News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by ajross on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @11:58PM (#14862593)
The "why" is just "because the DoJ made a case before Europe or Japan". The "how" is just extradition. Greece was willing to extradite him to the US to face these charges. The US would do the same with Greece, though not with Russia as we lack an extradition treaty with Russia (and probably not to face a charge that would be a clear first amendment violation anyway).
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by olalonde on Thursday July 27, 2017 @12:23AM (#14862702)
I don't mean to be argumentative but surely no [BTC-e] US customer was a "victim" of any money laundering that may have been going on?

Edit: Since my question wasn't clear, the emphasis was on customer, as in: "customers of a business that also engages in money laundering aren't usually considered victims of that money laundering."

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by ajarmst on Thursday July 27, 2017 @12:35AM (#14862740)
Money laundering statutes do not require a discrete 'victim' with standing. They simply require the illegal manipulation of funds. In particular, disguising the origin of funds or assisting someone in doing so.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by ajross on Thursday July 27, 2017 @12:32AM (#14862727)
Uh, "surely"? It seems extraordinarily unlikely that in a $4 BILLION money laundering effort that none of that money came from sources in the US.

More to the point though: money laundering statutes were written (speaking very broadly) because they don't have to prove the underlying crime. It's criminal to be evading disclosure and tracking requirements even if all the money was obtained legally.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by olalonde on Thursday July 27, 2017 @12:39AM (#14862756)
> that money came from sources in the US

What I meant is I've been to a restaurant which turned out to be a money laundering front but I can't seriously describe myself as a victim. In fact, the food there was cheap and delicious!

But I appreciate your clarification. To rephrase what you are saying: it falls under US jurisdiction because some US persons were victims of a crime and some of that crime money ended up being traded on BTC-e (allegedly).

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by MichaelGG on Thursday July 27, 2017 @01:52AM (#14862964)
Yeah my favourite pharmacy just closed - pretty sure it was a money laundering op. Huge warehouse, fully staffed, inventory from pharmacy to electronics, hardware to perishable goods (but just random retail packages). In a couple years I've never seen more than 1 other car in the 50-space parking lot. Amazing service.

And of course there's no victims in money laundering. It's a victimless crime that has the sole purpose of helping prosecutors when they aren't able to find a real crime.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by reitanqild on Thursday July 27, 2017 @02:27AM (#14863079)
And of course there's no victims in money laundering. It's a victimless crime that has the sole purpose of helping prosecutors when they aren't able to find a real crime.

While the laundry operation is victimless it often directly assists crimes that have very real crimes:

Trafficking

Drug abusers [0]

Illegal weapons trade [1]

[0]: Esp. as since it is currently illegal they suffer a lot as getting their drugs means dealing with people you normally don't want to deal with and doing stuff you rather wouldn't do.

[1]: no, I'm still pro guns. I just don't want them sold illegally.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by atemerev on Thursday July 27, 2017 @04:28AM (#14863554)
Right. And cars manufacturers assist kidnappers and bank robbers escapes. And cell phones can be used as remote detonators. And end-to-end cryptography... no, this is an abomination, you shouldn't even think of it unless you willingly submit your private keys to the appropriate government agency for safe escrow to aid lawful investigations!

(I would have put /s here, but all these lines will be used at face value soon enough).

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by piaste on Thursday July 27, 2017 @05:58AM (#14863876)
Money laundering is knowingly assisting criminal activities. You're actively hiding where the money comes from, exactly because you know it comes from illegal sources. (If the source were legal but embarrassing, all you'd need is standard bank privacy, not active laundering.)

The car-related analogy isn't a car manufacturer. It isn't even an anonymous, stealth rental car service (although plenty of crimes could benefit from it).

The analogy is a taxi service that advertises itself as willing and able to crash through police barricades.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by justinjlynn on Thursday July 27, 2017 @06:34AM (#14864044)
Actually, no. Money laundering is generally defined as obscuring the source and/or destination of funds whatever the reason. It is a false equivalence to say that because one wants to hide the source or destination of funds that one knowingly is doing so with an illegal activity being the motivating cause. There is no such thing as "standard bank privacy" when nearly anyone in that organisation can look up your data without explicit justification or judicial review. In an era where, for corporations at least, money is speech, it certainly is limited for us mere mortals who can't setup shell corporations to sacrifice themselves for our causes.

Edit: I should be quite clear, I am neither for or against AML regulations. I, however, am for an equal playing field. I would like to see a world where the increasing quantity of money one has doesn't have an increasing effect on how many times one's vote counts at the expense of those who don't have as much. Privacy and the ability to act collectively to support unpopular opinions should not be a commodity that can be bought and sold in the form of a corporate veil.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by codedokode on Friday July 28, 2017 @04:03AM (#14872752)
> Money laundering is knowingly assisting criminal activities. You're actively hiding where the money comes from, exactly because you know it comes from illegal sources. (If the source were legal but embarrassing, all you'd need is standard bank privacy, not active laundering.)

Building an encrypted messaging app is knowingly assisting crimial activities ... all you'd need is standard communication privacy laws, not actual encryption.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by atemerev on Thursday July 27, 2017 @09:15AM (#14864911)
Like I said before, not everything that is illegal is wrong. In Germany, homeschooling is illegal. In Russia, telling teenagers that some people are gay and that's OK is illegal. The US law is a hodgepodge of contradicting legal statements which are different in different states, and many things can be counted as legal or illegal based on your wealth, political connections, race, or just luck.

Law is not a bright shiny source of truth from outer heaven, it is a sketchy framework of hacks and patches written in haste to aid people in resolving their conflicts.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by s73ver on Thursday July 27, 2017 @08:42PM (#14871040)
"Like I said before, not everything that is illegal is wrong."

But things that are illegal are... illegal.

Nobody in this thread is really debating the morality of illegal actions we're talking about. And while debating morality can be entertaining, it doesn't really change what happened here.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by reitanqild on Thursday July 27, 2017 @05:06AM (#14863669)
And cars manufacturers assist kidnappers and bank robbers escapes.

No. Because there never is any planning between the manufacturer and the bank robbers.

Remember: we are talking about money laundering operations here, not accidentally receiving stolen goods without knowing.

Can these use be abused? Yes. Very much. Should they still exist? Yes.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by atemerev on Thursday July 27, 2017 @09:21AM (#14864957)
Yes. Two questions are: did the BTC-e founder knew that he is helping to legalize proceeds for MtGox hack? Or some general hack? Or just he didn't make due diligence on the source of money and just agreed to help for a fee? And second — what authority the US government has in running the trial? Why the case is not tried in Japanese or Russian or Cyprus courts?
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by reitanqild on Thursday July 27, 2017 @12:21PM (#14866717)
I'm of no opinion here.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by MichaelGG on Thursday July 27, 2017 @09:20AM (#14864954)
That might be totally true, but money laundering as a crime itself is just a cover for prosecutors inability to find the real crimes. It's about as morally defensible as asset seizures.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by emodendroket on Thursday July 27, 2017 @09:46AM (#14865163)
That seems pretty bogus. You're telling me that you think if I operate a front business and help human traffickers launder their money (thereby helping them to cover up their crime), but don't involve myself with human trafficking itself, I've done nothing wrong, and prosecuting me would be morally indefensible?
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by MichaelGG on Thursday July 27, 2017 @11:31AM (#14866193)
Yes, the money laundering part should not be prosecutable as long as you weren't involved in any crime. The very concept that not telling the government about everything you do financially is somehow a crime is simply abhorrent.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by reitanqild on Thursday July 27, 2017 @04:52PM (#14869386)
Yes, the money laundering part should not be prosecutable as long as you weren't involved in any crime.

That is the thing: if you are knowingly working with criminals to perform their crime then you are involved in crime:

Case 1: Planning the getaway from a bank robbery. Driving the getaway car.

Criminal? yes

Case 2: Driving a taxi with a person who happened to have robbed a bank earlier that day. Getting paid in stolen cash.

Criminal? no

Case 3: Helping to carry and hide away stolen goods or physical money when you know they are stolen.

Criminal: yes

Case 4: Helping someone with anything just because you are a nice guy/gal. Afterwards it turns out you assisted in a major art heist without knowing.

Criminal: no

Case 5: Helping to launder stolen money or money from trafficking when you know or should know[0] the source.

Criminal: yes

Case 6: well at this point you either get it or not.

The very concept that not telling the government about everything you do financially is somehow a crime is simply abhorrent.

Actually here we somewhat agree. As much as I am a fan of paying tax and avoiding criminality I'm also a huge fan of cash. :-)

[0]: (Actually it is stricter now - borderline hilarious as my bank for the last twn years starts asking for my passport because of the KYC rules)

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by MichaelGG on Thursday July 27, 2017 @05:18PM (#14869664)
>[0]: (Actually it is stricter now - borderline hilarious as my bank for the last twn years starts asking for my passport because of the KYC rules) That's an issue, isn't it? Everyone can easily be in violation.

Anyways yes if you are working with the criminals that's one thing. Running a BTC exchange, if you aren't inquiring about the customers funds (you shouldn't, it's none of your business!) then it should be no issue. If you somehow know the BTC was stolen from Mt Gox, then yeah, you're helping with the hack and should be charged for that (not for money laundering, just for whatever the general charge is as a participant to a crime).

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by reitanqild on Thursday July 27, 2017 @06:22PM (#14870191)
If you somehow know the BTC was stolen from Mt Gox, then yeah, you're helping with the hack and should be charged for that

Here we agree. If they knew or should have known then they are guilty.

(not for money laundering, just for whatever the general charge is as a participant to a crime).

I think this is what money laundering originally meant:

Washing dirty money by for example using them to pay shell companies who again pay "clean" companies.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by emodendroket on Thursday July 27, 2017 @08:30PM (#14870998)
At the bottom of it the regulations create an objective standard for when you "should have known" the provenance of money, so it seems fairer to have them than not.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by s73ver on Thursday July 27, 2017 @08:44PM (#14871046)
"Yes, the money laundering part should not be prosecutable as long as you weren't involved in any crime."

Aiding criminal activity, which money laundering most assuredly is, is itself a crime.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by logfromblammo on Thursday July 27, 2017 @10:31AM (#14865625)
Yes. The crime in question is the human trafficking. Pursue and prosecute that.

If you go by the economic definitions of money, which generally include uniformity and fungibility, money laundering is really a whinge from law enforcement that police work is difficult, and can't they please go after someone who may be less dangerous and less guilty, but is much easier to catch?

You can't reasonably expect people to investigate the full history of all money they receive as payments. Merchants have the right to presume that their customers are innocent in the absence of blatantly obvious evidence to the contrary.

As they say, gold has no smell. A coin that was obtained by murdering its former owner cannot carry residual guilt from the crime. Once it is used to buy a sack of oranges at market price, it is indistinguishable from a coin that was mined and refined by devout monks, repeatedly donated to charity, sequentially blessed by all the religious figures at that bar where all the jokes happen when they walk into it, and then spent on a sack of grapefruits.

If you buy a house with 50% legit income, and 50% black market contraband profits, you don't seize half the house and claw the other half back from the previous owner. The proceeds of criminal activity attach to the criminal, not to the property. The money has no soul or conscience. It is innocent whenever the person who carries it is.

And money laundering is not a crime, in my opinion, because in order for it to be a crime, certain inaccurate assumptions about money have to be true--namely that money is not uniform and fungible. It artificially makes money from a marijuana dispensary business different from money from a pharmacy. Cash should be cash, agnostic of the sins of its bearer.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by emodendroket on Thursday July 27, 2017 @02:11PM (#14867907)
You seem to be conflating multiple issues here. As far as I know, nobody considers it money laundering to unwittingly accept money from illegal activities as payment. But I don't buy the idea that if I knowingly set out to conceal the source of ill-gotten funds then I've done nothing wrong. I've colluded with criminals to abet their crime in that scenario.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by logfromblammo on Friday July 28, 2017 @10:45AM (#14874600)
Know-your-customer laws do just that. Go to a bank with $20000 in cash and no ID, and try to open an anonymous account with it. Take that $20k to a car dealership, and try to buy a car off the lot with it. As you walk away, cops stop you and take your cash via forfeiture. The prevailing assumption seems to be that anyone carrying that much cash is a criminal. The assumption should be that cash is cash, is cash, is cash. The whole point of having it is to dispense with ledgers and accounting books in everyday commerce. They burned the tally sticks and stocks to make us use paper money, and now they want the account history back.

Money with a history is not uniform and fungible.

If you make a dollar that came from a criminal worth less than a dollar that came from a saint, you are attacking one of the foundation concepts of money.

For the sake of argument, let's say I get $1 from my crime boss for intimidating a witness. I put it in my pocket. Then I find $1 lying on the street. I put that in my pocket. Then I help an old lady put groceries in her car, and she tips me $1. I also put that in my pocket. Then I go to the convenience store and buy a pack of gum. I reach into my pocket and pull out $1. What is the source of that money?

My pocket. Most people simply don't care where that dollar came from before that. Most people have no conceivable means of knowing where it came from before that. And if they knew, they wouldn't have the recordkeeping capacity to distinguish which dollar came from which activity. They only really care that I pay for the gum instead of shoplifting or strong-arming the clerk.

But ever since the invention of forensic accounting as a crime-fighting/investigative-reporting tool, it would seem that following the money often remains a valid tactic even when other methods of investigation fail. This is because financial businesses must keep meticulous records, as a consequence of being such juicy targets for fraudsters. So all the cop has to do is pop down to the bank records office with a warrant.

So as a society, we have a choice between having money that is more suitable for open trade, and money that is more suitable for combating crimes. My personal preference is for the former. Those who would like for money laundering to be a crime in and of itself--rather than an inchoate offense dependent on other crimes--prefer the latter.

The root question is whether you believe that criminals should be allowed to participate in white-market commerce, like normal people. I do. With that opinion, their blood lucre spends the same there as all the more righteous bills. They might be discouraged from committing crimes if they are less able to profit from them, but I don't think that's the case. If you make the cost of whitewashing black market money 25% of its face value, the criminal just does more crime, or charges more for their black market stuff. It's just another cost of doing [black market] business.

If you're trying to make crime unprofitable, you really need to seize assets and revenue streams only after a conviction, and in proportion to the magnitude of the crime. Civil forfeitures with inanimate defendants and prosecuting inchoate offenses in the absence of primary offenses is just slapping justice across her blindfolded face.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by emodendroket on Friday July 28, 2017 @07:38PM (#14878457)
I think you are still confused about what constitutes money laundering. Accepting money from a criminal in exchange for goods or services is not money laundering, yet your whole post is about that.

Like, let's take the complication of know your customer out for a second. Of course you should not be prosecuted because a bank robber comes to your store and uses the money he stole to buy something. But if you are keeping fraudulent books in a cash-heavy business to conceal the source of tens of thousands of dollars you or your associates made through criminal activity, why shouldn't it be a crime?

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by conanbatt on Thursday July 27, 2017 @08:12AM (#14864498)
Money laundering is almost certainly tax evasion. On that regard, it is effectively a crime.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by MichaelGG on Thursday July 27, 2017 @09:17AM (#14864933)
Can you explain this? If someone has a bundle of cash from illegally selling drugs, then they give it to their store front to "launder" as retail income, aren't they now paying tax they wouldn't otherwise pay?
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by conanbatt on Thursday July 27, 2017 @01:00PM (#14867174)
When you earn your income, you pay a tax, and when you spend it, the business pays a tax.

In money laundering, only the retail business pays the tax, so effectively its not the equivalent taxation.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by MichaelGG on Thursday July 27, 2017 @01:51PM (#14867724)
Why would there be personal income tax on the criminal activity? Guy sells drugs but obviously can't record the profits as DrugCo's profits, so he records it as RetailCo's income. If DrugCo was legal, the taxes would be on that company instead. His personal income tax is unchanged: whatever he takes out of RetailCo is still taxed, and RetailCo pays whatever corp taxes are applicable.

The only difference is in the details of the corporate taxation. Selling meth legally might be taxed differently than laundromat services. So an ethical money launderer should look to use front businesses that have an equivalent tax rate and not take advantage of any special tax discounts that wouldn't apply to the original source.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by mirimir on Thursday July 27, 2017 @12:38AM (#14862749)
> It's criminal to be evading disclosure and tracking requirements even if all the money was obtained legally.

It was criminal to help fuel a nuclear arms race that put everyone at risk of nuclear holocaust. It was criminal to destroy Iraq for bullshit reasons. It's criminal to kill people with drones based on metadata.

But criminalizing money laundering? That's just power tripping.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by reitanqild on Thursday July 27, 2017 @02:48AM (#14863161)
I've answered this elsewhere but basically money laundering is responsible for keeping the wheels turning in a lot of real criminal activities like human trafficing and illegal weapons trade.
Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by jnbiche on Thursday July 27, 2017 @09:26AM (#14864996)
OK, so to play the devil's advocate, let's take the example of btc-e. btc-e did do a lot of business with criminal enterprises, it appears, but they also had a lot of legitimate users.

So how is that different from a restaurant deep in mob territory in some urban area that serves tons of mobsters dinner every evening? Should that restaurant be prosecuted? How about the corner grocery that serves the same mobsters? I mean, food is just as critical to surviving as money is, right?

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by reitanqild on Thursday July 27, 2017 @10:44AM (#14865753)
So how is that different from a restaurant deep in mob territory in some urban area that serves tons of mobsters dinner every evening? Should that restaurant be prosecuted? How about the corner grocery that serves the same mobsters?

No, IMO it should not be prosecuted as long as they are only serving food and getting paid the normal way.

They might very well get in trouble if they for example

start offering the mobsters empty "takeaway food" for 1000 monies,

transfer 900 monies in payment for non-existent ingredients to a shell company run by mobsters.

Warning: IANAL. And I made this example to be simple and clear. I guess you could get in trouble for less than that.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by conanbatt on Thursday July 27, 2017 @08:15AM (#14864525)
Not to go down the rabbit hole with this line of reasoning, because I would always argue that money laundering is tax evasion, but the fact that criminal activities is incidental to another activity, doesnt make the other one criminal.

As another user said, cars and guns are used for robberies, if you banned them, then you would also be curbing criminal activity.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by ambicapter on Thursday July 27, 2017 @09:20AM (#14864952)
Buying a car from a guy you know or highly suspect used the car to rob a bank and is selling it to you for the express purpose of hiding what car was used in the bank robbery sounds like a crime (or at least something that would land you in hot water).

Buying a gun from a guy that you know or highly suspect used the gun to kill a guy and is selling you the gun for the express purpose of hiding what gun was used in the murder sounds the same.

^Those are closer to what money laundering is.

Re:BTC-e and its founder charged in 21-count indictment over... by detaro on Thursday July 27, 2017 @12:41AM (#14862761)
There are victims of crimes BTC-E is claimed to help facilitate and make more viable though. And/Or there were US criminals being helped.