News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is social graph portability workable? by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Friday July 07, 2017 @04:22PM (#14721737)
What is sad, is how similar the ideal portable social graph looks to email with your own domain name. You own the identifier, and you can select which provider hosts your email. In addition, you can send an email to somebody which will just work no matter what host they are on. You have the option of having a local copy of everything.

When we look back, I think we will see that in abandoning email as the medium of social interaction, we basically gave up on the open internet.

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by swiley on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:53PM (#14722459)
Email really isn't totally abandoned.

People in various compromised situations use it because it doesn't need a phone number (unlike a rapidly growing amount of social networks.) I've set up dates over email, most of my work is done over email. I tell people to email me rather than text me because I am /much/ more likely to get an email (and get it quickly, thanks to IMAP IDLE.) It's the only thing I get notifications for on my laptop and the only thing I reliably get notifications for on my phone.

It's not abandoned, it's just not as hip as snapchat.

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by subway on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:02PM (#14722074)
I think it's more the abandonment of federated protocols in favor of centralized services, than the abandonment of a specific protocol.

An only tangentially related anecdote: SMTP and later XMPP offered beautifully portable social graphs. In fact, in 2012, I found it so portable that I decided to migrate off the self-hosted postfix/dovecot/ejabberd install I'd run on my own domain for years to GApps. Cue the replacement of GTalk with Hangouts, and now I really don't have much of a choice but to pay Google each month, or discard/re-establish the social connections I've built over the last decade and a half.

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by Xeoncross on Friday July 07, 2017 @05:58PM (#14722496)
Email is the only truly successful decentralized protocol which is why the OP's statement mentions it.

A) Wide global adoption

B) Decades of use

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by jimktrains2 on Friday July 07, 2017 @06:08PM (#14722560)
> Email is the only truly successful decentralized protocol

HTTP?

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by radarsat1 on Friday July 07, 2017 @06:28PM (#14722698)
HTTP is a transfer protocol, not a semantic protocol. Email at least lets you identify the sender/receiver and other metadata and separate them from the message, HTTP is just "this is the filename, this is the data.." It's not much more than a TCP stream really.
Re:Is social graph portability workable? by jimktrains2 on Friday July 07, 2017 @07:19PM (#14722997)
> Email at least lets you identify the sender/receiver

I'm not sure of your point. Http also allows you to identify the server. Forwarding mail servers are analogous to caching and forwarding proxies.

> other metadata and separate them from the message

Just like http.

> HTTP is just "this is the filename, this is the data.." It's not much more than a TCP stream really

No, it isn't. No more than SMTP, IMAP, and pop3 are.

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by radarsat1 on Sunday July 09, 2017 @12:45PM (#14730571)
By "sender" and "receiver" I mean person, not server. I truly don't understand why you're on about servers and transport protocols when this thread is about social networks.
Re:Is social graph portability workable? by jimktrains2 on Friday July 14, 2017 @12:10PM (#14770911)
> By "sender" and "receiver" I mean person, not server.

What's the difference? An email address isn't a person, nor does it represent one.

> I truly don't understand why you're on about servers and transport protocols when this thread is about social networks.

Because it was mentioned that SMTP is the only decentralized protocol, and I disagreed.

Re:Is social graph portability workable? by narak on Saturday July 08, 2017 @11:17PM (#14728184)
Email is still the de facto protocol for business communication, so you could probably build a professional network on top of it.