Just like mifeng mentioned, it really is a facts and circumstances determination per token. Given we had to build all of the token sale scaffolding (legal, tech, etc.) for Filecoin, it made sense to open this up to other technologists as well. Our hope with CoinList is that creators can focus on building awesome tech and expanding the valuable uses for application tokens while reducing the amount of time and resource they need to spend making sure they stay within the parameters of the law. Filecoin may be limited to accredited investors for this particular sale, but that's not to say other tokens that use the platform in the future would be required to do the same. Ultimately the decision is up to the creators, but they should be very well educated on the implications of what those choices could mean.
From what I've read, the SEC doesn't mandate any particular method to verify net worth. In this space, wouldn't it make sense to accept a signature proving ownership of a large ETH balance?
The FileCoin ICO will be the first CoinList ICO, seeing as it was set for 2 days from now I wonder if it will be effected. All the major crowdfunding websites seem to offer equity funding options now, and I'm curious about how they pull that off legally, but if they do, I imagine CoinList will jump through the hoops so FileCoin is compliant.
They want to leave themselves room to study the market and issue definitive guidance later. Also, these investigations cost time and money. So to discourage bad actors, they go after the most obvious offenders but it's not really in their best interest to present a positive counterpoint.
Where it gets strange is if your tokens are picked up by an exchange. What happens if someone buys your tokens with the expectation that they can sell them to someone else? Then the price of your tokens might rise, and they've made a profit. Does that count as expectation of profit?
If I understand it right, your hypothetical is just a kickstarter project where a funding level reward is a "virtual token" and just as say a reward of a t-shirt this token doesn't represent equity in the project? Would anyone expect the value of the t-shirt to go up? Is it possible, yeah actually, imagine if Apple originated through crowdfunding, I bet that original crowdfunding t-shirt might sell on the secondary market, so it all boils down to if there was a subjective belief of a profit or a reasonable personable would have expectation of profit.
In other words NINJAs (no income, no job applications) were being rubber stamped for million dollar plus homes with $0 down and 103% financing. And so prices continued to go up because the next NINJA would be approved to buy yesterday's million dollar house of 2 million today.
The same conditions don't exist with ICO tokens.
Why would the supply of money/loans increase unless people were taking out loans to buy houses more than usual, and why would they do that unless they expected the price to increase? The increase in supply of loans happened because people bought houses expecting a profit. So increase in credit supply is a secondary effect that occurs when people are more willing than usual to buy houses on credit. And people are willing to this when they expect a profit.
Because the regulations that limited supply of loans disappeared.
Consider that many more people want a million dollar home than can qualify for the loan (afford it).
Think about how much a single change in regulation would effect the number of people who can qualify for the loan/afford the $1M, example: cash down payment. How many more people can afford a $1M if the regulations for the loan approval require cash down of: 100%, 20% or -3% where the bank pays you $30,000 cash to take the $1M loan to buy the house.
Allowing people to finance 103% of a $1M home significantly changes the number of people who can act on the want (demand), to the extent supply of the homes drops and as a result their prices artificially increase supported by more bad loans.
if the token is part of or essential to a yet-to-be-developed app, but not themselves traded, I cannot see why there would be any sense of an investment. but I would in such cases never market the sale of such tokens as an ICO or crowdfunding. I would offer them up for sale, as a product pure and simple. buy now. use later.
i see it as selling an atari 2600 with no game cartridges, and then selling games later when available.
where does it say that exchanges and trading are required? (serious question...is there any such requirement?)
In particular, they apply the security test: "did investors invest money with a reasonable expectation of profits derived from managerial efforts of others?" Since DAO was a wisdom-of-crowd VC fund, the answer is a clear YES.
On the other hand, they are careful to say that other token sales MAY be securities but will be treated based on their specific facts and circumstances.
My takeaway is that this doesn't change anything. The SEC is proceeding cautiously: applying securities law in clear-cut cases, "studying the effects" generally.
It's also not a bad thing to comply with securities regulation. FileCoin is doing quite well selling only to accredited investors on CoinList.