News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by lngnmn on Saturday July 29, 2017 @11:12PM (#14884250)
There is no such thing as Infinite outside your heads. This is actually a pattern - a false dichotomy with a pure abstraction produced as an abstract opposite or an abstract result of negation of some other concept or a named entity. Applied Hegelian nonsense if you wish.

Infinity is a pure abstraction, like zero, but ill-defined (zero is an symbol for a concept of an empty slot, absence or nothing, while infinite is mere a negation of finite). Like many other concepts it might be useful, but usability does not imply existence.

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by nabla9 on Sunday July 30, 2017 @10:06AM (#14885998)
Infinity has been well defined mathematically. Infinity well defined in calculus, set theory and logic.

For mathematical object to 'exist' only thing required is logical consistency under the rules used. Mathematical objects don't have other substance or existence than relations to other mathematical objects.

Ontological claim that abstract things that "don't exist" by some ontological definition is fine, but it does not mean much. We can't see or think anything concrete. We have never touched anything 'physical' or 'real'. It's all abstract representations in our brains.

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by lngnmn on Sunday July 30, 2017 @11:49PM (#14889342)
> For mathematical object to 'exist' only thing required is logical consistency under the rules used.

This is precisely the rule which establish existence of gods, accelerating time, higher dimensions, and other mental UFOs.

Disconnected from reality (from what is) abstract, seemingly consistent logic is what supports all the chimeras.

Read some Indian or Tibetan tantras, look at some mandalas - everything is logically consisted according to a particular sectarian logic.

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by Chris2048 on Monday July 31, 2017 @06:44AM (#14890813)
> This is precisely the rule which establish existence of gods

Can you provide a reference to that?

> Read some Indian or Tibetan tantras, look at some mandalas - everything is logically consisted according to a particular sectarian logic.

So? "sectarian logic" isn't mathematical logic.

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by lngnmn on Monday July 31, 2017 @07:33AM (#14890983)
But some mathematical logic is indeed sectarian.
Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by Chris2048 on Monday July 31, 2017 @07:55AM (#14891107)
Can you give an example?

Also, Just to clarify: Is the specific logic wrt mathematical infinity (limits etc) also used to "establish existence of gods"?

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by lngnmn on Monday July 31, 2017 @08:32AM (#14891285)
Bridging of Finite-Infinite Divide
Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by Chris2048 on Monday July 31, 2017 @10:17AM (#14892176)
What does that mean? Show me a specific example, not just a vague description.

If you mean this article, please quote the part that does that.

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by lngnmn on Sunday July 30, 2017 @11:36PM (#14889306)
> We can't see or think anything concrete. We have never touched anything 'physical' or 'real'. It's all abstract representations in our brains.

This is some sectarian preaching in my opinion. The whole thing including these very Western philosophical sects are possible exactly because something concrete definitely exist. The DNA and the laws which make it stable and the whole life on top of it is the consequence of the fact that something concrete is out there.

This, BTW, is an millennia old debate between some branches of esoteric Eastern schools and should, perhaps, be a part of seconady school lectures.

As for definitions of infinity, the theoretical possibility of infinite series, infinite small numbers or infinitely many real numbers between 0 and 1 is nothing but mental constructs. There is not a single "concrete" infinity.

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by umanwizard on Sunday July 30, 2017 @01:13AM (#14884532)
How is "zero" more of an abstraction than "five" ?
Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by rafiei on Sunday July 30, 2017 @02:09AM (#14884625)
Because typically you'd be building `five` out of `zero`, but that's more of an "implementation detail" rather than a property of `five` or `zero`. Examples are numerous:

i. Peano Axioms: (Typically) your initial element is 0 and you'll get 1 by applying the successor function to 0 and 2 by applying that to 1 and so on.

ii. Von Neumann's definition of Ordinals: {} is zero and one is {{}} and two is {{}, {{}}} and so on.

iii. Conway's definition of Surreal numbers: {|} is zero and { {|} | } is one and so on.

iv. Church encoding

and many more.

P.S. I'm not a logician and don't know whether "more of an abstraction" has any well-defined meaning and not just the meaning that might be inferred by a software developer.

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by gizmo686 on Sunday July 30, 2017 @01:21AM (#14884545)
Zero was invented long after the rest of the natural numbers (to my knowledge this is the case in every culture that independently invented zero). At least in the case of the Greeks, its status was somewhat controversial; I am not sure how other societies viewed it once it was invented.
Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by johncolanduoni on Sunday July 30, 2017 @01:31AM (#14884562)
If we find out some alien race started using positive numbers and zero at the same time, do they then become the same level of abstraction?
Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by smhost on Sunday July 30, 2017 @01:28AM (#14884557)
It would go something like:

> Zero is offensive and ungodly. With "five", at least there's something there to abstract. With zero, there's not even anything! How can nothing be something?

Cue angry biting of thumbs

Re:Mathematicians Bridge Finite-Infinite Divide by colordrops on Sunday July 30, 2017 @01:02AM (#14884516)
An orthogonal issue is that most if not all humans have a hard time distinguishing which aspects (all of them?) of their reality are just abstractions.