News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by uuid on Sunday June 27, 2010 @11:44AM (#1465626)
As someone who ran a hackintosh for over a year, here's the summary:

CON - even if things work now, they can and will break in the future (removed hardware support etc)

- every update takes time and work

- don't even think about running it on the hardware you already have - only use specifically built systems (such as those linked)

- backups aren't as nice as on a mac (disk cloning, time machine)

PRO - you get a lot of harddisks (internal, cheap and fast ones)

- it's almost stupid not to use a raid setup (such as 10)

- serious GPU power is affordable, but OSX is picky

- repairs are really really cheap

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by illumin8 on Sunday June 27, 2010 @01:01PM (#1465752)
I'll second this. I built a hackintosh 2 years ago that ran 10.5 beautifully (leopard), with quad core, 4GB RAM, 750GB hard drive, for only $800. The problem is that now there is no driver support to run snow leopard, so I'm stuck running an OS from 2 years ago that probably won't be supported much longer, and I can't even install point releases very easily without risk of breaking my system.

So, 2 years later I've got a system that runs Windows or Linux beautifully but isn't really a functional Mac. This can be great for a short time, but just keep in mind that anything you build now will probably not run 10.7 when it comes out next year.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by drewcrawford on Sunday June 27, 2010 @05:53PM (#1466319)
But if you're a hacker, and you like doing it (like I do), you can bring new OS support. For instance, I wrote patches to get my system up to speed on 10.6 the week of its release. Lots of other people now use my code. That's rewarding.

Like anything, it's a tradeoff. Do you want to learn about deep osx internals? Or do you want to go back to your day job writing webapps? Both can be rewarding; it's a function of your free time and how much you want things to "just work" vs how much you want to learn.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by tvon on Sunday June 27, 2010 @05:07PM (#1466222)
What hardware did you have issues with?

Not that I necessarily recommend the hackintosh route, but if you had 10.5 running, 10.6 should run as well. I had my system moved to 10.6 within a week of it's release.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by uuid on Sunday June 27, 2010 @05:18PM (#1466242)
I had an ATI 3870 which was supported in 10.5 but ceased to be in 10.6 - a shame, since it outperformed the nvidia cards in core graphics by a large margin.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by sandaru1 on Sunday June 27, 2010 @02:23PM (#1465920)

  - don't even think about running it on the hardware you already have - 
  only use specifically built systems (such as those linked)
As far as I know, hackintosh works well in laptops. I'm running it on HP Pavilion dv5-1010us. The only hardware I can't get to work is wireless - which is admittedly quite a pain.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by uuid on Sunday June 27, 2010 @05:18PM (#1466244)
QED
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by jsz0 on Sunday June 27, 2010 @03:53PM (#1466103)
I've been playing around with Hackintoshes since the original leaked 10.4 developer build from 2005. It's really no worse than the type of upkeep and headaches you get from using Linux on the desktop in my opinion. The quality of available applications for OSX makes it worth doing if you can put up with some tinkering.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by bombs on Sunday June 27, 2010 @10:38AM (#1465529)
"As Mac OS X Snow Leopard was never meant to be installed on this hardware, any drivers that work now, may need workarounds later. There are absolutely no guarantees when it comes to this stuff- but that's what makes it fun."

I guess it has to be the fun part, because these aren't that much cheaper than a Mac mini (which won't come bundled with the same headaches).

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by GiraffeNecktie on Sunday June 27, 2010 @11:39AM (#1465618)
The $800 budget hackintosh seems roughly equivalent to a $2600 quad core Mac Pro.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by rbranson on Sunday June 27, 2010 @02:12PM (#1465898)
Roughly? The Mac Pro has a workstation-grade dual-socket motherboard with Xeon processors, ECC FB-DIMM memory, and four PCI-E x16 slots. The build quality is also significantly better than most off-the-shelf PC hardware. Granted, this isn't important to most people buying their home system to dick around with, but it IS called the "Pro" for a reason. Go spec out the same hardware from Dell or HP and you'll find similar prices.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by perlpimp on Sunday June 27, 2010 @02:41PM (#1465948)
Actually they don't use FB-DIMM ram anymore http://www.apple.com/ca/macpro/specs.html

Seems that it has gone the way of rambus.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by drewcrawford on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:02PM (#1466340)
Yeah, but you don't need that stuff unless you're Pixar or running production servers.

I think there's a market for a midrange, expandable mac. A quad-core machine with a few extra drive bays and two PCI x16 slots. A software developer's box. A Mac Mini is underpowered, but the Pro is way overpowered, esp with regards to I/O. The quad-core iMac is a step in the right direction, but it's not really expandable.

Apple has traditionally taken the position that there's not enough margin on this sort of market. But all those iOS developers have to run something. Couldn't Apple sell it at cost and write it off as developer evangelism for iOS?

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by tptacek on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:09PM (#1466482)
Probably not. Even if you (unrealistically) assume that there isn't a huge amount of overhead to designing and maintaining another Mac product, there's a huge cost involved in complicating their product line and confusing customers. Part of Apple's computer product strategy involves an extremely simple product line with few options.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by statictype on Monday June 28, 2010 @03:37AM (#1467360)
Isn't a Mac Mini a perfectly valid choice for iOS development?
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by drewcrawford on Monday June 28, 2010 @02:24PM (#1468868)
There's a pretty big difference in compile time for large projects. If you're just hacking around, sure, works great. But if you make a living on iOS and do a few hundred compiles a day, it's a no brainer to buy a quad-core or eight-core machine.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by root on Sunday June 27, 2010 @03:31PM (#1466057)
>but it IS called the "Pro" for a reason

Exactly, the money you safe on hardware you'll lose on support issues. If I were still a student I'd probably be running a hackintosh but my time now is too valuable to dick around with such a setup and afaik there are no firms offering support for hackintoshes.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by lamnk on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:47PM (#1466434)
Well with the money you save you can even build another hackintosh as backup.

But if you value the time to buy parts and assemble them more then a mac is good for you.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by mambodog on Sunday June 27, 2010 @12:36PM (#1465712)
Here in Australia, the quad-core Mac Pro is $3600 AUD, and I've built myself a similarly spec'd machine for about $2000 AUD. This included some extras, like an external pro sound card, which I highly recommend to hackintosh builders as it negates having to mess around getting the chipset sound working. That said, in my case getting onboard audio working was as simple as installing the VoodooHDA kext, but as mentioned in the article YMMV.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by w1ntermute on Sunday June 27, 2010 @01:05PM (#1465760)
And the $1350 build is rougly equivalent to a $3650 Mac Pro.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by rottencupcakes on Sunday June 27, 2010 @11:28AM (#1465597)
But they're also much more fuller spec'd than a Mac mini.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by mhd on Sunday June 27, 2010 @12:14PM (#1465673)
That's a big problem with Apple nowadays. They offer two desktops that don't have a built-in display, and there's a huge gap between the humble Mac mini and the Mac Pro. And I fear it's getting worse now that they focus so much on the mobile market.

We need a couple of new Performas...

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by jseliger on Sunday June 27, 2010 @02:23PM (#1465918)
That's a big problem with Apple nowadays.

This has been a problem with Apple since at least 2005 and really since at least 2002, when I started thinking about getting a Mac: they've never sold a decently powered, expandable box.

And it probably will continue to be a problem moving into the future.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by mhd on Sunday June 27, 2010 @03:26PM (#1466046)
Apple tries to push external solutions to expandability, i.e. USB and wireless (and failed with Firewire). This works for some stuff (hard drives), but it's still a big waste if you want to get a faster (GPU, CPU) iMac, but would be perfectly fine with your existing display. At least used Macs sell at a reasonable price…

And Mac Pros aren't consumer machines. They might look like medium to high grade desktop PCs, but Apple tends to see them more as the successor to SGIs and Sun workstations.

The problem is: Is there a real demand for a mid-range desktop? Even the normal market is migrating towards laptops. And they have the advantage that the power users see them as more disposable than laptops anyway, despite the price premium, and that even low-performance models are a good value for those that don't need the speed.

The only possible exception where I'd see some money coming it would be gamers. Steam is porting more and more games, so there'd actually be some usage scenarios, and the Mac hardware landscape isn't unified enough (GPU and CPU-wise) so that developers could gain much by optimizing one path only (as done with gaming consoles). But alas, the usual home-built gaming PC is almost on par with a Mac Pro anyway (or even superior), so what would Apple sell for that? And they wouldn't earn a lot from upgrades, as those are sold by third parties.

So as much as I'd like to see a bigger product palette from Apple, I certainly understand the reason why they're doing it like this. And it seems to work for them.

The bigger problem is that we don't have a good desktop hardware market anyway. There's no real competition. Linux doesn't sell hardware (in that range), there's no IBM/HP/Sun/SGI/Apollo Unix market, there's no Amiga, Atari or Be anymore. It's either parts, parts, parts or desktops/laptops not designed for one OS specifically – or Apple.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by bombs on Sunday June 27, 2010 @12:18PM (#1465682)
The CPU sure, but I'm wondering how usable the graphics card would be, it not being one of the graphics cards that ships with a Mac. It'd suck having am lack of drivers be a bottleneck.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by mambodog on Sunday June 27, 2010 @12:57PM (#1465747)
If you're willing to spend a bit of time following a guide to set it up properly, your performance shouldn't be much worse than the cards that ship with real Macs. Comparing with Windows, games performance is pretty average (on par with genuine Macs) but I have no trouble with video playback, window draw/effects, and even 3D work in Silo.
[deleted]
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by borisk on Sunday June 27, 2010 @11:59AM (#1465647)
There are torrents with Vmware images with preinstalled OS X (including 10.6).

BTW as far as I understand running OS X on non Apple hardware is forbidden in the EULA.

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by pudquick on Sunday June 27, 2010 @12:28PM (#1465696)
... as is running a VM instance of OS X on anything but the following: VM OS X Server (guest) on an OS X Server (host).
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by MisterWebz on Sunday June 27, 2010 @12:30PM (#1465702)
So with the Vmware it would be possible to develop Iphone apps on the PC?
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by illumin8 on Sunday June 27, 2010 @01:04PM (#1465758)
The main problem with running OSX in VMware is that quartz extreme is not supported, which means many of the apps that support video acceleration are broken. I would imagine that you could do some limited development of iphone apps, but you can forget about doing anything that uses OpenGL or OpenCL.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by borisk on Sunday June 27, 2010 @12:45PM (#1465722)
No idea, Apple may require a valid OSX/Mac serial number before registering a developer.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by PieSquared on Sunday June 27, 2010 @01:01PM (#1465751)
Both a hackintosh and a VMWare install can be used to develop iPhone apps. (I tried both, before just buying a mac for dev purposes). However, VMWare lagginess and bugginess is a pain even on a high-spec'd machine. And having a real mac is much nicer.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by MisterWebz on Sunday June 27, 2010 @02:05PM (#1465884)
Well that's very disappointing. I'm already getting an Iphone, but buying a mac as well would be too expensive/unnecessary. Perhaps there are modified versions of the necessary software to run on windows?
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by PieSquared on Sunday June 27, 2010 @10:32PM (#1466853)
Don't get me wrong - if you are on a tight budget, a Hackintosh (if you can set it up) - is very usable. You might have to forgo some things, like working audio or wireless, but it will work well enough to develop iPhone apps if you have another main computer. Sadly, VMWare is impractical for anything serious, and XCode cannot run on windows.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by drewcrawford on Monday June 28, 2010 @02:29PM (#1468893)
You can grab a low-specced Mac Mini off ebay for <$300.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by hackermom on Sunday June 27, 2010 @01:49PM (#1465850)
There are no OS X serial numbers, nor serial keys. There are unique Mac platform identifiers, but these are not used by Apple for anything today. Nothing is required of you to start developing for the iPhone, except the obvious of downloading the XCode+iPhone SDK package from ADC (which is free).
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by hackermom on Sunday June 27, 2010 @01:45PM (#1465842)
Not all countries are impaired by the inflated legal power of a EULA; they are entirely void in most of Europe.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by Locke1689 on Sunday June 27, 2010 @02:14PM (#1465902)
To be clear, enforceability of the EULA in the United States is murky as well.
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by eli on Sunday June 27, 2010 @02:57PM (#1465983)
Yeah, but installing it probably also violates anticircumvention provision of the DMCA (i.e. is criminal)

IANAL

Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by lokiujhytyu on Sunday June 27, 2010 @03:26PM (#1466043)
We in the free west laugh at your DMCA
Re:Three complete specs for OSx86 compatible PCs by Locke1689 on Monday June 28, 2010 @12:46PM (#1468487)
I hope that's a joke because the "free west" doesn't exist. Every country has their own disturbing rights violations.

Canada still runs religiously discriminated public schools in Ontario. Bill 101 in Quebec has been widely criticized as a violation of freedom of speech and freedom of language.

Britain has the right to remain silent, but your silence can be used against you in court. In addition, the truth isn't a defense against libel.

France has serious police abuse issues, to the point of torture in French prisons.

Germany's 202c essentially bans network penetration testing. Working with Metasploit could be a crime.

And so on and so forth...