Citation? I can't get the NIH study to load, but the other two are wildly different from 16/8 IF. IF proponents like to look at alternate day fasting or periodic weekly fasting and claim evidence for the effectiveness of 16/8 fasting, but going without food for >24 hours is definitely not the same as skipping breakfast, which is all 16/8 really is.
16/8 probably helps with weight loss for many people, because it shortens the eating window, which will make it easier to reduce caloric intake. But I have never seen a study that indicated 16/8 had effects similar to 24/24 or the other IF patterns typically studied.
If you try to eat 2000 calorie lunches, you'll have major lethargy in the afternoon and insomnia from hunger in the evening.
Better to use hunger as a driver during the day, then gorge and go to sleep at night.
Is this just a guess you are making, or do you have research or citations to back up this advice?
I heard about that a few weeks ago while listening to this podcast by Dr. Rhonda Patrick: http://tim.blog/2017/05/04/smart-drugs-fasting-and-fat-loss/
This article might also be of interest: http://minimalwellness.com/mealtiming/
As well as this video interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-R-eqJDQ2nU
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/world_now/2012/07/cairo-the-...
That means a population that only uses a flour that is ground locally, then immediately used within 12-48 hours after grinding. The mill grinds the entire wheat grain, under cold temperatures, sourced from older strains of grain (e.g., einkorn or emmer), without separating and then adding back in bran, etc. Before milling, the grains are held in cold or even freezing, dry, dark storage.
If such a population can be found and studied, it could support or refute these assertions that modern hybrid grain strains and modern processes for even "whole wheat" flours is causing deficiencies in our diet that are contributing to various metabolic disorders.
Whole wheat is a poorly-regulated term [1]. Baking with whole, heirloom wheat might benefit from deep learning algos, automation, and appropriate sensor tech, considering how finicky the variables are [2]. If we can solve that, then we might be able to deliver industrial-scale baked goods with all the asserted benefits, without the high prices of artisan production. There are a lot of claims surrounding the adverse effects of industrialized grain and its affiliated production [3] [4], but I don't know of anyone coming at the other end, showing populations that eat heirloom grains that are freshly-processed differ from the general population in significant ways. I'm curious if an analogous condition exists for rice.
[1] https://ww2.kqed.org/bayareabites/2013/08/16/the-whole-grain...
[2] http://www.thekitchn.com/chad-robertsons-5-essentials-for-wo...
[3] https://paleoleap.com/what-is-wrong-with-grains/
[4] https://authoritynutrition.com/modern-wheat-health-nightmare...
To lose weight, it's recommended to eat many times a day (like 5-6), but limit yourself to small portions.
Intermediate fasting (discussed elsewhere in this thread) is much closer to being a modern understanding.
Spoiler: I'm a Tunisian.
That intermittent fasting has many of the same benefits of calorie restriction is obvious if you realize that people practicing intermittent fasting usually do not compensate the lost calories in other meals. So they effectively calorie restrict. Often that is even the main goal.
I have never seen a study that indicated 16/8 had effects
similar to 24/24
It's well known when the body goes into the fasted state: after at most 12 hours. So 16/8 gives you at least 4 hours in that state, vs. 12 hours for 24/24. In addition to that there is the calorie restriction. It would be surprising if 16/8 did not confer much of the same benefits as other forms of intermittent fasting.FWIW I have moved to eating small meals every 3 hours a few years ago and have seen huge improvements in my energy and general well-being. The most key of those meals is the midnight meal that ensures I wake up full of energy and ready to go.
Nutrition is tricky.
I can't imagine what food combinations would constitute a small meal that would be eaten 5/6 times a day. Sample menu for a full day?
I tend to increase my intake right before and after gym sessions. That's why 2nd lunch and Dinner are bigger than the others.
And on this particular day I felt like having candy after dinner because I was low on carbs, so midnight meal was slightly smaller than usual.
And my pet theory is that most of the effect in energy levels and well being that people get from IF is actually just from being mindful of what they eat for the first time.
Funfact: everyone feels better when they start eating well. Exactly which trick they use to make themselves eat well isn't too important.
All that to say that so far whenever I talked to anyone who's discovered intermittent fasting and said how much more energy they have now than they did before, when asked about their habits before, it's usually something like "Oh I just ate whatever I could find at random times in the day with pretty much no thought given to what I'm doing"
I didn't notice anything different yet besides that I can more or less eat what I want and not gain any weight.
1. Calorie restriction is almost impossible for most humans to follow long term
2. Many of the same benefits of calorie restriction may be achievable through intermittent fasting, which is much easier for people to follow. I've been experimenting with a daily 16 hour fast (all calories consumed within an 8-hour window) and have seen small improvements in my energy and general well-being, although it's decades too early to say how this will impact my longevity.
Relevant articles: https://www.nature.com/articles/srep33739 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2622429/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-hunger-gains-...