Re:Bitcoin May Have Solved Its Scaling Problem
by h1d on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:14PM
(#14829958)
100mbps guaranteed is not the same as best effort. Besides it's an average which would max out on bandwidth from time to time unable to process data at full speed.
And with that kind of cost, forget about individuals hosting.
Also since each block is so huge, others miners will take something like 30+ seconds to validate a block leading to an unfair start on the next block. (5% of a 10 min sounds like some serious gain.)
Re:Bitcoin May Have Solved Its Scaling Problem
by kalleboo on Saturday July 22, 2017 @07:00AM
(#14826526)
From what I've read, one of the issues is that it's very difficult to maintain that extra bandwidth through the Great Firewall of China, resulting in any miners on the other side of where the block was found being at a disadvantage as they will get the blocks too late to be competitive. This will result in mining finally being 100% concentrated in China.
Re:Bitcoin May Have Solved Its Scaling Problem
by tlrobinson on Saturday July 22, 2017 @08:28AM
(#14826854)
This begs the question: couldn't the Chinese government intentionally delay even small (outgoing) blocks to give Chinese miners an advantage (with either benign or malicious motives)?
Re:Bitcoin May Have Solved Its Scaling Problem
by kalleboo on Saturday July 22, 2017 @09:51AM
(#14827198)
Or not even the government but the miners themselves... "Oh our connection is slow [stands strategically in front of router QoS settings]"
Re:Bitcoin May Have Solved Its Scaling Problem
by tlrobinson on Saturday July 22, 2017 @11:09AM
(#14827558)
That's basically what the "selfish mining" attack is, isn't it?
I think the interesting thing about the government doing it is it doesn't require any coordination between miners within China. They wouldn't even necessarily know it was happening unless they looked for it.
Re:Bitcoin May Have Solved Its Scaling Problem
by z3t4 on Saturday July 22, 2017 @05:55AM
(#14826302)
you want as many miners as possible or the whole network will be in danger when there are only a few miners having 50% of the mining power. it would be grate if smartphones could mine when they are charging or idle, and also run a full node and make transactions.
I don't know about you but I feel pretty good that without any algorithmic optimizations, Bitcoin seems to have a 100x scaling potential, with a full node still remaining affordable to run by a "serious" Bitcoin individual (~$100 /month).