The article makes out that there has been controversy about the degree of genetic cause of schizophrenia, citing tiny effects of specific genes - but that misses the point (as the article mentions, it is a polygenic disease) - at least for the last 20-30 years we've thought that there was a roughly 30% influence of our genetic make up on acquiring the disease - the environment has long been known to have an effect on acquiring and also relapsing with the disease.
Also using an anecdote of what someone remembers of their experience being admitted to a psychiatric hospital post delivery is unlikely to be useful. If she really had a psychotic episode, her memory of the event is likely going to be very patchy, and a lack of insight is a common feature of the disease. She probably received some sort of anti-psychotic as an emergency measure - I somehow doubt she smiled and agreed with the doctors to get discharged. Post-natal psychotic episodes are seen as some of the most aggressive / dangerous forms of psychosis.
The article makes some good points that psychiatrists may find they have less and less time to spend with patients, and that medication is seen as the answer to too often.
The reason I say the article is dangerous is psychotherapy and anthropology are not sciences. I think they can be used as ideas to test, but the efficacy of anti-psychotics has been proven in trials. Not effectively treating a psychotic episode can easily result in death, and anyone experiencing psychotic symptoms do need to seek proper medical help. Just hearing voices on its own is not enough to make a diagnosis of schizophrenia, but they would at least check for the other symptoms.
Anyway, maybe a psychiatrist can chime in here, it's been a while since I've been involved with anything psychiatry-related.
> Without medication there's no way to break the cycle.
Metabolic therapies break the cycle too. The simplest form of this is Niacinamide, one of the B-vitamins. Also useful are T3 thyroid, topical progesterone USP, CO2, good nutrition, etc...
I found the article to be interesting and well written, and I'm very much a strong supporter of actual science.
Mental illness is incredibly complex, and we have a long way to go in making significant progress.
EDIT: the parent comment has been edited to remove some aggressive language. Thanks, I appreciate that.
I think this is the wrong place for this piece.