Re:Is IBM Watson a 'Joke'?
by wodenokoto on Sunday July 02, 2017 @05:23PM
(#14684428)
How does 3 compare to something like sklearn and pandas?
I'm having a really hard time figuring out what Watson is.
Re:Is IBM Watson a 'Joke'?
by mannykannot on Sunday July 02, 2017 @06:59PM
(#14684754)
> I'm having a really hard time figuring out what Watson is.
That is consistent with danpalmer's suggestion that it is a marketing construct.
I think sklearn/pandas are very low level tools that one could use to build products like those offered by the Watson APIs. Will Watson be better than a developer playing with sklearn for a week? Yes. Will it be better than a small machine-learning focused team, working on a domain specific problem for a few months? I would doubt it.
Re:Is IBM Watson a 'Joke'?
by utkarshsinha on Sunday July 02, 2017 @08:57PM
(#14685205)
A fair comparison might be something like microsoft's cognitive services or google's cloud vision.
IBM have built several, individually successful pieces of technology, all branded as "Watson", and used the impression that they are a single entity to market it as far smarter than it actually is.
Under the hood "Watson" technologies seem to fall into 3 categories:
- The very successful publicity stunt on Jeopardy. The technology here was good, although from what I understood from tech talks given by IBM, it was a bit more brute force than you might think.
- Custom built software, often for medical and legal purposes, that is effective, if limited in scope, and comes with a hefty consulting and support contract. You're essentially buying a data science team at IBM.
- Productised machine learning APIs, that aren't particularly great, and are very isolated in their abilities.
(1) is fun but not useful to anyone really, (2) is useful, but expensive and no better than what you'd get from most other consultancies, or might be worse knowing IBM's consulting practices, and (3) is too limited to build the core of a business on, so will likely only ever be used to provide a step up until companies move technologies in house.