News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by conradk on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:50AM (#14702351)
The article says that consumers are discouraged by the cost of repair.

A few weeks ago, I repaired an eltronical appliance and was surprised to see that all screws were screwed into plastic. As I unscrewed them to access the inside of the device, the plastic around the screw broke.

I think there should be laws that prevent screwing into plastic. That just makes no sense appart from upfront cost. Once the plastic is broken, there is no way but to throw the broken device away. Unless you can somehow glue everything back together, but that seems unpractical.

It's like devices are not even planned to be repaired. They are designed to be sold and then abandoned. That's the real issue. Not cost of repair.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by F_r_k on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:07PM (#14703585)
À better law would be something around: "devices should be made so that they can be taken apart and reassembled at least n times".

That would discourage copious amounts or glue and still let the engineers use the methods they want.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by etix on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:57AM (#14702397)
> It's like devices are not even planned to be repaired. They are designed to be sold and then abandoned. That's the real issue. Not cost of repair.

Absolutely. Smartphones are the best example, the software makes the hardware unusable or insecure because of the lack of updates pretty quickly.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by taway_1212 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:57AM (#14702862)
> the software makes the hardware unusable or insecure because of the lack of updates pretty quickly.

Or, alternatively, the (practically) mandatory updates make the previously perfectly fine phone slow to the point of being unusable.

I'm saying that the updates are practically mandatory because if you don't apply them, your apps gradually stop working (as they cannot talk to their respective server backends, which are being updated without maintaining backcompat) - and of course, the current version of the app requires the current(ish) version of iOS. This all amounts to an engineered obsolescence of millions of perfectly good phones.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by logingone on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:25PM (#14704361)
Or, alternatively, last night my (untampered) phone got bricked by an ota update.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by oever on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:57AM (#14702867)
Agreed. Software and hardware should be sold separately.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by briandear on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:20AM (#14703085)
How does that work? Computers would be sold without operating systems? Good luck pitching that idea.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by oever on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:02PM (#14704745)
Very simple: you buy hardware and software from different vendors. Each device must have enough information available publicly so that other companies can write software for it.

You might be able to purchase software and hardware at the same time, but there should be a choice of software and the price of the software should be listed separately on the bill.

The prevalent software business model of lock-in has infected hardware. This has disastrous consequences for the environment. Just because some software is unsupported, expensive hardware is bricked.

The parliament recommendation has this to say about this problem: "software solutions which prevent repairs from being performed, other than by approved firms or bodies, should be discouraged".

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by simion314 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:35PM (#14703866)
Better would be to force them to open source the drivers and specifications and repair guides for all devices, who knows if I can use my PS3 in 10 years, we will have to hope that open source community can make drivers for it.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by xxs on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:35AM (#14703223)
Technically that works when you assemble one yourself and en-masse won't make any sense.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by cube00 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:54AM (#14702378)
It's not "like", they are and they've got a term for it; planned obsolescence.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by IshKebab on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:06AM (#14702945)
Rubbish. Planned obsolescence is extremely rare. The low quality of products is because of cost cutting.

Manufacturers design for a minimum lifetime as cheaply as possible. "It must last 2 years. How can we save money?" Virtually nobody is going "It must break after 2 years." Except in a very small number of cases that is conspiracy theory nonsense.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by mbrock on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:01PM (#14703528)
But that's effectively the same goal. If you engineer it to work for 2 years as cheaply as possible, you're probably engineering it to break after 2 years. Would we get better results from "it must cost max X, how can we make it last as long as possible and be repairable?" Probably, but the incentives don't reward it.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by IshKebab on Thursday July 06, 2017 @08:05AM (#14709702)
Yes but the intent is vastly different. It's like the difference between accidentally and deliberately killing someone. Same result but they're not the same are they?
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by mbrock on Friday July 07, 2017 @10:01AM (#14718361)
Depends on the systematicity and avoidability of the accidents, I would say. Negligence is different from manslaughter, but it seems like a spectrum.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by xxs on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:04AM (#14702924)
>>I think there should be laws that prevent screwing into plastic.

And the beauty of glue would be everywhere. Glue is such a great engineering tool, easy to apply and no need to worry about repairs ever.

I like repairing my stuff...

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by briandear on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:18AM (#14703061)
A law requiring a particular material? Unless it’s health or safety related, no way. The last place I want to see government is regulating how a product must be constructed (unless it’s health or safety critical obviously.)

If you want a device without plastic screw holes, pay more money and find one or make one yourself, market it and sell it to other like-minded people.

If I have a toaster that breaks, the time it would take me to go to a repair shop is more valuable to me than the cost of a new toaster – not to mention the cost of the repair itself.

In China, you often do get smaller appliances repaired because the labor cost is so low. So it makes economic sense to get those kinds of items repaired.

But in France, if I want to get a microwave fixed, the item is either still under warranty or the depreciated value is less than the repair cost. Perhaps if government lowered taxes and relaxed the labor code, then repair shops could charge less and it would incentivize people to get repairs on smaller ticket items rather than buying replacements. But I certainly am not going to spend €65 getting a €150 microwave repaired when the microwave is already several years old. I migh spend €20 for that repair if I really liked the microwave.

I certainly wouldn’t be happy if I had to pay several hundred euros more for a microwave because of a law mandating the type of screw holes that must be used. The increase cost wouldn’t even be in materials as much as the buereaucratic cost of implementing such requirements.

Health and safety regulations – of course. Regulations because you’re unhappy with screw holes? Not a chance.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by xxs on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:34AM (#14703203)
The electronics could have a 'repairability' rating similar to energy-efficiency one.

Otherwise there is no feasible way to know what's the build quality before opening it yourself.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by shabble on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:28PM (#14704403)
Generalising and mandating some sort of 'star rating' + notes along the lines of the ifixit Repairability Score[1] system would be a good first step.

AIUI, for products marketed in the US there are often internal photographs & other documentation (e.g, a totally random example product I found with one of the FCC ID search engines: https://fccid.io/2AMOCKST-900)

Having some semi-standardised set of robustness and repairability criteria and requiring that businesses publish an evaluation of their products against the criteria would at least allow people to get some idea of the 'build quality' or other potential decisionmaking info before buying.

Of course, it would be easy for unscrupulous product manufacturers to find ways to game the evaluations, or just outright lie, so you need some teeth to the rules if caught.

And on the other hand, you're imposing further regulatory burdens on those producing new products, increasing costs and maybe time to market. So there are definitely downsides.

Balancing everything and making it useful without being burdensome is the real problem.

As an afterthought, even if you look inside one instance of a product, there isn't any degree of certainty that if you buy an (externally) identical, matching model number/SKU, it will be the same.

Some regulatory system that actually required version-numbering, or different model-numbering on non-trivial changes would be useful, especially if combined with some obligation to record/announce those version releases, maybe even with some actual change notes.

[1] https://www.ifixit.com/smartphone-repairability

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by conradk on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:18PM (#14704880)
For me, the point is that when we throw out a device because it's too expensive to repair, then we diminish our health, because we pollute our environment.

It's hard to measure, like a lot of things, but we should not throw away a microwave because a single transistor broke. We should get someone to repair it. We would collectively save money (instead of paying people with the RSA doing nothing, we should get some of them to learn how to repair stuff) and save the environment.

As for the tone, you might want to be a little more respectful than to simplify other people's thoughts down to "regulations because you're unhappy with screw holes". It does not help you in any way.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by simion314 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:41PM (#14703924)
What about more expensive items like big TVs, washing machine is it fair to replace them instead of replacing one small component inside it, and if they would have spent maybe a few cents more and not use the cheapest parts on this expensive object and maybe added some protection for electrical and mechanical damage(water,dust) your device would work for 10 years.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by reacweb on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:29AM (#14703161)
For health, it is not so obvious: see the scandal of epipen.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by pikzen on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:41PM (#14704548)
>Perhaps if government lowered taxes and relaxed the labor code

Oh, Brian, we meet again, and we disagree once again. Taxes and the labor code are not what is making things expensive.

- The labor code is not even close to being the one reason companies do not hire : https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/2871900?sommaire=287202...

- Countless fiscal advantages have already been given and tried, effectively the same thing as lowering taxes on companies. That includes the CIE, CICE, CIR, the reduction of TVA in restaurants, fiscal benefits for life insurance holders, lowering the ISS to 34.6%, removing taxes on plus-value, the globalised worldwide profits regime, and the countless things that can be listed here : https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niche_fiscale

All of these happened, and the costs have not changed. Some of them were given in exchange of promise of jobs (the change of TVA in restaurants being one of the most notable), and none happened. Profits went up, though.

I would rather have microwave repair costs go up to 80€ than lower our living standards.

>I certainly wouldn’t be happy if I had to pay several hundred euros more for a microwave because of a law mandating the type of screw holes that must be used.

hyperbole.txt