It's a U.S. site; of course they don't put the qualifier "American" on everything, for the same reason programming languages have namespaces. HN's case is different, since we're obviously an international community, but (a) readers here are smart enough to disambiguate things, and (b) the internationalness of the site means we all need to be particularly respectful when talking about each other's countries.
American internet has a very strong and direct impact on 'international' internet. Aside from the fact that a large fraction of international traffic passes through American switches or servers, America is a policy leader to many other nations - both passively and actively. Passively by signalling to telcos in other nations that they could probably attempt the same thing, and actively by forcing some of these provisions as part and parcel of trade agreements.
You just can't pretend that the impact these decisions will be isolated to the US.
Don't get me wrong, we need everybody's help we can get for this, but if they were trying to do the same in Germany it would be written by Germans, in German, and be targeting a German audience.
THOUGHT EXPERIMENT: Imagine an ISP writing some text about "the American Internet". Imagine that it gives the impression of the American Internet being isolated. That foreign entities shouldn't worry (or lobby), because changes to American law or regulation will have no impact on the rest of the world.
In this scenario, I imagine there would be lots of comments about American arrogance. About how the Internet is more interconnected than that. About how ignorant Americans are, for not realizing that other nations' data flows through our pipes, and is subject to the whims of our legislators and regulators, etc.
People on HN are always so bothered by everything. Too often on posts, you have to scroll halfway down the page to find any substantive, non-meta discussion... rather than arguments about font selection or CSS layout, or various political tangents that people find more interesting. At any rate, the U.S. is deserving of so many legitimate criticisms, the imagined grievance in this sub-thread is flatly absurd.
The companies, the entrepreneurs that would be affected could move their operations just the same way.
"Wilders' public admiration for Trump was ultimately his downfall because the American's radical, chaotic policies go too far even for his own most loyal followers -- not to mention the many swing voters who had sympathized with him."
http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/why-mark-rutte-wo...
>American internet, others will be fine
Yeah, because what happens in America doesn't affect anyone else...
You can say the same about almost every other nation on this planet. Where are the outrages against Russia, China, Saudi Arabia, France, Great Britain, ...?
Are they even US companies anymore?
Can you elaborate on this?
For example, news.ycombinator.com is decidedly us based your electric company is not but you spend more time on hacker news than paying your electricity bill.
The articles and commenters are from all around the world.
Part of the beauty of the internet is that it does not care about or even see geographical or political borders. Saying the internet is "basically an American institution" makes no sense.
[1] http://www.vertoanalytics.com/why-china-beats-the-u-s-in-mob... [2] http://technode.com/2017/04/07/alipay-leads-chinas-third-par...
"This is a battle for the Internet's future." - just American internet's future
"Team Cable want to control & tax the Internet" - they will be able to control the global system in which the US is just a part of?
"If we lose net neutrality, the Internet will never be the same" - American internet, others will be fine