News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by chairmanwow on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @07:11AM (#14701439)
I originally thought this paper presented evidence for extra dimensions discovered in gravitational wave readings.

This is certainly not the case, as this paper presents two potential effects from higher dimensional gravity waves and proposes methods to detect them.

Namely, we would need an equivalent to LIGO that features detection arms in all three axes rather than just X and Z. The second predicted effect requires a GWave detector that is several orders of magnitude more sensitive than LIGO.

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by TheRealDunkirk on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @08:26AM (#14701817)
> I originally thought this paper presented evidence for extra dimensions discovered in gravitational wave readings.

And you've perfectly illustrated the current problem with science reporting. It's hard to keep people interested in ongoing discovery when 1) the link doesn't accurately represent the paper's thesis, and 2) the paper is so obtuse as to require a specialized degree to understand.

Whatever your qualifications, your comment provided the context to understand what was being asserted. You are the sort of person who should be writing articles on scientific papers.

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by Steuard on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:23AM (#14702610)
This isn't a "science reporting" site: arXiv.org is providing the actual scientific article. The paper is supposed to require a specialized degree to understand: that's the intended audience of the vast majority of content on arXiv.org. (And for regular users of the site, it's immediately clear that no paper categorized as "hep-th: High Energy Physics - Theory" would be announcing actual observational results.)

Aside: The authors of this article seem to have submitted a revised version a couple of weeks ago; sometimes (but not always) that coincides with either journal submission or responding to reviewer comments. There's no indication here yet of what its current stage in the peer review process is.

Edit: I see from later comments here that the target of this link may have been changed to arXiv.org after its original submission. If the earlier link was paywalled as someone said, that suggests that this result has been formally published somewhere. (I'm a little surprised that the authors didn't note that on the arXiv page once it happened.) So maybe the earlier context made the purely theoretical nature of the paper less clear.

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by homarp on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:34AM (#14703208)
Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics https://doi.org/10.1088/1475-7516/2017/06/048

Received 8 May 2017

Accepted 13 June 2017

Published 23 June 2017

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by pvitz on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @03:55PM (#14705612)
I am astonished how quickly it was reviewed and published. Is this common for journals on cosmology? It has been some years but I remember that submissions to e.g. Phys.Rev.E could take a long time till they would be published.
Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by gus_massa on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:35AM (#14702250)
> And you've perfectly illustrated the current problem with science reporting.

In this cases, this is the proposed title to the research article in the peer review journal. (Is this accepted yet?) So this is not a problem of a bad clickbait journalism.

My guess is that it's a good title for the people in the area, because they have enough context of the current research state to guess that it's a theoretical result and not an experimental result (and in case of doubt they can RTFA). So I suspect it's not malice (neither stupidity).

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by nolemurs on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:08PM (#14704184)
Ironically, in this case, the Hacker News link could really have benefited from a title change to communicate the missing context.
Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by the8472 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:58PM (#14704713)
> the paper is so obtuse as to require a specialized degree to understand.

I have no degree in physics and I find the authors make a decent job giving several summaries (abstract, introduction, description of the work) that make clear that they propose hypotheticals that could be observed, not actual observerations.

> We discuss whether these two effects could be observed.

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by coldtea on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @03:06PM (#14705254)
>And you've perfectly illustrated the current problem with science reporting.

What "reporting"? This is a science paper -- and its actual title.

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by Already__Taken on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @08:01AM (#14701677)
There's going to be multiple LIGO style detectors around the world, could their results be combined to account for the 3rd axis?
Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by tqkxzugoaupvwqr on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:05AM (#14702452)
From my understanding as a layperson, using other LIGO style detectors to substitute the z-axis won’t work. You need to shoot laser pulses continuously and in sync into two axes from the same detector to be able to detect ripples in spacetime. The sensitivity of two non-connected detectors working together is not high enough. See [1] for how the detection works.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iphcyNWFD10

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by Already__Taken on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:59AM (#14702880)
Given the size of the wavelength is multiples of the earth are they not able to sync up the section of the wave being measured and deduce further measurements from there?

You couldn't add 1 axis of another detector as a 3rd leg but having 3 measurements on 3 planes from 3 pairs of beams due to their positions on earth should. Each stations 2 axis measure 1 plane, and you build the 3 plane from the positions on the earths surface.

Wouldn't the relative velocities of the earths spin, orbit and the solar systems velocity from the gravity wave origin all make the above measurements... difficult. Or all things considered, the angular tiny velocity from the origin makes that irrelevant.

Physics is hard.

Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by cryptonector on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @04:01PM (#14705660)
LIGO is an interferometer. Light is made to interfere with itself. You can't integrate results from other LIGOs to recover the Z dimension because you'd be missing the requisite opportunity to interfere light traveling across that arm with light from the others.
Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by vpribish on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @06:59PM (#14706826)
Other detectors around the surface of the globe will be oriented on different planes. The two we have now give error-rejection and, I suppose 1-D detection. Add another in Europe and one in Australia, do some trigonometry, and bob's your uncle, no?
Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by mandarlimaye on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @07:29AM (#14701528)
Perhaps the LISA detector will be sensitive enough? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Ant...
Re:Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves by thechao on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:49AM (#14702344)
OP said "a few". The paper says LIGO et al. are sensitive up to an order of 3 or 4; planned interferometers are targeted at lower ranges. The needed device needs to be sensitive to modes of at least order 12---but preferably order 21 & higher (to cover all theories). So, realistically, they're about 18 orders of magnitude off. Conservatively.