News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by xenophanes on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:14PM (#1466587)
> in fact Swarm SG is much deeper than Backgammon or Chess and I believe that it could even take years to master

uhhh, if it's "much deeper than chess" then it definitely takes decades to master.

One shouldn't claim to be deeper than chess without knowing the first thing about how much it's possible to study chess.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by s3graham on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:51PM (#1466656)
I'm a bit skeptical on backgammon too after playing the 'real' (non-capturing) version against turks/lebanese. Certainly it's not chess, but substantially complex.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by eru on Monday June 28, 2010 @08:54AM (#1467750)
Lots of games can be analysed quite deeply, if you care enough about it. And I agree that the analysis for chess has been done to quite deep levels.

Even humble Poker has provoked some sharp minds.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by DennisP on Monday June 28, 2010 @09:47AM (#1467892)
It's even provoked at least one advance in game theory. Some mathematicians at (iirc) the University of Alberta tried to use game theory to analyze poker, and found it was intractable. That led them to invent a systematic way to approximate complex games. (They built some good poker bots out of it, too, and sold one version as a training tool.)
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by eru on Monday June 28, 2010 @11:27AM (#1468232)
Go has also provoked some interesting developments in Combinatorial Game Theory. Conway got started with "On Numbers and Games" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Numbers_and_Games) basically got started by analysing end-game situation in Go.

Note: Combinatorial Game Theory has almost no overlap with Game Theory. Interestingly Combinatorial Game Theory has some analogies in topology. You can for example give meaning to the temperature of a game.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by st3fan on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:02PM (#1466566)
"If you are thinking of building an iPhone/iPad app I would set aside one-two weeks just to navigate the certification process, and setting up all the legal stuff that you need to have set-up just to be able to sell games (rather than give them away for free)."

Uhhh seriously?!

I know the certificate/provisioning profile stuff was broken and hard to get right in the beginning. Like 2 years ago. But now you spend 3 minutes in a Wizard and you have setup your certificates and profiles.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by cmelbye on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:41PM (#1466634)
This popped out at me as well. Especially with recent versions of Xcode, the process is incredibly simple. Run the wizard, download the files it gives you, and then open them. Boom, you're ready to run the app on your device and submit it to the store.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by ajg1977 on Monday June 28, 2010 @02:20AM (#1467250)
Sure, parts of the process are now a lot easier (and Google-able), but getting everything together for the first time would still a bit of an overwhelming process.

1-2 weeks is very extreme though.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by cubicle67 on Monday June 28, 2010 @01:36AM (#1467180)
Yeah, 2 years ago, when I first set this up, it was a hair pulling experience and took me a solid evening to get sorted. Now it's literally a 10 minute job
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by mkramlich on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:26PM (#1466511)
I bet a big factor in his iPad sales is the "gold rush" effect of being one of the first batch of iPad-only/iPad-optimized games. That's not to take away from whatever good qualities it might have. But I'm sure it is a factor.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by beambot on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:36PM (#1466410)
Pardon my ignorance, but I'm genuinely interested...

Is ~20+ sales per day considered good / high for a just-released iPad application?

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by Zev on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:58PM (#1466461)
~$100/day is ~$100/day. Its nothing special, but if you have a couple apps that sell like that, you can make a decent living.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:41PM (#1466780)
The life cycle is weeks; you probably need several apps in the store at various stages of lifecycle, and several more in development simultaneously to "make a living"
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by dminor on Sunday June 27, 2010 @11:48PM (#1466988)
Hmm that sounds suspiciously like a full time job.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by Zev on Monday June 28, 2010 @12:47AM (#1467102)
The life cycle is weeks...

Only if your plan to make money is to make a cheap, one-time-use $.99 app. If you're working in a niche or two, you can make $100/day, consistent for months/years.

Thats firsthand experience, by the way. Not me blathering on about what I think is possible.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by blueski on Sunday June 27, 2010 @11:31PM (#1466953)
Curious to understand whether Appcelerator is the best choice currently for building native apps based on HTML5 and JS.

I'd like to build an app for iPad and Android tablets so HTML5 seems the way to go. I've looked at Appcelerator and also Sencha - the latter seems to be geared more towards mobile sites rather than apps (though these can be wrapped into apps using something like Phone Gap).

It'd be a nice bonus to have a separate mobile site but native apps are my first priority.

Appreciate any thoughts.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by blueski on Monday June 28, 2010 @01:11AM (#1467142)
OK so I've looked into this more. From what I understand the difference is:

- Appcelerator transforms HTML and JS (built around its own client library) into native apps with native components.

- Sencha builds HTML5 sites using CSS3 to mimic native components and behaviors. These sites can potentially be wrapped with Appcelerator (using a Web View), Phone Gap or similar to be submitted to the Apple App Store/Android Market.

Looks like the advantage of Appcelerator is the speed and UI consistency of using true native components - and perhaps a greater chance of Apple including it in the App Store since the output (I think) is entirely Objective C. Advantage of Sencha is getting a HTML5 mobile site "for free" (if your main aim is to build apps) and in some cases more flexibility since the Appcelerator libraries don't exposure all the native functionality.

In my case I want to build something around Maps. The Appcelerator Maps component is just too limited to fit my needs right now so I'll be going down the Sencha route.

Hope this is helpful to someone. Let me know if I've missed/misunderstood something along the way.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by dugmartin on Monday June 28, 2010 @10:47AM (#1468077)
Almost. Appcelerator Mobile is a cross compiler with a component framework. It takes Javascript and compiles it into Objective-C and links it against their framework. You can build completely native apps in it.

It's a little confusing in Justin's case as he is using it to host a UIWebView which is running his game. You can do the same thing in Objective-C with a few lines of code and some magic mousedrags in Interface Builder. However, I believe he is also using Appcelerator's sqllite bindings to save game state from the UIWebView. You can also do this in Objective-C by making your own bridge from the UIWebView using intercepted custom URLs (which always feels like a dirty hack - not as clean as Flash's DOM injection using ExternalInterface).

Btw, Justin is part of a two person podcast I listen to regularly. I'd recommend subscribing:

http://techzinglive.com/

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by credo on Monday June 28, 2010 @02:37AM (#1467275)
>>"Day 5 4 Sales Day 6 27 Sales (5 reviews – 10 ratings) Day 7 59 Sales (Front page of iPad Games in New & Notworthy) Day 8 68 Sales

>>For me these stats and reviews are amazing. More than I could have hoped for."

59 and 68 sound like very low sales/day numbers for an app that is featured on the front page of "New and Noteworthy"

The numbers may indicate that the market for this app is fairly small or that some changes (in feature or price or ....) are needed to make the app more attractive to users.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by hardwareguy on Monday June 28, 2010 @08:51AM (#1467745)
The game costs $9.99 so I wouldn't epect it to sell in the thousands. If he'd have had it at $0.99 or $2.99 when it hit the front page he'd be talking about "how I made 10k sales in a week".
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by credo on Tuesday June 29, 2010 @06:48PM (#1473178)
No, the post explicitly said that the app was priced at $4.99
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by wzdd on Monday June 28, 2010 @10:13AM (#1467963)
Or perhaps the gentleman at the board games evening had a point -- how much of an app store app's sales is due to word of mouth?
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by wallflower on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:49PM (#1466653)
Good testimonial. I don't have an iPad to try it out. It seems like he created a quality product: a novel game. Yes, he created it using Titanium from Appcelerator, and he had to deal with some nasty, niggling Javascript performance/implementation issues. Key to his success was the 'First Follower' (positive reviews).
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by stcredzero on Sunday June 27, 2010 @11:35PM (#1466959)
I'm most interested in his, "way of trapping “mistake” touches and NOT acting on them."
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by nirmal on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:38PM (#1466413)
Great article but when I read the article title I thought the game was sold outside of the app store. Is there a centralized online store for selling web apps that live on the home screen and act like native apps?
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by pmjordan on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:58PM (#1466460)
In case it wasn't clear, his game isn't just a web app that lives on the home screen as a bookmark. It uses the Titanium Appcelerator, which is a thin native wrapper around a Webkit view. The app logic is written in JavaScript, rendering is done using HTML/CSS and/or SVG or so. FWIW, this actually obeys the arbitrary App Store rules: C, Objective-C, C++ and JavaScript (if run in Apple's supplied runtime) are allowed.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by nirmal on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:35PM (#1466524)
Oh, I realized that after I read the article. I just misinterpreted the title.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by silencio on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:48PM (#1466440)
No centralized store, but Apple maintains a catalog of webapps for iOS: http://www.apple.com/webapps/
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by nirmal on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:50PM (#1466443)
Thanks! I wonder what is keeping Apple from trying to cash in on some of these apps as well. Looks like there is a submission process and possibly a review process for these apps as well.
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by silencio on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:08PM (#1466481)
Because it's not a storefront to sell apps, it's just a catalog, and the developer of the webapp needs to take care of anything like that on their own. The submission/review for these is basically a cursory look to see if it's actually an iPhone webapp, categorized correctly, etc., not much more. How would Apple try to cash in on these when most of them are free or tied to a service that I assume a lot of developers created the webapp for in the first place, rather than have to fork over 30%/pay the $99 iOS Developer Program fee/deal with review hassles with Apple?
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by nirmal on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:47PM (#1466534)
Because it's not a storefront to sell apps, it's just a catalog, and the developer of the webapp needs to take care of anything like that on their own.

I understand that it is a catalog and not a store. I didn't mean to imply that the exact webpage you linked was a storefront.

How would Apple try to cash in on these when most of them are free or tied to a service that I assume a lot of developers created the webapp for in the first place, rather than have to fork over 30%/pay the $99 iOS Developer Program fee/deal with review hassles with Apple?

Other than the OP I have seen other complete applications built on top of web technologies. I can believe that there are some web devs who would be willing to have their app reviewed and do the revenue share if it meant they didn't have to worry about setting up a store front and handling payments.

Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by sitmaster on Monday June 28, 2010 @12:45PM (#1468484)
How many of you would be interested in having an API to build try and build an AI for the game? I know I would!
Re:How I sold 172 copies of my HTML iPad app in the first 8 ... by mattmaroon on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:51PM (#1466657)
"Swarm SG is much deeper than Backgammon or Chess "

I'll call.