out in such a way to not implicate them, and ultimately install their guy at the top. Kinda a slow-mo coup or something, with the attack being the illegal precursor to the takeover via legal means (because of terror and fear pushing people to vote in a much different manner - perhaps manipulated as well).

Probable? Not likely, outside of Tom Clancy novel. Possible? Well - perhaps. We've learned of stranger things in history, long after the events have passed.

Ultimately, there's no evidence for any of this being the case, and it's just a fictional possibility. But I don't think it is something that would require 10000+ people to pull off; that's only necessary if the group doing the work needs it done "now" - and isn't willing to wait decades for the final shoe to drop.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by yflu on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:02AM (#14891494)
There are far far too many links in that massive chain to trust on obscurity as security.
Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:08AM (#14891536)
Unless you can point to how someone get access to a lot of machines at one time then yes obscurity is actually a really strong method.

Furthermore it's not just obscurity it's also the other things I mentioned non-connectedness being one of the biggest.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by deif on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:25AM (#14891693)
You don't need to get access to a lot of machines. Because the chain is long and obscure, there's no way to be verifiable, and even if there was that chain would require specialist infallible programmers to ensure nothing has been tampered with.

I'm not sure how you can argue that obscurity is a strong method of security when one machine in the country could be compromised, or the counting method code could be compromised, or the programmer verifying the code could be compromised, or the distribution system of voting machines could be compromised, or any part inside the voting machines could be compromised (e.g. the touch interface), or the voting machine remains secure during the voting period (i.e. voters are tampering with it on poll day).

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @09:47AM (#14891892)
If the machines aren't connected of course you need access to a lot of machines to have any effect on an election.

All machines are hackable all systems are hackable. But focusing on the box showing you can hack that changes absolutely nothing about the overall threat of the US election being hacked. No one with serious technical understanding would claim that it was impossible to hack the boxes. And so you are back to a much harder task which is the social engineering part of convincing thousands of people to betray their country and no one finding out.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by foepys on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:07AM (#14892086)
> All machines are hackable all systems are hackable.

Then why use machines at all? As mentioned in this thread multiple times, Germany can count all votes within a few hours without any voting machines.

Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by rurban on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:53AM (#14892525)
To alter the results in a cheaper way than with traditional vote stuffing methods, as recently observed in the Turkish national referendum. https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.09839
Re:Hacking Voting Machines at Defcon by ThomPete on Monday July 31, 2017 @11:36AM (#14892933)
Since when has any of this been rational? People want digital because they think it's better or more accurate.