News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by FiloSottile on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:03AM (#14741689)
I am just a passenger, but this looks very over-blown. A pilot aligned with the taxiway, that's bad. But no pilot would ever land on a runway (or taxiway) with 3 planes on it. Just search the Aviation Herald for "runway incursion". And indeed, he spotted them, communicated, went around.

Aviation safety margins are so wide that this does not qualify as a near-miss.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by csours on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:21AM (#14741754)
> Aviation safety margins are so wide that this does not qualify as a near-miss.

I think you have this kind of backwards here. If you were going in for an amputation, and they only prepped the wrong leg, would that not be a near miss?

Rare incidents are hard to reason about and measure because they are so rare; but there are things that lead up to rare events - like being on approach to the wrong runway, that are less rare, and so they are easy to measure.

After you have plans and procedures to stop the actual rare disasters, reducing near misses is the most effective way to stop disasters.

> But no pilot would ever land on a runway (or taxiway) with 3 planes on it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenerife_airport_disaster

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by FiloSottile on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:28AM (#14741773)
> After you have plans and procedures to stop the actual rare disasters, reducing near misses is the most effective way to stop disasters.

Oh, full +1. This is a bad incident that should result in an investigation and maybe safety recommendations.

My point is that aviation has been at it for so long, that a "bad incident" is very far removed from what the common interpretation of "near miss could have triggered greatest disaster" (#1 on HN) would suggest to a random observer.

(And I think the author knew it, and went for clickbait.)

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by mnm1 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:53AM (#14741875)
Maybe, the author went for the clickbait, but only 584 people have to die for this to be the worst airline disaster in history. With potentially five planes involved, if he had crashed, I think that'd be highly likely in this situation.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by dx034 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:46AM (#14742082)
Tenerife was very different. Here, the aircraft were at the beginning of the runway and clearly visible. In Tenerife, aircraft were at different part of the runway and couldn't see each other until it was too late. That's not comparable.

We know from the recording that the pilot saw planes on the taxiway and asked the tower about it. He would've never landed there after the tower confirmed that the runway should be empty.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by will_hughes on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:48AM (#14741848)
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by lisper on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:40AM (#14741822)
I'm a private pilot who has flown into SFO once, and flies over SFO on a regular basis (I'm based at Palo Alto airport). This is not being overblown. If you listen to the audio tape, the tower orders the go-around at the 33 second mark, and United 1 reports that "Air Canada flew directly over us" 16 seconds later. That is a breathtakingly close call.

Safety margins are wide when pilots don't screw up. But this one did. Royally.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by dotancohen on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:09AM (#14741933)
> Safety margins are wide when pilots don't screw up. But this one did. Royally.

And the safety margin was wide enough to absorb that screw up.

This is _why_ we have wide safety margins. So that one screw up doesn't absorb all of it. People will always screw up, and policy accounts for that fact.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by wfunction on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:33AM (#14742021)
Can you tell me what the second safety margin that kicked in here and saved them was? Seems to me that it was another pilot noticing them and asking "Where's this guy goin'?" which is not something I'd consider to be a safety margin kicking in... it sounds like sheer dumb luck, where the last margin had already failed.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by jbg_ on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @05:02AM (#14742620)
* Conditions were clear. The pilot landing would likely have seen the aircraft on the ground in plenty of time to go around.

* Conditions were clear. The pilot landing would have an increasing probability of noticing their mistake from lights on the runway and taxiway as they got closer to landing.

* After being alerted that the pilot landing could see lights on what they thought was the runway, the ATC would likely have paid closer attention to the various tools available to them to see the location and heading of the aircraft.

And finally, the one factor that happened to be the first of these to happen:

* Multiple pilots looking directly toward the oncoming aircraft, one of whom alerted ATC.

Just because this happened first doesn't mean the other things failed or wouldn't have happened.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by wfunction on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @07:35AM (#14743261)
> And finally, the one factor that happened to be the first of these to happen:

> * Multiple pilots looking directly toward the oncoming aircraft, one of whom alerted ATC.

I don't get this.

You're an engineer/pilot/whomever filing for {the current system/pilot/plane/whatever-needs-approval} to get approved. The power-that-be (e.g. FAA) asks you what your safety margins are. You cite "other pilots looking directly at my aircraft in the 30-second span of my mistake" as one of your "safety margins"? ...what?

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by jbg_ on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @04:56PM (#14756603)
I'm inclined to agree with you. Airports tending to be full of hyper-aware pilots who are communicating on the same radio frequencies as you shouldn't really be considered a safety margin, but it can still prevent accidents sometimes.

Incidentally, Aviation Herald reports[1] that "AC-759 had already overflown taxiway C by about 0.25nm when ATC instructed the aircraft to go around" and further that "it is estimated that AC-759 overflew the first two aircraft by 100 feet".

100 feet isn't much, and I imagine this was utterly terrifying for the pilots lined up on the taxiway, but 0.25nm past the beginning of taxiway C is basically touchdown point on the runway (had they been lined up with it), and they were still 100 feet above the ground. That indicates pretty strongly that the pilot of AC-759 had noticed their mistake and was taking evasive action already, before ATC instructed them to go around.

[1] https://avherald.com/h?article=4ab79f58&opt=0

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by wfunction on Wednesday July 12, 2017 @05:11PM (#14756718)
Wow, that's nice to know. Thanks for that bit of info!
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by dotancohen on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @05:20PM (#14748182)
If you think that's bad, wait until you discover what safety margins exist on the highways, and how much professional training drivers receive.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by CaliforniaKarl on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:42AM (#14742064)
Unfortunately we don't have enough information here to know for sure.

For example, the approach controller may have noticed that a plane they recently handed off to Tower was not yet lined up. The controller would then call up to Tower to make Tower aware of the issue.

Or, Tower may have a screen showing them a radar view of the approach, similar to Approach's screen. They may have noticed it there.

But, the nature of aviation radio is such that you use one frequency to transmit and receive. That means you can't speak over anyone else; you have to wait for them to stop talking before you can start. And if you mess up, there's no easy way for you to know (except when someone else on frequency says "blocked").

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by lisper on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:11AM (#14741940)
> And the safety margin was wide enough to absorb that screw up.

Barely.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by baq on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @07:35AM (#14743255)
considering that jet turbines take 5 seconds to spool up to go-around and 8 to full thrust at landing airspeeds (...not entirely sure if that's correct - that's the best i could google), the margin was about 10 seconds. i'm inclined to agree that it should be a terrifying incident that ended in a successful landing.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by mikeash on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @12:25PM (#14745463)
The recording is edited for highlights. The LiveATC archive has a ~40 second interval between "go around" and "flew directly over us" and even that archive is edited to remove silence, so the real interval may have been even longer.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by lisper on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @12:51PM (#14745732)
Can you post/link the unedited version? I can't find it.

Notwithstanding the timing on the tape, the AC jet could not have been very far away because the fact that he was lined up with the taxiway was first noted by a plane on the ground. That would not have been evident unless the plane was very close.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by mikeash on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:55PM (#14746328)
There's a less-edited version here:

http://archive-server.liveatc.net/ksfo/KSFO-Twr2-Jul-08-2017...

The action starts at about 14:45. I suspect there isn't much silence removed in this particular area, so 40 seconds may be close to the actual time.

I haven't been able to find a pure unedited version. They may not be saved.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by lisper on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:44PM (#14746833)
What makes you think this version has been edited?
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by mikeash on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:58PM (#14746961)
It's an archive of a 30-minute period but the file is only 18 minutes long.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by hyperbovine on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:36AM (#14741802)
> But no pilot would ever land on a runway (or taxiway) with 3 planes on it.

Just like no pilot would ever crash into the seawall short of 28L in broad daylight with unlimited visibility. In that case the pilots knew what was about to happen seconds before impact and they were powerless to stop it. I could easily see the same thing happening here. Airplanes are big cumbersome objects with a ton of inertia.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by WalterBright on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:17AM (#14741964)
Inertia wasn't the problem for that accident. It takes several seconds for the engines to spool up, and they didn't have any seconds to spare.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by kobeya on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:42AM (#14741828)
When did that happen?
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by chinathrow on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:51AM (#14741862)
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by TacticalMalice on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:47AM (#14741846)
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by rl3 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:46AM (#14741840)
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by rl3 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:41AM (#14741825)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USAir_Flight_1493

Though air traffic was not heavy at Los Angeles airport, the local controller was distracted as Flight 1493 was on final approach by a series of abnormalities, including an aircraft that inadvertently switched off the tower frequency and a misplaced flight progress strip, which resulted in the SkyWest flight being told to taxi into takeoff position while the USAir flight was landing on the same runway without the Metroliner ever being given a takeoff clearance.

Upon landing, the 737 collided with the twin-engine turboprop, continued down the runway with the turboprop crushed beneath it, exited the runway, and caught fire. All 12 people aboard the smaller plane were killed, as well as an eventual total of 23 out of the 89 passengers on the Boeing.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by exDM69 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:40AM (#14741820)
Assuming the liveatc audio in the article has not been edited, it sounds like there's about 10 seconds between ATC giving go around and the United pilot saying they flew right over. With instructions given to Air Canada in between so it might have been seconds earlier.

Based on that, it was seconds away from a collision. It seems like a near miss when considering aviation safety margins.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by dx034 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:49AM (#14742087)
I would assume it was edited. He only joins the frequency about 30 seconds before it happens. That means tower only took control once he was 60 seconds before landing. I don't know the procedures at SFO but that seems too short.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by mikeash on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @12:26PM (#14745476)
It has been edited. The LiveATC archive has about 40 seconds between "go around" and "flew directly over us." The LiveATC archive appears to be edited to remove silence, so it may have been even longer.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by CaliforniaKarl on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:44AM (#14742073)
What's missing is, when (relative to radio traffic) did the pilot begin the go-around maneuver. Did they begin doing so before being told to go around, or did they only start to do so after?
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by exDM69 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:49AM (#14742090)
If the pilot initiates a go around they need to announce it to the ATC. It is usually a drastic full power pull up that will certainly disrupt nearby air traffic.

So the pilot probably did not start the go around before being told so.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by CaliforniaKarl on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @03:04AM (#14742134)
Sorry, I have to partially disagree. The FAA is pretty clear on this: The priorities (in order) are Aviate, Navigate, and Communicate[1].

The pilot is ultimately the person responsible for the safe operation of the aircraft. That will occasionally mean performing a maneuver before telling anyone.

In response to this, procedures are designed so that pilots can safely abort an approach without posing a danger to themselves (i.e. running into terrain) or other aircraft.

For example, let's look at the LDA PRM runway 28 Right approach [2] into SFO, which the pilot may have been flying. If you have to abort the approach prior to the DARNE waypoint, you make a climbing right turn to heading 030 and 3000 feet, then you proceed directly to the Oakland VOR, and then you hold as published.

When Approach clears you for this approach, the controller is also clearing you to fly the missed approach, if needed.

If you have to go missed-approach after DARNE, the instructions are similar, but are documented in [3] instead of in [2]. But note the "unless otherwise instructed by ATC". In this case (see [4]), Tower placed the pilot onto runway heading, likely with a climb to avoid the hills. Approach would then have taken over, and brought the pilot back around.

[1]: https://www.faasafety.gov/gslac/ALC/course_content.aspx?cID=...

[2]: http://155.178.201.160/d-tpp/1707/00375LDAPRM28R.PDF

[3]: http://155.178.201.160/d-tpp/1707/00375PRMAAUP.PDF

[4]: https://flightaware.com/live/flight/ACA759/history/20170708/...

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by exDM69 on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @03:31AM (#14742237)
Yes, it's impossible to tell from the footage but I would have assumed hearing the pilot, not the ATC call for go around if it was pilot initiated.

But you're right, the pilot may have started the go around but we can't tell what happened from the footage.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by rdtsc on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:18AM (#14741740)
This isn't quite a regular "runway incursion". That term is usually reserved for a taxiing aircraft (or maybe a service vehicle) which didn't stop in time at the threshold and went a bit beyond it.

This is more like runway "confusion". A term I made up, not sure if there is such an official name for it.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by FiloSottile on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:21AM (#14741752)
Right, I meant that if pilots sort-of-routinely spot runway incursions, they surely won't land on 3 wide-body jets sitting there.

This is why you want human pilots, instead of computers, not the opposite. A human can apply common sense and decide not to land on three planes after all even if it looks like a cleared runway.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by cyberferret on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:35AM (#14741798)
> This is why you want human pilots, instead of computers

I actually believe the opposite is true. Systems like ACARS have managed to avoid the prevalence of air to air incidents that used to be almost an epidemic in the 60's and 70's.

Autolanding technology has brought planes home safely where a pilot would have had to go around and find an alternate aerodrome.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by tjohns on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:48AM (#14741849)
Are you sure you're not thinking of TCAS?

(ACARS is used for delivering clearances and other routine operational/maintenance messages. Basically text messaging for airplanes.)

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by cyberferret on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:36AM (#14742033)
Sorry yes (Duh!) TCAS, not ACARS! Thanks for the correction. I haven't flown in a LONG while now, and sometimes the acronyms get muddled in my brain. :)
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by MaxfordAndSons on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:19AM (#14741743)
Ehh, the fact that he was cleared to land and the taxing aircraft could tell he was over the taxiway means it was probably less than 1 minute from landing. That's a pretty close call imo.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by meowface on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:09AM (#14741706)
Right, I'm confused by this. Surely the pilot would notice at least one of the planes he'd be inevitably crashing into well before he started to land?
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by ddeck on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:21AM (#14741753)
>Surely the pilot would notice at least one of the planes he'd be inevitably crashing into well before he started to land

In theory yes, but the risk is that the plane you crash into is not yet on the taxiway or that poor visibility or tunneled focus prevents you from noticing it.

You don't need to be moving quickly to have a significant accident. The deadliest aviation accident in history (583 fatalities) resulted when two planes collided on a taxiway (edit: actually on the runway) in dense fog [1].

Edit: as correctly pointed out below, the actual collision took place on the runway at significant speed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenerife_airport_disaster

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by Pinckney on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:27AM (#14741769)
You're mistaken. The KLM plane took off when it was not cleared, and they collided at 260km/h.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by cyberferret on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:32AM (#14741789)
That was just one of seven distinct mistakes that lead to the crash. The PanAm pilot missed his turnoff, the controllers were busy watching a football match and missed the radio cues that could have alerted them to the fact there was an impending problem etc. etc.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by kgwgk on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:29AM (#14741777)
It's interesting that it happened 40 years ago. Risks might be decreasing if we didn't see a larger one yet.
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by cyberferret on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:24AM (#14741763)
At night, and if he was fatigued or on instruments for a long time before that, the disorientation could have easily lead to such an error.

LOTS of planes accidentally line up on the taxiway if visibility is reduced and cockpit workload is high. Heck, aircraft have even taken off on non active runways at the most advanced airport in the world with disastrous results at night. [0]

Inclement weather on approach at the end of a long flight can also lead to crew pressing home while under confusion, as in the case of the Korean airlines accident that landed short. [1]

More recently, at SFO too, the Asiana B777 crash was something that should have been almost impossible in a modern jetlines, but over reliance on automation and lazy piloting lead to that disaster.

[0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iHekCU9CYvI

[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=II4dwx00v28

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by notatoad on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:24AM (#14741760)
>Surely the pilot would notice at least one of the planes he'd be inevitably crashing into well before he started to land?

Which seems to be what happened here - the pilot aligned with the taxiway, noticed he was in the wrong spot, and the tower told him to try again.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by ChuckMcM on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:29AM (#14741774)
I expect you are correct, but I also note that it has happened before. One could have said this just before the Asiana flight flew into the ground as well. "What pilot would miss the fact that they were way too low?" Or just before Harrison Ford flew over a plane on the Taxiway and then landed on that taxiway.

Fundamentally it takes several things to fail all at once for an air disaster to actually transpire, but it does happen.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by omegant on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:22AM (#14741981)
The Asiana problem is that some asian pilots are encouraged NOT to fly manually ever.

There is a pprune forum post of an american instructor explaining how a visual circuit flown in manual was the worst "emergency" he could set in a simulator. Up to the point that he failed one of the chef pilots in Asiana and they wanted to fire him. This seems to be a cultural thing, they ace the theory (really know all the manuals by heart), but are not allowed to think outside the box at all.

This airmiss is important, but could only happen flying in manual and visual conditions.

It's hard to ignore the sigthing of other planes in that conditions, even if you are confused about which strip you are aligned with.

In my opinion it's much more dangerous taxing in a complex airport with fog. There is a real problem of runway incursions, that could be solved with better systems.

I'll try to find the pprune post.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by kobeya on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:40AM (#14741823)
What if the airport was fogged out and the Air Canada pilot was doing a instrument landing?
Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by CaliforniaKarl on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @02:48AM (#14742085)
Then this specific type of incident would likely not have happened.

The pilot here was flying visually (which I expect either means a visual approach, or else the LDA PRM Runway 28 Right approach).

If the airport was fogged out, the pilot would be on an ILS or RNAV (area navigation) approach. The former uses ground-based signals to provide precise lateral and vertical navigation; the latter uses either GPS or multiple ground-based aids to accomplish the same thing.

The downside to ILS, RNAV, etc., is that you can't fit planes as close together while still being safe. That's why you get delays when major airports have reduced visibility: The flight scheduled are "tuned" for maximum planes per runway per minute, which is only possible when skies are clear and winds are (relatively) calm, so that you can use visual approaches.

Re:SFO near miss might have triggered aviation disaster by milesf on Tuesday July 11, 2017 @01:09AM (#14741709)
Seems that it was the ATC and another pilot who spotted it.