News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by d--b on Sunday June 25, 2017 @01:59AM (#14628848)
I think it's a bit naive to believe that guitar heroes can bring the interest for the guitar back. People look back at the guitar heroes time with a nostalgic fondness for a time that doesn't exist anymore. This was already visible in Wayne's world and became more than obvious in school of rock. Guitar-heavy rock has become a geek genre. Pop has moved on.

There are obviously various reasons for this: 1. Technologically the instrument ran its course. While the tech was still innovative in the 90s with the new digital effects, it hasn't changed much in 20 years. 2. Electronic music however has brought in a lot of new sounds that gave pop music a fresh start in the 2000s 3. People seem to be more interested in 2 things: dancing and lyrics. You could write songs with totally inintelligible lyrics and a good solo, and you'd have a hit. I don't think that's true anymore. Similarly a solo kind of ruins the dancing.

I think die hard rock fans need to get over it, guitar heroes are not coming back any time soon. I don't think it means the electric guitar is going to die. It still is an amazingly cool instrument. But, it means that your average kid may not want to try to play that "ten years after" intro anymore.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by johan_larson on Sunday June 25, 2017 @03:20AM (#14628999)
The electric guitar is now what the saxophone was in the fifties: the iconic instrument of the hottest music of dad's generation.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by fh973 on Sunday June 25, 2017 @05:37AM (#14629317)
Hold on, I am a not very young dad and the music of my youth was with two turntables and a mic. The 90s golden age of hip hop :) There was also electronic music like techno, drum and bass, ...

Guitar music is I'd say evergreen, but hasn't been the hottest thing for much longer.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by johan_larson on Sunday June 25, 2017 @05:42AM (#14629328)
OK, so it's the music of dad's dad's generation. I was double-extra right. :)
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by s3graham on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:08AM (#14630036)
Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins, Soundgarden, Metallica... 90s were still pretty hot on guitars.

(Maybe less so by the late 90s, so maybe I'm a few years old than you :)

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by agumonkey on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:19AM (#14629551)
Funny how saxophone was a big sidewinger in 80s pop too.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by zwieback on Sunday June 25, 2017 @09:57AM (#14629983)
I tried and failed at playing the solo from Urgent on my sax
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by InitialLastName on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:54AM (#14630253)
Let's be fair, the saxophone had a quick resurrection in the late 90's/early 00's.

Source: Played baritone sax in an early 2000's ska band

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by meggar on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:27PM (#14630778)
At least we can always count on ska coming back. Isn't it about time for the fourth wave?
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by grondilu on Sunday June 25, 2017 @06:05AM (#14629366)
That may be an accurate comparison.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by zdkl on Sunday June 25, 2017 @03:13AM (#14628989)
I think you're missing the point. The question is certainly not whether the guitar heroes of old inspire new generations to the same extent it did us. Sure pop has moved on from the image of hairy flashy axe wielding fairies shredding away while 3 other dudes prance around. But that's fashion. It has little to do with the instrument and everything to do with fads and marketing. Also you can sure as hell not ruin dancing with a solo (Black Sabbath, Led zep, Red Fang more recently!?), the issue is that there are too many fretboard wankers who pushed technical style for technical style's sake. That is what I hope the next generation of metal/rock guitarists will break away from.

Keep it heavy, and keep it coming \m/ (sorry hn)

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by iainmerrick on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:57AM (#14629637)
There's a whole section near the end of the article about a noticeable bump in sales of guitars to women, inspired by Taylor Swift. You just have to be more flexible about what "guitar hero" can mean.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by hoorayimhelping on Sunday June 25, 2017 @08:09AM (#14629665)
I think even the most flexible definition of guitar hero shouldn't include Taylor Swift. I'd say that style of guitar - using it for texture under the song - is antithetical to guitar heroism. The guitar became heroic because it broke out of the background music section of the band that supports the singer and became a star in its own right. It was another avenue of expression just by itself. Strumming some chords on an acoustic guitar as part of a song where the focus is the story of the lyrics doesn't require a guitar. It could be swapped with a keyboard, or a mandolin or a piano and it wouldn't really change the song that much.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by iainmerrick on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @12:28PM (#14646839)
There are other approaches to the guitar that are just as historically significant as the Hendrix-style electric solo. Not long before that, in the folk music boom, the acoustic guitar was seen as the ultimate democratic instrument -- you could toss it in the back of your car, drive to a gig or a party, and start playing immediately (rhythm, harmony, melody, whatever you like).
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by sdenton4 on Sunday June 25, 2017 @11:15AM (#14630360)
An electric guitar is really just six independent oscillators with an archaic user interface...
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by throwawaylolol on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:00PM (#14630626)
And music is really just a the electrical impulses from bunch of soundwaves banging up against the membrane in our eardrums. Jeez, that kind of reductionism really kills the magic (not to mention ignoring the talent and feel involved for an artist to make those oscillators 'speak' to you)
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by abiox on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @05:36PM (#14649702)
"It is a poor poet that falls silent when he finds out that the sun is actually a massive sphere of hydrogen fusing into helium." -Richard Feynman
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by moogly on Sunday June 25, 2017 @11:25AM (#14630415)
> 1. Technologically the instrument ran its course. While the tech was still innovative in the 90s with the new digital effects, it hasn't changed much in 20 years.

This is... whilst not exactly incorrect, it's not the whole truth either. The article touched a little bit on this with the robotic tuner thing, but didn't fully explain why.

In my experience partaking in internet guitar forums over the decades, the vast majority of guitar players are really conservative. Extremely conservative. Especially people who mostly are into Fender/Gibson/PRS. They shun every new material (graphite/carbon fiber necks/fretboards), even if it has clear advantages (torsion/tensile/impact strength, weight, temperature/humidity insensitivity), often with unscientific emotional-based hand-waving like "it sounds too cold".

Headless guitars also stayed niche, even though they have clear advantages (lighter, shorter, more well-balanced, can't break your headstock off — a quite common way to damage your guitar).

It also took decades for 7-string guitars not to get scoffed at. The first 15+ years you had a lot of guitarists making fun of people with 7-string guitars. After they became somewhat accepted, 8-string guitars had an easier time, mind you.

People are very sceptical of True Temperament (http://www.truetemperament.com/) as well, believing that you can't perform string bending (you can, it doesn't really feel any different), and decided that to be the truth without even bothering to try.

There are still many areas on the guitar you can improve and innovate (and some stuff out there already that primarily Ned Steinberger showed us in the 80s could (and IMO should) be standard), but people want fragile, heavy and climate-sensitive "tonewood" in their guitars. They want soft brass bridges. They want maintenance-heavy soft "nickel/silver" (actually brass and nickel) frets. They want headstocks.

Maybe these old people in the article (I'm 37 so I'm one of them as well, I guess) are the problem, and when younger people that don't revere the word "vintage" so much can usher in the era of the truly modern guitar that Ned Steinberger has shown us glimpses of? One can only hope.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by jdietrich on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:06PM (#14630653)
>Maybe these old people in the article (I'm 37 so I'm one of them as well, I guess) are the problem, and when younger people that don't revere the word "vintage" so much can usher in the era of the truly modern guitar that Ned Steinberger has shown us glimpses of? One can only hope.

It's already happening. A huge proportion of young guitarists are playing metal, which is a hugely progressive scene in terms of technology. The coolest young guitarists are playing Strandberg Bodens, Kiesel Vaders and the weird and wonderful stuff from Ibanez's Iron Label. 7, 8 and 9 strings, fanned frets, headless, active electronics, carbon and titanium reinforcement, it's all on the table. They're abandoning valve amps in favour of Helix, AxeFX and Bias. They couldn't give a toss about Hendrix and Clapton - they revere the likes of Tosin Abasi and Rob Scallion.

The baby boomers have disproportionate influence because they've got a ton of disposable income, but big changes are afoot in the guitar business.

The future of guitar looks very much like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sMbW4sptVnE

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by moogly on Sunday June 25, 2017 @01:12PM (#14631017)
Sure. Headless designs is going in the right direction IMO, but other than that, don't fool yourself, the Strandberg and Kiesel guitars etc. are still very traditional designs:

Wooden body, wooden neck, wooden fretboard, and in the case of Strandberg, Ibanez AANJ-style neck joint and silver/nickel frets (Carvin/Kiesel have neck-through and SS frets as options, or at least used to have). Most, if not all parts, you can get from Warmoth/All Parts, no custom designed parts there, apart from maybe the Strandberg's string fastening mechanism/headpiece, but that one is pretty crude, to be honest.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by jdietrich on Sunday June 25, 2017 @01:54PM (#14631234)
Strandberg use stainless frets and carbon neck reinforcement on everything but the entry-level Classic model. Stainless frets are a $40 option on any Kiesel and carbon reinforcement is standard on any of their extended-range guitars. The Strandberg headpiece and bridge is made in-house; Kiesel use custom headless hardware designed in collaboration with Hipshot. Strandberg use fanned frets throughout their range and Kiesel offer it as an option on most of their solid-body guitars.

There are merits to both the neck-through construction used on the Kiesel Vader and the bolt-on joint used by Strandberg. Through-necks are arguably more stable, but bolt-ons are far easier to maintain and repair.

The Strandberg neck profile is anything but conventional:

https://strandbergguitars.com/strandberg-endurneck/

There's nothing terribly wrong with wood construction. It's aesthetically pleasing, relatively economical and more than strong, stiff and stable enough when used appropriately.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by luckydata on Sunday June 25, 2017 @01:35PM (#14631133)
C'mon, innovation is clearly trickling down. It all began with Ken Parker:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dR01zIjj4_w

Line6 has created the Variax that uses the piezo signal of each string to model other stringed instruments and their electronic system (and even things like banjos and resonator guitars)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UYHJaL6g6Jc

and now even Music Man is adopting steel frets lately. Guitars evolve slowly but they do evolve.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by mickael-kerjean on Sunday June 25, 2017 @09:28PM (#14633358)
Thank for the discovery of Covet And Rob Scallon
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by eyeJam on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:07PM (#14630663)
> can't break your headstock off — a quite common way to damage your guitar

Really? Are people using their guitars as hammers? I think it's pretty damn hard to break a headstock off. Much more common damage to a guitar is denting the frets, distorting the neck or busting the tuning pegs. I'd put "breaking off the headstock" as the 99th percentile of common ways people materially damage their guitar.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by jdietrich on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:44PM (#14630862)
Gibson guitars are notorious for broken headstocks, due to an archaic and inherently defective design. Modern scarf-jointed headstocks do occasionally break, but they're more prone to cracking around the machine head holes.

https://www.google.com/search?q=gibson+broken+headstock&tbm=...

http://jacksinstrumentservices.com/why-do-les-paul-headstock...

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by eyeJam on Sunday June 25, 2017 @06:32PM (#14632584)
I stand corrected
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by moogly on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:55PM (#14630925)
I should've said accidental damage. Dropping the guitar. Knocking the stand over. Shipping damage. Guitar trauma, basically.

Tuning pegs don't really tend to fail. Unless you have those "vintage" Les Paul-style ones (yuck), but they're easy to replace.

Frets get worn down, necks tend to bow or arch, or at worst warp (more seldom). Fret recrowning/redressing, truss rod adjustment and fretboard leveling are part of the regular maintenance of a long-lived electric guitar.

Now, headstock breakages are usually pretty easy to fix for a luthier, and the result is stronger, since a glued joint is stronger, just not as strong as a glued scarf joint.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by elihu on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:46PM (#14630868)
It's common with Gibsons due to the angle of the headstock relative to the grain of the wood.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by elihu on Sunday June 25, 2017 @08:16PM (#14633008)
I don't think it's just conservatism. When buying a guitar, most buyers are primarily concerned with three things: does it sound good, is it easy to play, and does it look good.

Graphite and carbon fiber has superior properties in some respect, but substituting carbon fiber for wood doesn't necessarily make the guitar sound or look better or improve playability. Compared to acoustic instruments, electric guitars are low maintenance and durable. People in very humid or very dry environments might prefer carbon fiber to wood, but for most of us, wood is fine.

Robotuners similarly don't solve a significant problem that most players have, and they're complex and probably costly to make and introduce a battery to a guitar that didn't need one before. The convenience of automatic tuners probably aren't worth the costs.

Headless guitars similarly don't solve a particular problem, as far as I can tell. I expect to be able to rest a guitar on leg and not have it tip one way or the other while I'm playing. Most guitars balance fine with a proper headstock. I haven't tried a Steinberger, maybe they're really great guitars, but there's no particular reason for me to expect that I would enjoy playing a headless guitar more than a "normal" guitar. (Note: I have built headless cigar box guitars [1], and I kind of like the design, but that's a bit different than a full-size electric.)

True Temperament is more interesting because that actually is addressing a real problem, sort of. Electric guitars are pretty bad when it comes to tuning, but the problem isn't so much intonation, the bigger problem is that 12-tone equal temperament is a compromise -- you can sound okay in every key (12-TET) or you can sound really good in one particular key (just intonation), but you can't have both. (The latter alternative leads you to some interesting looking fingerboards [2].)

I would be more interested in the TT guitars if they were focusing on temperament rather than intonation errors. (I suspect they may actually be doing that, but their marketing material says they're correcting intonation. I'm skeptical that any normal guitars would need such extreme corrections just to play in exact 12-TET unless the action is set unreasonably high.)

TT also has the problem that normal frets can be repaired or replaced by any competent luthier using ordinary guitar tools, but I wouldn't even know you would do a fret dress on TT guitar. Maybe you'd need a special crowning file that goes around corners or something?

I think there are some ways that the electric guitar could be improved, but to some degree, I think unscientific emotional hand-wavy reasons can be a better guide to making an instrument people want than to approach the problem by using science to optimize specific criteria based on some untested assumption that optimizing that criteria will make the guitar better.

[1] http://jsnow.bootlegether.net/cbg/neck2.jpg

[2] http://jsnow.bootlegether.net/jik/CAM00441.jpg

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by kinleyd on Sunday June 25, 2017 @06:39AM (#14629465)
<I think it's a bit naive to believe that guitar heroes can bring the interest for the guitar back.>

Isn't it the heroes in any field that inspire others to take it up? Or are you saying that there can never be another guitar hero again who will be good enough to inspire another generation? That would be naive, wouldn't it, considering how awesome the electric guitar is?

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by mcv on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @05:34AM (#14643647)
> I think die hard rock fans need to get over it, guitar heroes are not coming back any time soon.

I disagree. The guitar isn't gone yet, and even if there are newer instruments, the guitar will be with us for a long time.

And there's more to music than dancing. Even if guitars will be playing second fiddle to computers, they'll remain relevant just like violins are still relevant (and perhaps making a comeback in the hands of people like Lindsey Stirling). Besides, I need guitars in my dance music. Dance music shouldn't be sterile. The dirty, distorted sound of a guitar gives my the energy to dance in a way that an electronic beat does not.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by Nav_Panel on Sunday June 25, 2017 @08:09AM (#14629667)
> Similarly a solo kind of ruins the dancing.

The right kind of solo can accelerate the dancing. 80s pop had it all figured out in this regard: some of the best dance music ever made while also being phenomenal pop music.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by manmal on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:04AM (#14629515)
Nickleback is a good example of a band that keeps the guitar alive. Yes, they don't play ANY soli (or do they?), but they get serious airtime and I haven't heard kids call them old-fashioned..
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by snarfy on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:22AM (#14629564)
Of all the examples to pick from...
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by manmal on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:35AM (#14629596)
So I'm downvoted on HN for mentioning Nickleback now?

If you listen to the whole of their albums and not only the commercial hits, it's a really solid rock band.

Now give me some of the other examples of rock bands that regularly make it to the top 10.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by anoonmoose on Sunday June 25, 2017 @08:20AM (#14629691)
The writing is juvenile, the band's attitude towards other music is insulting, every album sounds more or less the same, and there's an argument to be made that their fame partially stems largely from a Canadian law requiring Canadian music to make up a certain percentage of radio time. According to sources[0], their new album is getting outsold by Jason Isbell & The 400 Unit's new album, they're a fairly straight country act, so I'm not sure I'm even willing to take Nickelback's popularity as a given in 2017.

Like the other commenter said, Foo Fighters would have made a better example. Maybe Coldplay. Chili Peppers. Look, I understand that art is subjective, but at the end of the day, some art is less subjective than others. Nickelback deserves their spot in the pantheon of groups who get shit on whenever you mention them.

[0]https://headlineplanet.com/home/2017/06/20/nickelbacks-feed-...

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by manmal on Sunday June 25, 2017 @09:14AM (#14629830)
You have a rational access to music, and I respect that; though not everybody cares about an artist's street cred while listening to their music. Indeed, country seems to take over the guitar torch, and why not. Coldplay mostly doesn't even have sounds that resemble a guitar anymore. Chili Peppers, yeah why not! I want guitars to somehow stay in the charts, or I'll feel quite obsolete with my hobby (electric guitar)..
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by metaobject on Sunday June 25, 2017 @10:22AM (#14630107)
I realize that you qualified your remark about Coldplay with "anymore", but it should be noted that their first two releases were guitar-centric and they were actually musically amazing (imo). I don't know about their more recent releases, although I believe they collaborated with The Chainsmokers for at least one of their latest songs. I'm not sure if this is representative of all their new songs, though.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by Naga on Sunday June 25, 2017 @09:16AM (#14629841)
CanCon, as the process is known, has many problems. It has forced radio stations to constantly play the Tragically Hip as well, who I would argue deserve to be played.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by snarfy on Sunday June 25, 2017 @08:36AM (#14629727)
I'm not hating on them. I mentioned it because the hive mind certainly does and so seemed a poor example.

I'm not a fan because they are unoriginal and re-use the same template in their production software for multiple songs.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4258547

They also seemed to take a few to many liberties with their 'inspiration', e.g.

Hero - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZuX0RdK0HF8

vs

Kiss From A Rose - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yivLt9cTaio

The melodies are a little too close to gain my respect. It's like they were tasked with making music for a Batman movie and started browsing the previous movie scores.

Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by SmellyGeekBoy on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:49AM (#14629623)
Foo Fighters?
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by laumars on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:03PM (#14630642)
A topical example considering they were the headline act at Glastonbury last night.
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by manmal on Sunday June 25, 2017 @08:16AM (#14629681)
That's a legit example and I dig them a lot!
Re:The slow death of the electric guitar by douche on Sunday June 25, 2017 @07:55AM (#14629632)
Green Day had their moment, although it has passed.

The Black Keys are good, but maybe not that mainstream.

The best show I've ever seen was Avenged Sevenfold, which is definitely in the metal niche. But I'll never forget when they had a break in the middle of the show, and their lead guitarist came out and just solo'd for a while. Incredible talent.