News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by gumby on Thursday July 20, 2017 @02:56PM (#14815298)
The big crime is how little epistemological support there is for some of the big forensic tools (fingerprints, DNA, bite marks, arson spread, etc), how little interest there is in researching these areas, and how trusted they are.

But I am curious: apart from TV shows, how important is this kind of evidence in most trials? Is it actually uncommon?

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by ch4s3 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:05PM (#14815388)
From what I understand DNA has gotten pretty good when used responsibly, but the rest are no better than reading a chicken's entrails. Have I perhaps been misinformed about DNA?
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by rayiner on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:45PM (#14816134)
The problem with DNA is that the theoretical random match probability gets thrown at the jury (like one in whatever billion), while in reality the error rate is dominated by lab error (like one in a hundred). But judges tend to exclude evidence of lab error rates (I guess to avoid people thinking the other way, that DNA isn't reliable).
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by neaden on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:49PM (#14816170)
There is also the problem of multiple comparisons when they check DNA against a database the probability of randomly finding a match goes up.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by leephillips on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:08PM (#14816317)
It's one version of the epidemiological fallacy. My impression, which may be wishful thinking, is that prosecutors are better educated about these things now and that this kind of thing is less common.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by barrkel on Thursday July 20, 2017 @07:19PM (#14817000)
AFAIK prosecutors are motivated by convictions, not justice.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by leephillips on Thursday July 20, 2017 @09:31PM (#14817479)
I've heard plenty of anecdotes that suggest that this is true of many prosecutors, but other anecdotes showing that there are also good ones out there.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by rayiner on Friday July 21, 2017 @02:09PM (#14822599)
Viewing it "good ones" versus "bad ones" terms is misleading. Prosecutors work in situations where (1) they constantly view the worst aspects of society; (2) the bulk of their job involves people who are obviously guilty.[1] There's some prosecutors who are just downright unethical. But for the most part, within the model of "better to let X guilty people go free than to put Y innocent people in prison," prosecutors are people who select different numbers for X and Y than other people.

I think juries should be clearly educated on the limitations of DNA testing, and other kinds of forensic evidence should be banned. Then again, I recognize that for every person unjustly convicted based on lab error, there are a dozen who just want to throw that possibility out there hoping to confuse the jury enough to get an acquittal.

[1] Courtrooms are open to the public, and I'd encourage everyone to go to your local federal courthouse and sit in on a dozen sentencing proceedings.

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by ch4s3 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:04PM (#14816283)
Ahh, this post and the reply are both really interesting.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by pyre on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:14PM (#14815450)
Is comparing fingerprints really "no better than reading a chicken's entrails?" I could understand things like trying to guess based on similarities with a partial print, but comparing two full prints seems like it would be pretty easy.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by ch4s3 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:25PM (#14815534)
You would think, but even "experts" on fingerprinting call it at best an art. It can be affected by bias[1], and there's no standard for declaring a match[2](same case as [1]).

> I could understand things like trying to guess based on similarities with a partial print

That's really the rub, pun intended I guess, there are no clean neatly pressed fingerprints left on object collected by police, generally speaking.

[1]http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2211368113...

[2]http://www.cbsnews.com/news/fingerprints-infallible-evidence...

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by wyldfire on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:21PM (#14816397)
The stuff in this thread about fingerprints matching algorithms and DNA lab errors -- does that mean we shouldn't even use it as exculpatory evidence?
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by Retric on Thursday July 20, 2017 @10:23PM (#14817634)
It's easier for evidence to say the person is innocent than guilty. Ex: a blurry video of a white guy. It's in no way enough to show which white person did it, but it is enough to show no black person did.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by ch4s3 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @10:08PM (#14817586)
The top comment under which my comment falls is about police use of forensic "science".

>The big crime is how little epistemological support there is for some of the big forensic tools (fingerprints, DNA, bite marks, arson spread, etc), how little interest there is in researching these areas, and how trusted they are. But I am curious: apart from TV shows, how important is this kind of evidence in most trials? Is it actually uncommon?

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by maxxxxx on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:24PM (#14815515)
Some years ago I worked on a project where they wanted to do fingerprint classification and comparison with computer vision. I was amazed how much human judgment is involved in the process. Even with full prints a lot is up to the examiner and two examiners won't necessarily give you the same result.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by NumberSix on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:24PM (#14815523)
Regarding fingerprints, in the wake of the Brandon Mayfield case which raised serious questions about the accuracy of fingerprint identification by the FBI, the National Academy of Sciences was asked to perform a scientific assessment. Initial results were published in:

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)

Bradford T. Ulery, 7733–7738, doi: 10.1073/pnas.1018707108

Accuracy and reliability of forensic latent fingerprint decisions

Bradford T. Ulerya, R. Austin Hicklina, JoAnn Buscagliab,1, and Maria Antonia Robertsc

Edited by Stephen E. Fienberg, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, and approved March 31, 2011 (received for review December 16, 2010)

ABSTRACT

The interpretation of forensic fingerprint evidence relies on the expertise of latent print examiners. The National Research Council of the National Academies and the legal and forensic sciences communities have called for research to measure the accuracy and reliability of latent print examiners’ decisions, a challenging and complex problem in need of systematic analysis. Our research is focused on the development of empirical approaches to studying this problem. Here, we report on the first large-scale study of the accuracy and reliability of latent print examiners’ decisions, in which 169 latent print examiners each compared approximately 100 pairs of latent and exemplar fingerprints from a pool of 744 pairs. The fingerprints were selected to include a range of attributes and quality encountered in forensic casework, and to be comparable to searches of an automated fingerprint identification system containing more than 58 million subjects. This study evaluated examiners on key decision points in the fingerprint examination process; procedures used operationally include additional safeguards designed to minimize errors. Five examiners made false positive errors for an overall false positive rate of 0.1%. Eighty-five percent of examiners made at least one false negative error for an overall false negative rate of 7.5%. Independent examination of the same comparisons by different participants (analogous to blind verification) was found to detect all false positive errors and the majority of false negative errors in this study. Examiners frequently differed on whether fingerprints were suitable for reaching a conclusion.

http://www.pnas.org/content/108/19/7733.full

Authors

Bradford T. Ulery

aNoblis, 3150 Fairview Park Drive, Falls Church, VA 22042;

R. Austin Hicklin aNoblis, 3150 Fairview Park Drive, Falls Church, VA 22042;

JoAnn Buscaglia bCounterterrorism and Forensic Science Research Unit, Federal Bureau of Investigation Laboratory Division, 2501 Investigation Parkway, Quantico, VA 22135; and

Maria Antonia Roberts cLatent Print Support Unit, Federal Bureau of Investigation Laboratory Division, 2501 Investigation Parkway, Quantico, VA 22135

One might wonder why such an assessment was not done a long time ago.

This is a report on the Brandon Mayfield case:

https://oig.justice.gov/special/s0601/exec.pdf

Bottom line is fingerprints are much more accurate than chicken entrails but hardly infallible as used to be widely believed.

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by mncharity on Thursday July 20, 2017 @09:59PM (#14817554)
Fingerprint identification: advances since the 2009 National Research Council report https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4581003/ has a recent summary.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by NumberSix on Friday July 21, 2017 @12:35AM (#14818090)
Just a comment, whether a 0.1 percent false positive rate is "small" is a subjective value judgement. Would you drive across a bridge that had a 1 in 1000 (0.1 percent) chance of collapsing and killing you as you drove across it? No, probably not.

In addition, the 0.1 percent false positive rate is based on a small sample of around 1000 cases. The Federal fingerprint databases such as the ones used in the Brandon Mayfield case have millions of people in them and may eventually have all US citizens (over 300 million people) in them. How does this "small" rate extrapolate when a fingerprint is compared to every fingerprint in the US or the world?

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by bsder on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:28PM (#14816445)
First, we have no idea how "unique" fingerprints actually are. Silly, eh?

Second, have we programmed a computer to do it? At this point, something like "fingerprint analysis" should be quite open to machine learning. If we can't program a machine to do it, then probably humans aren't actually accurate either.

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by pessimizer on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:54PM (#14816209)
The problems with DNA are contamination and prosecutorial overstatement of probabilities.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by mncharity on Thursday July 20, 2017 @09:35PM (#14817487)
> how little epistemological support

An introduction with links (caveat Frontline): http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/forensic-tools-wha...

Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward (2009), Summary: https://www.nap.edu/read/12589/chapter/2 This https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4581003/ puts it in more recent context.

> arson spread

For example: "Progress" In Fire Investigation: Moving from Witchcraft and Folklore to the Misuse of Models and the Abuse of Science[2](PDF; not as good as the title; depressing) from [3].

> how little interest there is

One challenge is the forensic expert "system" is extremely heterogeneous. In funding, honesty and integrity, professionalism, research, oversight and regulation.

> how important is this kind of evidence in most trials

And since most "trials" are plea bargains, how important in pleas?

And the US plea bargain system is its own pit of systemic dysfunction.

[2] http://www.firescientist.com/Documents/PROGRESSIN%20FIRE%20I... [3] http://www.firescientist.com/publications.php

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by dragonwriter on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:18PM (#14815475)
> But I am curious: apart from TV shows, how important is this kind of evidence in most trials?

I think it's fairly widely used as part of the evidence, but I don't think statistics are kept, and even if they were it's hard to know how important it is in convincing juries. When the issue with fiber analysis and the admission of it's nesr complete lack of validity by the FBI broke, there were hundreds of criminal convictions, dozens of death penalty convictions, and several who had already received the death penalty identified directly tied to FBI testimony on fiber analysis, and concerns of tens of thousands of convictions based on work by locsl, FBI-trained, fiber analysts.

So, its at least not insignificant in potential impact.