News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is social graph portability workable? by subway on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:02PM (#14722074)
I think it's more the abandonment of federated protocols in favor of centralized services, than the abandonment of a specific protocol.

An only tangentially related anecdote: SMTP and later XMPP offered beautifully portable social graphs. In fact, in 2012, I found it so portable that I decided to migrate off the self-hosted postfix/dovecot/ejabberd install I'd run on my own domain for years to GApps. Cue the replacement of GTalk with Hangouts, and now I really don't have much of a choice but to pay Google each month, or discard/re-establish the social connections I've built over the last decade and a half.

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by Xeoncross on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:58PM (#14722496)
Email is the only truly successful decentralized protocol which is why the OP's statement mentions it.

A) Wide global adoption

B) Decades of use

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by jimktrains2 on Friday July 07, 2017 @06:08PM (#14722560)
> Email is the only truly successful decentralized protocol

HTTP?

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by radarsat1 on Friday July 07, 2017 @06:28PM (#14722698)
HTTP is a transfer protocol, not a semantic protocol. Email at least lets you identify the sender/receiver and other metadata and separate them from the message, HTTP is just "this is the filename, this is the data.." It's not much more than a TCP stream really.
Re:Is social graph portability workable? by jimktrains2 on Friday July 07, 2017 @07:19PM (#14722997)
> Email at least lets you identify the sender/receiver

I'm not sure of your point. Http also allows you to identify the server. Forwarding mail servers are analogous to caching and forwarding proxies.

> other metadata and separate them from the message

Just like http.

> HTTP is just "this is the filename, this is the data.." It's not much more than a TCP stream really

No, it isn't. No more than SMTP, IMAP, and pop3 are.

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by radarsat1 on Sunday July 09, 2017 @12:45PM (#14730571)
By "sender" and "receiver" I mean person, not server. I truly don't understand why you're on about servers and transport protocols when this thread is about social networks.
Re:Is social graph portability workable? by jimktrains2 on Friday July 14, 2017 @12:10PM (#14770911)
> By "sender" and "receiver" I mean person, not server.

What's the difference? An email address isn't a person, nor does it represent one.

> I truly don't understand why you're on about servers and transport protocols when this thread is about social networks.

Because it was mentioned that SMTP is the only decentralized protocol, and I disagreed.