News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medieval Scholars Believed in the Possibility of Parallel... by dredmorbius on Sunday June 25, 2017 @12:04AM (#14628573)
There are some broader lessons from this than who believed what and when (or what other philosophical or religious traditions had similar or "better" beliefs).

Belief based solely on faith has a pronounced tendency to go off in the weeds. That's the distinction which the scientific method makes, particularly in the tradition of the bacons -- Roger Bacon (13th c.) and Francis Bacon (16th c.), no relation. Each emphasised the value of observation or experimentation.

Second: if you find your premises, or traditional authorities, at odds with observed reality, you might care to strongly favour dismissing your premises or authorities, rather than your observations -- so long as the latter seem to be independently verifiable. An interesting case of this developed most especially in the 19th century, within the field of geology, where the record of the stones was found in marked difference to the record of the scripts, particularly the biblical record. Noted geologists spent not inconsiderable time attempting reconciliation of these records. There was no reconciliation possible, of course, one of those records was simply wrong.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Dwight_Dana#Publicatio...

Third: if you've found a persistent discord between observation and theory, then it's quite likely you've illuminated a lacuna in your knowledge or understanding. Again to geology: it was clear from the geologic record that the Earth was at least some hundreds of millions of years old, but no known force or energy could explain the observed temperature of the Earth's interior. The answer to this turned out to be previously unknown form of energy potential and release: radioactivity. That also happened to provide the clock by which the Earth's age could be determined, as well as the mechanism by which geology is ultimatley founded: plate tectonics. Not fully accepted, it turns out, until 1965, though it's now considered the fundamental organising principle of geology. Which gives us a fourth lesson:

Fourth: You can study a thing for a long, long, long time before you come to a proper understanding of it.

Fifth: Study of ancient authorities isn't wholly useless. I advise people to look to philosophy, especially, if not for truth then as a record in how the truth, and error, are arrived at, over time.

And finally: it's not enough to come to the correct answer, but to come to the correct answer through the right chain of reasoning. Science is structured knowledge. It's not a dry recitation of facts, but rather, the structure, through which, those facts become evident. If not self-evident, then building on observation and mechanism. Precursors of current understanding, absent the underlying structural foundation, are interesting, but are not science as it's properly considered.

Re:Medieval Scholars Believed in the Possibility of Parallel... by simonh on Sunday June 25, 2017 @03:28AM (#14629013)
Good stuff, but that last point is what a lot of critics of science don't get. We don't believe scientific discoveries, such as that the speed of light in a vacuum is a universal limit, because a famous scientist proved it years ago and now we take it on faith. We believe is because every physics student that goes through university and studies this stuff proves it themselves from first principles. We believe it because we have followed through the chain of reasoning, studied the experimental equipment and done the experiment ourselves. Many of us anyway. These experiments and the principles they are based on haven't been proven a few times, in many cases they've been proven hundreds of thousands of times.
Re:Medieval Scholars Believed in the Possibility of Parallel... by dredmorbius on Sunday June 25, 2017 @04:07AM (#14629116)
Right.

I don't know if you caught wind of any of the "decolonising science" movement, one adherent of whom claims that science is based on who says a thing is so. The truth is the exact inverse. The motto of the Royal Academy is particularly instructive: In nullis verba. By the word of no one.