News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by _jn on Friday July 14, 2017 @09:11PM (#14774491)
This whole article is based on the presumption that the interiors of driverless taxis won't be recorded... and yet security cameras in Ubers already exist[0] (and aren't dissuaded by the company)

[0]: https://uberpeople.net/threads/security-camera.52864/

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by ilaksh on Friday July 14, 2017 @09:27PM (#14774535)
Right and the other part is how do you know when the footage needs to be reviewed?

Just add two buttons to the app "minor cleanliness issue" and "major cleanliness issue". Then someone remotely checks the footage. If it is confirmed then the previous passenger gets charged a cleaning fee. Majors cost more or could result in ban. Cleaning can be done by carwashes.

Eventually you develop some clever covers and devices/stations that enable rapid cleaning.

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by btb on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:13AM (#14775783)
> how do you know when the footage needs to be reviewed?

With all the computing power and vision AI available in such a vehicle, it seems like it would be possible to perform an automated interior scan of the cabin after each ride. Detecting cleanliness issues(and forgotten baggage).

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by maturz on Saturday July 15, 2017 @09:37AM (#14776553)
Might be difficult to detect if someone peed though unless you can make the interior highlight it somehow. Maybe a moisture detector could be added but could be difficult to calibrate that for rainy days.
Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by gambiting on Saturday July 15, 2017 @04:31AM (#14775657)
Interior of the local metro trains is recorded from every possible angle you can think of, yet almost every night they turn into garbage cans on wheels. The problem is always reviewing the footage, finding the culprit and making them pay. If an automated taxi comes back to the depot after 12 hours of driving and you find it in a messy state, are you just going to pay someone $50 to clean it, or are you going to spend time reviewing 12 hours of footage to find out who made the mess and then spend weeks trying to get the money back?

Which of course creates a self-perpetuating problem, because if the behaviour is not punished, it will never be corrected and it will become "ok" to make a mess in an auto taxi(not vomit, but just leaving your rubbish behind).

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by pg314 on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:35AM (#14775840)
You're anonymous in a metro train. You're not in a self-driving car.

As others have mentioned, the app can have a button to report a cleanliness issue. Working back from the first report means you don't have to review 12 hours of footage. As a side note (since this is HN), you don't have to review 12 hours linearly, you can use a binary search, which means you can probably find the culprit in minutes at most.

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by EliRivers on Saturday July 15, 2017 @04:49AM (#14775721)
or are you going to spend time reviewing 12 hours of footage to find out who made the mess and then spend weeks trying to get the money back?

Fortunately, I can get that done for me at a cost of much, much less than 12 hours of my own time. I can farm it out overseas to somewhere with a large supply of very cheap labour. I wouldn't be surprised if sitting in front of a bank of a half-dozen taxi-interior replays running backwards at triple-speed (with the empty periods already taken out by some relatively simple processing) from a point at which the uncleanliness is visible was seen as a good job, compared to some other options available.

Wouldn't be surprised if I could have that done for me at a cost of a few dollars a time; if I then charge the culprit a hundred bucks on their already registered credit card or taxi account for cleaning (fifty sounds too low), it becomes very economical for me.

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by phire on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:25AM (#14775806)
Triple speed?

You know exactly what time your customers entered and left the vehicle. All you have to do is pull out a set of freeze frames from before and after each customer and compare the two.

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by Sharlin on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:04AM (#14775915)
This is basically a git bisect. You don't even have to linearly check every customer, you can do a binary search in log time.
Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by EliRivers on Saturday July 15, 2017 @10:05AM (#14776652)
So it's even cheaper. Great. However the fuck it's done. The point is that it's really cheap. Still, this is the HN comment tax.
Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by gambiting on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:07AM (#14775767)
Ok, then the customer does a chargeback on their credit card insisting they didn't do the mess, and you have to sit down and actually watch the footage because you can't be certain if your $5/hour overseas firm did a good job or if they just selected a random passenger to get it done quicker. Inconveniently, they also did the chargeback at the last possible moment(say a month after) so you don't have the recording anymore. Or maybe the video is not that clear what happened.

I mean, we have to deal with shitty customers all the time. 99% of the time it's just not worth pursing someone who broke something or just left a mess, even if theoretically I could hunt down proof that they did it. It almost always escalates to some multi-month situation that is not worth the effort.

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by kalleboo on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:20AM (#14775799)
Just take the Google approach: ban them from the app and don't have any phone support.
Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by Johnythree on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:20AM (#14776308)
It gets reported, so you clean it, and flag the previous occupant.

If someone becomes a multiple offender, you ban them.

Simple.

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by wisty on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:02AM (#14776246)
Computer vision makes this really easy. And having the customer's credit card on file makes enforcement a lot simpler.
Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by gambiting on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:26AM (#14776326)
I'm extremely curious how "computer vision makes this really easy". Is there a system which can already do that, or are you talking about a hypothetical system where all cars are identical, the camera always has perfect lighting and which can tell vomit apart from a crisp bag on the seat. Having the customer's credit card works only until they do a chargeback, and then you have to go through a long and unpleasant process of proving that yes, it was absolutely, definitely them who made the mess.
Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by DanBC on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:31AM (#14776346)
> and then you have to go through a long and unpleasant process of proving that yes, it was absolutely, definitely them who made the mess

The cars are going to have cameras constantly running in them.

Re:Self-Driving Taxis Will Become the Most Disgusting Spaces... by _jn on Saturday July 15, 2017 @10:52AM (#14776914)
If this really becomes an issue, (and assuming companies manage to coordinate) you could simply require a one-time security deposit around $50–100 to be sent from a bank account. Voilà, no chargebacks.