Hindsight is 20/20
Do you also need to be warned that if you create a plane autopilot, the FAA might get involved?
No, from my guess, Hotz copped out when he realized that his prototype, while fun, was no where near production ready and would be completely illegal to ship to any customers.
Hotz never seemed like the guy who would do things similar to what Cruise did. Vogt had already sold two startups prior to Cruise, and he was well versed in the tactics of the startup world. Have great articles put out, polished PR touches, the whole works.
OTOH, Hotz had this 'Hacker' air to whatever he does. From the iPhone, to PlayStation, to even hacking the cars he was building the tech with, he had a very different attitude compared to the let's-be-poised-for-a-buyout vibe that many startups give. Startups like Cruise are scared of breaking rules, worrying about how it might bite them later in the day.
If you ask me, Cruise was never going to make it on its own. The major car companies have decades of supply chain process management and huge amounts of capital behind them. Cruise couldn't never do what it said it would do, and I would imagine, a buy out was always on the founders minds.
Comma.ai is a different beast. They aren't really worried about rules. That's terrible attitude for a 'startup', I agree. People here have valid arguments about thinking about the NHTSA before hand, but I think they just dared to go ahead without giving a crap. It backfired, but I wouldn't attribute his decision to failure in building a working product.
Are you gonna hate this guy just because he has a face and a personal reputation?
Or are you going to watch with bemused interest as he successfully scales the obstacles and actually puts some nice products out there.
he released the hardware plans, specs, and software as opensource. You can go build it, today. And if you have a supported car (currently certain honda civics, and accura ILX's.. soon honda crv, toyota prius, and chevy bolt/volt) you can actually use it, today. There are videos on youtube of people doing exactly that.
Changing your business model, is IMO.. the opposite of folding. it's adapting.
That's a hell of a non-sequitor
Udacity has their own self-driving vehicle. They built it for their Self-Driving Vehicle Car Engineer Nanodegree program; I just started term 3 yesterday, and apparently they're going ahead with the plan for student to run code on it.
https://medium.com/udacity/term-3-in-depth-on-udacitys-self-...
Apparently, they have a test track, and will have a safety driver on-board. For that part of the term (dubbed "Integration"), we'll be broken into teams of 10-20 students, and (somehow) have to coordinate on building the software pieces to run on the vehicle. This will all be done using a custom simulator designed to replicate the test track (similar to what has already been used). Once something is working, the group will then merge the pieces (nodes and modules for ROS and something called AutoWare) all together in a shared github repo. That'll be shipped over to Udacity for testing on "track days", and results sent back to the team for analysis.
I'm not sure how well this whole thing is going to work; it's very much an experiment that I believe is unique for a MOOC and hasn't been tried before (develop software as a group project of international students, to drive a real self-driving vehicle on a test track in Mountain View, CA - yep, that seems reasonable).
I guess we'll see when we get there. The vehicle is named "Carla", and (overall) it is open-sourced. Here are some links to learn more about it:
https://www.udacity.com/self-driving-car
https://github.com/udacity/self-driving-car
https://github.com/CPFL/Autoware
The vehicle itself is apparently some standard vehicle converted by a third-party company (for the life of me, I can't recall the make or model of the vehicle, nor the company that did the conversion!); if you wanted to DIY this yourself at full scale, you'd basically want a vehicle that uses a mostly drive-by-wire control system for the brakes, accelerator, and steering. If that isn't available, then something that uses electro-hydraulic power braking and steering (or electric power-steering) would be the next best thing.
I'd shy away from trying to do this with a standard vehicle; building the actuators you would need to control everything is not a trivial thing to do (and especially to do so safely and reliably).
Honestly, if you really wanted to do this, and you didn't want to kill yourself, others, or damage property (as much?) - start out smaller with an RC car or similar. There are plenty of examples on how to do this on the internet, but my favorite go-to example is this one:
http://blog.davidsingleton.org/nnrccar/
That one occupies a "soft spot" in me because David Singleton was one of the original students in the Stanford-sponsored ML Class of 2011, taught by Andrew Ng. I was a part of that class; it taught us enough to build such a vehicle, and David was inspired to do so and follow thru with it. What used to cost hundreds-of-thousands of dollars (if not millions) back in the 1980s:
https://ftp.utcluj.ro/pub///docs/imaging/Autonomous_driving/...
...could in 2011 be done for much, much less.
Final note: I don't have any association with any of this other than being a student in the Udacity course and interested in learning about this technology.
And yes - we're running student code on the car, around a test track, and we'll send you the results (I think a video feed as well). It's your final project in the Self-Driving Car Nanodegree program.
I can't wait to watch the first time a student's code drives it around the track.
If my sunday psychology profile is correct, he seems to be passionated and fast to hack around and displeased by big corporations business model + slowness + suboptimality. Thus trying to dig diagonally on his own without the enterprise cruft. So far so good, the issue is that it seems he's lying about his abilities. He managed to do 20% and spins it as 70% claiming he'll be at 100% before everybody else. Without independant testing and legislation of course.
It worked for Cruise. Got them a billion dollars and a seat on GM's board.
That was surprising, because GM had a good self-driving effort with CMU, and had progressed to driving in Washington DC traffic autonomously.[1] That was way ahead of Cruise, and working in 2013. Then, somehow, GM totally blew it and lost that project, with the people going elsewhere.
[1] https://www.cmu.edu/news/stories/archives/2013/september/sep...
Every Toyota comes equipped with lane following and smart cruise control. They call it Toyota Safety Sense, and even the lowest priced, $18k Corolla has it.
I've a friend that has a comma neo with openpilot and it works enough well. Is not perfect, but they are on something.
The best projects that we know today were made by hackers with 0 enterprise skills.
Edit: I'm actually curious now that I think about it. Are there any good examples of hacker projects (or specifically projects that aren't intended to make money or pay people's salaries) that had to deal with any sort of regulatory hurdles?
I cannot compare anything in the casual software world, no matter how complex it is, to driving a car in streets. It's bridging physics and AI. Maybe hotz has a point and other SDV module vendors are as fake but that's irrelevant.
So when George said, "there are only three real competitors: Waymo, Tesla and us." What he really says is that Comma.ai's technology is on par with Waymo and Tesla's. The rest of the companies are either subpar or have no existing product to demo, likely both.
He also famously said "shippability" is the biggest differentiator between Comma One and the rest but decided not to fight the uphill legal battle being that he's taking the Android approach to grab the market share.
So, I kinda buy it.
[1]: http://www.thedrive.com/tech/5772/the-cancelled-comma-one-wo...
Looking at the github repository code, comma is a joke.
Sorry what's a bridge? I don't get the reference.
That's total bullshit. There are so many companies seriously working on autonomous vehicles, such as GM Cruise, Auroa Innovation, Drive.ai, Zoox, Nuro.ai, nuTonomy, Varden Labs, AImotive, Ford, and Nvidia
Edit, because George is on here: George, I want to like you, because I think your tech is really good (the street image segmentation from RGB images is seriously impressive- https://commacoloring.herokuapp.com/) and I think your business model of offering cheap devices and free services to crowd-source data, along with the comma points to incentivize users could give you a big competitive advantage. But the hyperbole makes it difficult to take you seriously.