Also, data caps are just price discrimination, which is pervasive even in highly competitive markets (and not necessarily a bad thing): http://else.econ.ucl.ac.uk/papers/uploaded/222.pdf. You walk into Home Depot and they charge you twice as much for the "Best" paint rollers versus the "Good" paint rollers. It's not because there isn't competition in the paint roller market, or because it costs twice as much to make one paint roller versus the other.
This is pretty similar to how you can't just freely add your own fiber to a utility pole, or freely build your own utility poles.
Oligopolies also appear to be the future of the American economy, with new business formation on the decline and wealth + market share concentrating under the few largest players in many industries.
So perhaps the discussion we should be having is, should we do something about oligopolies, and what? We already have antitrust laws, are they adequate? Are they being enforced?
It is a utility.
I can't go out and buy a bottle of WiFi to use how I see fit.
Now you can't have it both ways. Either you are a utility or you are not. Having competition doesn't mean you're no longer a utility.
Insofar as it might work for Home Depot, it may be due to local monopoly (competitor is not co-located) and asymmetric information (customers assume a bigger quality difference than is true). However in my experience, the price of premium tools/supplies often does reflect higher production cost these days.
Truly different goods don't have the same implications for consumer and producer surplus. That's not to say that price discrimination can't be disguised.
Capping certain websites is not price discrimination, it's website discrimination; Verizon promises a certain amount of GB per month on our phones, and capping certain websites for me when I'm still under my monthly data limit has nothing to do with my data limit and everything to do with discriminating against those websites to my and their detriment.
If you're fine with corporations turning the playing field into an uphill slant against you based on their preferences regardless of yours, then please argue for them capping limiting certain completely-legal websites they don't want to treat fairly.
There's definitely no way they could write a simple app to provide this info, and it would be crazy for them to white-list it so it didn't count against bandwidth usage :)
Social media and search seem to exhibit signs of monopoly as well.
Pull that paint roller out of your pocket and paint the wall next to you, then go to the restroom and pull it out again to paint over the graffiti on the stall wall. Then walk your dog and use it to paint the neighbors houses...
Never gunna happen. When do you need a paint roller? About once every 5 years on average, vs WIRELESS connectivity once every 5 minutes on average.
Not quite.. if they rationed milk to 250mL, but then let you buy an extra 25mL for what the first 250mL costs. They're not only creating scarcity, but then creating a market to profit from this artificial situation.
> They're not only creating scarcity, but then creating a market to profit from this artificial situation.
Seats on a plane are a limited resource.
Nowhere are IPSs offering "3mbps from 5-10 and 30mbps the rest of the day" plans. Because the cost to improve total network bandwidth is almost nothing, relative to the last mile costs. Every ISP could easily meet the full rated line bandwidth of every residential connection they have within their current margins without issue. They don't, because they have no competitive pressure to actually do anything than make sure the current service works. They have no competitors besides maybe cellular providers, who are already paying them in business contracts to attach towers to the backbone.
I've seen "off peak" data plans all over the world.
e.g. https://www.skymesh.net.au/nbn-services/fibre-to-the-premise...
$54.95
30GB Anytime Data
60GB Off Peak
50/20 Mbps*
$1.83 per GBAt (peak) times they actively traffic shape and penalize the heaviest users. It sucks, but I don't see people willing to pay the $$$ to upgrade infrastructure faster.
Do you think that everyone gets the aggregate rate they pay for? Do you think any ISP has capacity to deliver everyone their aggregate rate simultaneously? Does the combined bandwidth consumption of all customers over a given billing cycle approach the maximum theoretical bandwidth of the ISP? No, no, and no.
ISPs are charging for bandwidth like it's a commodity you buy at the store but if you buy a bag of rice at the store, the store doesn't take your left over rice at the end of the month and expect you to buy more. ISPs do though...
Make no mistake, the technical side of this has only gotten cheaper. That's before you consider the "investment" necessary to resolve the vast majority of Netflix bandwidth issues is connecting a cable from one router to another in a CIX.
Of course when you do that it becomes blatantly obvious that ISPs have oversold and overbooked capacity dramatically as we get closer and closer to the last mile to the customer. Now they don't want to pay up to actually provide what they have sold.
On one hand they don't have to compete in many place so ISPs are close to being a monopoly so they can keep charging $80 for < 1Mpbs if they want.
At the same time Moore iterations don't dig trenches and lay fiber between cities. Also frequency spectrum doesn't grow with Moore's law either.And in many instances it is still mostly a shared resource. Cable companies usually have groups of houses share the upstream bandwidth.
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1219210/000119312513...
Of course none of that ever makes it to the consumer, investment is stagnant or down and all this tech ends up achieving is accommodating higher Internet penetration (and customer counts).
Here is the DOCSIS evolution:
http://www.cablelabs.com/full-duplex-docsis/
All this cable infrastructure previously wasted on free to air crap has turned into a veritable gold mine with no further investment and tech again making up for all the growth so you don't have to spend any.
Sure, Moore isn't helping dig trenches but he sure has been tremendously helpful in turning that ole shitty copper wiring financed by Uncle Sam into a lot of green.
On what planet? I did a speedtest.net run the other day on LTE and got 150 Mbps down/20 Mbps up near a strip mall in exurban Maryland. That network did not come cheap.
Nice distraction, but no cigar.
I think the best way to figure this out is to conduct a little study: set up a script to monitor a representative sample of planes on FlightAware for a while.
We rely on the internet so much for our lives and jobs and economy and banking that it should be a utility and a right, hell, we use the internet more than our phones, and cell phones are more ubiquitous and relied upon than landlines by a longshot!
"Nobody's got to use the Internet." - Sensenbrenner
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2017/04/15/...
I can choose Sprint, T-mobile, Verizon or ATT.
What monopoly are you speaking of?
Considering the barrier to entry to becoming a cellular operator is owning spectrum, that is one of the most impossibly high barriers to usurp. Nobody has to sell you any, the owners can set whatever price they want, and there are no mechanisms to mitigate this state-created impossible to overcome monopoly on light.
Landline access, by comparison, is macro-harder and micro-easier. It is more likely you can get easement rights to run fiber on a given street than to get the right to use wavelengths of EM, but trying to get easement in an entire city can be similarly impossible.
Power is setup the same way in some states, where multiple companies share the wires. This is only because the government demands the wires be shared fairly. Its an interesting arrangement, essentially a regulated monopoly called a utility.
I see your point but as long as it's services like Netflix I hope people will not claim it as a right.
Netflix in particular is indeed not a right, and in fact Netflix charges a monthly subscription that you may or may not be able to afford. But if I pay for Netflix, I should have a right to access it, or any service I want, via my "chosen" internet service provider.
Anyway I'm making this post because I think I have a better version of the milk analogy, so here goes...
The main problem with the milk analogy is how the transactions are done. I pay the grocery store a fee for access to walk in and out of the market with a certain weight of groceries per second. Separately I pay the milk provider for all-you-can-drink access to milk.
(Alternatively, you can imagine the grocery store is one of those stores in a mall that you have to walk through to get to the rest of the mall, but I'm forced to walk in and out through their front door).
In this analogy, the grocery store should have no right to limit the amount of milk I can carry through their market, while claiming to offer access to any food by weight.
If your local grocery monopoly started rationing out milk to 250ml sold per day there would be protests, investigations, and 10 minute time blocks for it on the nightly news because the people would demand it. The internet just hasn't had this moment yet and it sucks because the momentum for this moment is building but it hasn't reached critical mass. I don't think this moment will happen for another decade at least.