I don't know about you but I feel pretty good that without any algorithmic optimizations, Bitcoin seems to have a 100x scaling potential, with a full node still remaining affordable to run by a "serious" Bitcoin individual (~$100 /month).
And with that kind of cost, forget about individuals hosting.
Also since each block is so huge, others miners will take something like 30+ seconds to validate a block leading to an unfair start on the next block. (5% of a 10 min sounds like some serious gain.)
I think the interesting thing about the government doing it is it doesn't require any coordination between miners within China. They wouldn't even necessarily know it was happening unless they looked for it.
Apples and oranges. Blocksize trade-offs are related with how decentralized the network is/will be. Off-chain is a way to build layers on top of bitcoin to allow payments to start being only sent between off-chain payment hubs, which at the very long-term will convert on-chain(layer1) transactions into more of a settlement system (instead of payment system).
This, doesn't have anything to do with developers or project governance. Even if the network is decentralized, you cannot decentralize knowledge. In opensource, meritocracy is king, and obviously it will always be like this (so long as know-how is required to solve technical problems).
As far as full nodes go, incentives are a big problem IMO: there's no direct profit in running one, so whoever runs a full node is either a hobbyist/altruist, or needs one to run a business. I don't really see what kind of user needs a full node yet is unable to pay for one, if Bitcoin is more of a high-value settlement network than a high-throughput payment network.
The point is, while blocksize has some effect on centralization I don't think it's all that big a factor in the end.
I'm not sure what you mean with your last point - that the code that gets used is always made by the developers best equipped to set economic policy? Because that is what decisions on blocksize are.
From the perspective of end users, all the Bitcoin advantages materialize only if they use it directly as a payment network; otherwise they are de-facto using something else and it doesn't really matter how that something else is settled in the background, it matters how that something else works and if it works differently than Bitcoin, they're using that and not really Bitcoin.
From the perspective of users (organizations) who need high-value settlement networks, the classic alternatives (e.g. Target2) are better than Bitcoin since the needs are quite different, and the advantages of cryptocurrencies aren't that useful for high-value settlement, they matter mostly for end users.
I disagree, blocksize is only related to decentralization/throughput trade-offs, not economic policy. The only economic policy that bitcoin has is the inflation rate, which is set in stone and very unlikely to ever change.
Bitcoin is not an economy, it's a protocol. Bitcoin does not consist of people, whereas an economy does. A planned economy is literally planning people's lives. An agreed-upon constant in a protocol is not related to this.
Please spare us the pure unsubstantiated and uninformed conjecture.
Obviously yes? I think you will have to explain it anyway since the block size cap does not affect mining difficulty.
What remains unknown, however, is whether this form of clearing network will be sufficient to scale Bitcoin payment processing to a sufficient degree. This is yet to be determined. In other words: can LN support a billion users doing ~50k TPS while keeping fees per payment at or below VISA fees?
The Lightning Network is not a solution that allows scaling Bitcoin payments to an arbitrary high throughput and arbitrarily low payment fee. LN has a limit on throughput and a minimum bound on average fee, and what that is for a LN network with N payers and M payees we simply don't know yet. For example: what will the maximum throughput, and average fee, of an LN network with 10 million payers and 10 thousand payees be?
Also, LN requires larger blocks if it wants to scale anything at all. You need to get your coins to and from it you know.
Once LN works people will need to do this every few weeks, months, or even years.
There is no technical reason for the limitation, no limits of bottlenecks have been reached now that the blocks are full and anyone could see that bitcoin as it stands takes very little CPU power and very little bandwidth to sync with the chain. If you can watch a stream on twitch or youtube, you can sync with bitcoin's chain with lots of bandwidth to spare.
Seeing that there is trivial resource usage currently and that the 1MB block size limit was chosen arbitrarily, that seems incredibly unlikely.
When I say there isn't a scaling problem and you say 'there has to be something to stop spam' these two things are not mutually exclusive. The fact that you haven't distinguished between one or the other is why FUD and propaganda works so well with bitcoin at this stage.
For a simple user, it's not worth to keep all blockchain, because it does not matter. they can't change it or include transaction into a new block if they not mining.
Bitcoin simply doesn't scale very well because of the way transaction history need sto be stored. As long as the rate of blockchain growth can't be significantly reduced, transaction rate can't grow very much.
So small block proponents are likely to be right in that on-chain scaling is unrealistic, but if the market must be forced by developers to adhere to an artificial limit, I think that in itself implies Bitcoin is unlikely to be able to grow very far as the market is unable to self-regulate.