News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by rayiner on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:45PM (#14816134)
The problem with DNA is that the theoretical random match probability gets thrown at the jury (like one in whatever billion), while in reality the error rate is dominated by lab error (like one in a hundred). But judges tend to exclude evidence of lab error rates (I guess to avoid people thinking the other way, that DNA isn't reliable).
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by neaden on Thursday July 20, 2017 @04:49PM (#14816170)
There is also the problem of multiple comparisons when they check DNA against a database the probability of randomly finding a match goes up.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by leephillips on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:08PM (#14816317)
It's one version of the epidemiological fallacy. My impression, which may be wishful thinking, is that prosecutors are better educated about these things now and that this kind of thing is less common.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by barrkel on Thursday July 20, 2017 @07:19PM (#14817000)
AFAIK prosecutors are motivated by convictions, not justice.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by leephillips on Thursday July 20, 2017 @09:31PM (#14817479)
I've heard plenty of anecdotes that suggest that this is true of many prosecutors, but other anecdotes showing that there are also good ones out there.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by rayiner on Friday July 21, 2017 @02:09PM (#14822599)
Viewing it "good ones" versus "bad ones" terms is misleading. Prosecutors work in situations where (1) they constantly view the worst aspects of society; (2) the bulk of their job involves people who are obviously guilty.[1] There's some prosecutors who are just downright unethical. But for the most part, within the model of "better to let X guilty people go free than to put Y innocent people in prison," prosecutors are people who select different numbers for X and Y than other people.

I think juries should be clearly educated on the limitations of DNA testing, and other kinds of forensic evidence should be banned. Then again, I recognize that for every person unjustly convicted based on lab error, there are a dozen who just want to throw that possibility out there hoping to confuse the jury enough to get an acquittal.

[1] Courtrooms are open to the public, and I'd encourage everyone to go to your local federal courthouse and sit in on a dozen sentencing proceedings.

Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by ch4s3 on Thursday July 20, 2017 @05:04PM (#14816283)
Ahh, this post and the reply are both really interesting.