But that's not to say I don't want a better solution!
Workout logging is primarily an exercise (pun not intended) in intense user experience design. The designer must understand the task context.
There's one killer input modality in my mind -- an Apple Watch.
I have no issue wearing a watch while I'm working out. And it'd be fantastic if an app could:
- Track my daily exercise ordering (i.e. it knows what I'm supposed to do next)
- Show my rep/weight history for the current exercise and allow input of results after sets
- Monitor and record my HR throughout my workout and estimate my rest intervals/vibrate when my rest interval is up
- Offer alternative exercises when requested
- Etc.
There's so much you could do with a watch as the primary mode of input.
The watch is what you use in the gym. And the computer/tablet is what you use for analysis later.
If someone were to execute this properly, I'd be all over it.
Speaking for me: I need to track partial sets, shady reps, circle training setups and posture/alignment/speed reminders/observations to myself. Free text works best; the last thing I want to do when I'm shaking and sweating profusely is diddle around with how to enter something in a convoluted app setup. (To be fair, I do my "creative", i.e. SW design/architecture notetaking mostly on paper, too.)
1) A timer - tracks rest periods (1.5 mins, 3 mins, 5 mins) and alerts when rest is over
2) set/rep tracking - I just want to know which set I am on and how many are left
everything else is icing on the cake. Would love a smart watch app that can track rests and sets/reps and upload to spreadsheet/db, which I could access from my phone or laptop once I'm home.
The biggest annoyance to me currently is having to take phone out of pocket, unlock it, tap to log.
I still leave my phone in the locker, take my iPod from 2007 for music and log my workouts on pen/paper.
Recently, I've been hitting some plateaus and I desperately wanted to see what my progress has been over the years as a motivator and that's what lead me to make Ewolo.
I'm starting to use it to log workouts directly in the gym but old habits die hard, haha.
Cheers,
One reason is that training regimes differ a lot - a single app is unlikely to be a good for strength training (training is build around 3-5 big movements with a few auxiliary exercises), body-building (more movements) and crossfitting.
Other reason is that convenience of pen and paper input is still hard to beat, and for reason or another, people don't get enough value from the digital views to their training history and performance.