Whether that means every person is their own business or we try some other type of union to give workers more leverage when negotiating or we crowd-fund the resources to start a competitor to shitty company A and have all the workers walk down to a new building and start company B with 95% of the same people but better deals all-around.
Lots of ideas, very few potential solutions. I don't think the wealthy are ever going to change the game to make it easier for us plebs, so we've gotta figure out a way to play the game and beat them at it.
They don't actually, see:
Consider first Friedman’s erroneous belief that shareholders “own” corporations. Although laymen sometimes have difficulty understanding the point, corporations are legal entities that own themselves, just as human entities own themselves. What shareholders own are shares, a type of contact between the shareholder and the legal entity that gives shareholders limited legal rights. In this regard, shareholders stand on equal footing with the corporation’s bondholders, suppliers, and employees, all of whom also enter contracts with the firm that give them limited legal rights.
http://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic... [pdf]
>The issue with abandoning the maximizing the shareholders profit mentality is that it has to be replaced with something else, and unless we change the way investment works, then it will still be serving the shareholders.
But this is relatively easy! Instead of top level management being rewarded for stock price only, they should also be rewarded for other metrics, like customer satisfaction or how much they lowered the spread between median and mean wages. Hell, we could even allow it to be determined only by share price, but only the share price on a long time horizon, no sales within five years.
We should question if this is the system we want to continue to perpetuate, or on the flip side do we want more regulations and restructuring of our market economy? The question is not "More or less market?" but rather "What kind of market?"
I don't think we should abandon shareholder profit completely (after all, companies do need to make money in order to stay in business). However, I do think the philosophy needs to be balanced with other aims like investment in employees, giving back to the community, environmental stewardship, and thinking about the long-term future of the company.
Importantly, these things shouldn't be after-thoughts - they should be cornerstones of the corporate philosophy.
It's not accidental that the tie between share price and executive comp came into being.
The challenge with this approach is share price is a highly lossy metric. By the time it all rolls up into the share price, you've lost a pile of other information. And a whole hell of a lot can hide under that lost information.
Example. IBM long ago sold off their PC hardware division and low-end servers. Those divisions' low profitability was dragging down the overall profitability metrics when the total numbers bubbled up the reporting. Selling off those assets gave a cash boost, and the shareholders were especially happy when the overall profitability numbers weren't getting held back by those laggard divisions. Big win!
Now for the rest of the story. This comes from what I saw at the ground level, from speaking with many IBM sales people at the time. After the sale, extremely good, higher-end sales reps saw the front-end of their pipelines collapse. By getting rid of those "low-value" divisions, many of these reps no longer had a built-in excuse to frequently see many different accounts.
Clients had no problem frequently seeing reps for these "low-value" products. The higher-end reps lots of times tagged along and found opportunities to help solve the client's pain points with higher-end solutions by simply being in the discussions, because these low-end products, in volume, interfaced with higher-end infrastructure all the time.
Without this channel of contacting clients, these higher-end reps were reduced to cold-calling and bringing in hordes of inside sales staff to bring the cold-calling volume up to the point where they could get back to their original sales volumes. The low-profit products were making IBM a profit, just not enough, but what the shareholders really should have seen was those products were a sales and marketing channel where the clients paid for the sales and marketing to reach them. Now IBM is spending cash it can't really afford on brute-forcing that channel, which clients hate.
I see this kind of "rest of the story" game played out in many different companies under many different guises, and the destruction of company value is pretty intense when it happens.
It was a good read, and a reminder that we are all subservient to the Shareholders (directly or indirectly). The companies of the previous generation had 3 pillars that needed to be strong: Sense of Customer, Employee Satisfaction, Shareholder support. All the attention is now shifted in winning Shareholder support.
I wish we could abandon this cargo cult mentality that shareholders are the utmost important stakeholders of a company. It's already been discussed that maximizing shareholder value is meaningless: https://hbr.org/2016/09/the-false-premise-of-the-shareholder...