Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ...
by dragonwriter on Thursday July 20, 2017 @03:18PM
(#14815475)
> But I am curious: apart from TV shows, how important is this kind of evidence in most trials?
I think it's fairly widely used as part of the evidence, but I don't think statistics are kept, and even if they were it's hard to know how important it is in convincing juries. When the issue with fiber analysis and the admission of it's nesr complete lack of validity by the FBI broke, there were hundreds of criminal convictions, dozens of death penalty convictions, and several who had already received the death penalty identified directly tied to FBI testimony on fiber analysis, and concerns of tens of thousands of convictions based on work by locsl, FBI-trained, fiber analysts.
So, its at least not insignificant in potential impact.
I think it's fairly widely used as part of the evidence, but I don't think statistics are kept, and even if they were it's hard to know how important it is in convincing juries. When the issue with fiber analysis and the admission of it's nesr complete lack of validity by the FBI broke, there were hundreds of criminal convictions, dozens of death penalty convictions, and several who had already received the death penalty identified directly tied to FBI testimony on fiber analysis, and concerns of tens of thousands of convictions based on work by locsl, FBI-trained, fiber analysts.
So, its at least not insignificant in potential impact.