News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by jve on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @02:19AM (#14802305)
I'm wondering about the legal side of this. Is it OK from LEGO side to have stuff like this and other similar tools?

And what if when you start printing stuff like that?

Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by kuschku on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @02:41AM (#14802385)
LEGO’s patents expired a while ago, and competitors such as KREO have replicated the shapes and some of the models already.

That said, no one is going to print LEGO – actual LEGO is a lot more robust and stable than anything you could print yourself.

Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by jve on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @03:58AM (#14802624)
Oh, I see. But replicating the existing plastic cube was not what I actually thought. I thought: what if I print/manufacture lego mega blocks from whatever material.
Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:48PM (#14808292)
You can't make "Lego bricks" as Lego is the trademark giving the origin of specific bricks but you can make near identical (missing the wording "Lego") bricks if you wish. If you do it at home and completely without any commercial aspect [giving them away can be commercial, so you have to take great pains to avoid being commercial] then you can make identical ones AFAICT.

This isn't legal advice of course.

Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by amelius on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @07:31AM (#14803521)
Don't they have design-patents on the newer bricks?
Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by verinus on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @03:52AM (#14802605)
While you can print LEGO there are several reasons not to: * you cannot print as precisely as LEGO bricks- so the quality is not the same * there are ugly layer bumps on the stones * the effort required * LEGo bricks are relatively cheap
Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by jandrese on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @10:36AM (#14804538)
As other people have mentioned it is generally not worth it, however I have seen some people print blocks that don't exist in traditional Lego sets. An example is a block consisting of three 2x8 flats joined in an equilateral triangle on the short edge.

Presumably you need to set your printer to its slowest and most precise mode to get a usable block.

Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by Renderbricks on Sunday July 23, 2017 @02:16PM (#14833574)
The LEGO Group has some rules under Play Fair on their website:

https://www.lego.com/en-us/legal/legal-notice/fair-play

The patent for the bricks ended in 1988. But the Minifigures have a copyright. As long as you don't use all this for commercial purposes and profit they are very relaxed. Because their fans and community are a very important part of the LEGO brand.

Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by cyphar on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @02:46AM (#14802403)
I believe the tolerances on Lego for it to be "just right" are fairly narrow, and most 3D printers aren't precise enough (but I could be mistaken).

It is likely that Lego has patents on parts of their brick design, so you could be in a fairly bad legal minefield if Lego decides to sue you. Also I'm not sure that describing your project as "a tool for designing Lego" is a good idea.

Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by Nullabillity on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @05:24AM (#14802967)
> I believe the tolerances on Lego for it to be "just right" are fairly narrow, and most 3D printers aren't precise enough (but I could be mistaken).

Yup, the Lego tolerances are ridiculously tight, even for injection molding. 3D printing will generally give you results far worse than even the sloppiest injection molding process.

> It is likely that Lego has patents on parts of their brick design, so you could be in a fairly bad legal minefield if Lego decides to sue you. Also I'm not sure that describing your project as "a tool for designing Lego" is a good idea.

Lego's patents expired in 1989, that's why we now have stuff like MegaBloks. Lego did try to trademark their studded bricks, but that was shut down by the ECJ and others.

Re:LeoCAD – A CAD program for creating virtual Lego models by cr1895 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @07:03AM (#14803412)
>believe the tolerances on Lego for it to be "just right" are fairly narrow

As far as I'm aware this is quite an understatement. The tolerances and consistency of lego pieces is impressive, to say the least.