News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by steveklabnik on Thursday June 24, 2010 @01:44PM (#1458595)
I was always taught that saying "In my opinion" was bad form. You're making a statement, of course it's your opinion! To say so is just repeating yourself.

So when I read REWORK, I see it as "Here's how I built my business. You could do the same." When I read Crush It, I hear "This is how I, @garyvee, built my business. You could do the same." I don't hear, "This is always the way that it works in every business ever." Maybe that's just me.

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by ryanwaggoner on Thursday June 24, 2010 @02:19PM (#1458673)
In my opinion, I think you're wrong.

In some cases (like mine above) it is unnecessary to specify that it's your opinion, because it's truly and obviously an opinion. But not every statement made is someone's opinion [1]. For example:

   "In my opinion, the earth revolves around the Sun."
   "In my opinion, Barack Obama is the 44th President of the United States."
   etc.
Because some statements are clear and simple facts, it can sometimes be useful to delineate opinion from fact, especially in cases where it's not explicitly clear which type of statement is being made. In most cases, I think that it's pretty clear from the context that 37signals' is writing from their own experience and sharing their opinions, and thus littering their writing with "weasel words" would diminish the quality of the writing.

However, in many cases (including some by 37signals), writers intentionally leave out the "weasel words" not because their statements are obviously opinion, but because they know it will get people riled up and serve as good linkbait. Ironically, they often fall back to this whole idea of "of course it's only my opinion, weasel words are bad writing, etc", which strikes me as kind of a reverse-weasel. Write as if you're stating absolute truth (in order to get links), even when you aren't, and then hide behind "good writing" when people complain.

[1] I'm really not interested in the greater philosophical questions of whether it's opinion that the earth revolves around the sun. If you are, be my guest, but I'm fully prepared to just accept some things as fact. The earth revolving around the sun is one of them :)

EDIT: I might have been using "heliocentricism" wrong, so I removed it to prevent ambiguity.

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by chc on Thursday June 24, 2010 @03:12PM (#1458835)
I think people read in the "linkbait" reasoning much more often. The simple truth is that even when there's some slight ambiguity, constantly printing disclaimers about how this is your opinion, other people think differently, you don't have to believe what I'm saying, etc. — it's annoying and detracts from the actual flow of information, and the benefit is questionable at best in many cases. (Even the people who complain about the "confusing" absolutism seem to understand what Fried actually means, and I suspect most other people understand it correctly as well.)

I haven't read Rework, but in "Getting Real," they had two paragraphs on one page explaining all of the above: "Yes, this is purely based on our experience. Some people do it differently and it works. We're just telling you about our way of doing things." And then the rest of the book was written simply, without cushioning. I think that's a fine compromise.

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by nudge on Thursday June 24, 2010 @02:24PM (#1458691)
Reverse-weasel is my new favourite concept.
Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by cabacon on Thursday June 24, 2010 @04:07PM (#1458979)
Quite related, I think, is preterition: the act of mentioning something by saying you won't mention it. I seem to encounter it from computer/math people a lot, it's nice to have a name for the action.
Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by mkramlich on Thursday June 24, 2010 @04:59PM (#1459105)
And within 24 hours somebody, somewhere on the Internet will upload some sort of porn based on it, of course, and it will be to 4chan.
Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by sqrt17 on Friday June 25, 2010 @03:44AM (#1460257)
The idea is that, if you think the reader will just accept something as a fact, you don't need to hedge it.

If your reader will see it as an arguable point (instead of an uncontroversial fact), then you should make (or at least sketch) the argument, because you're not a sect leader or anyone else who can spoon-feed "truth" to his minion. You should make the argument because you want the reader to be able to disagree with you and see where he/she still follows you. And if it's not worth making an argument, there's an opportunity to make the text shorter and more concise by exactly that sentence.

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by allend on Thursday June 24, 2010 @07:42PM (#1459516)
In my opinion, it is kinda like how you just know 37signals sometimes leaves out weasel words to get people riled up and serve as good linkbait.

Wait, did I need the 'in my opinion' or not? I am confused now.

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by nerfhammer on Thursday June 24, 2010 @08:31PM (#1459620)
insightful comment of the day
Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by humblepatience on Friday June 25, 2010 @01:26AM (#1460078)
Except, 37signals articles are clearly not statements of facts.

If they were, your point would be awesome. But they are clearly opinion.

"Resumes are dumb" != "The earth revolves around the sun"

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by MartinCron on Thursday June 24, 2010 @02:09PM (#1458640)
You are just being an informed and literate reader

If someone says "this is the way it works in every business ever" you can immediately know they are full of it.

I found Rework mostly unremarkable, but I do appreciate the way they are saying "you don't have to do things the same way everyone always has" so loudly.

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by nudge on Thursday June 24, 2010 @02:22PM (#1458685)
Your 'maybe it's just me' is a good example of what is often lacking in the 37signals writings. I haven't read rework, but Getting Real is exactly like this article describes: locally, even widely locally, good advice, presented with a presumably more easily rhetorically digestible universality.

The problem is that it's a lot harder to build a following while permitting doubt or ambiguity. So what you have is a number of extremely popular figures who each present what has worked for them without even entertaining the idea that that doesn't necessarily imply that it is the best way to do things, always and in all places. And the gurus often don't agree, but nobody seems to mind too much until the gurus' own projects finally triumph or fail, after which point the correct point of view immediately takes on the property of always having been obvious.

It's not necessarily JF's fault. The rewards for stridency are great, because there is always an audience for it.

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by ryanwaggoner on Thursday June 24, 2010 @02:25PM (#1458696)
It's not necessarily JF's fault. The rewards for stridency are great, because there is always an audience for it.

This is such a great explanation for what's going on here. I've often wondered if people who have been really successful at one thing and preach that method only (read: almost all gurus) are perhaps less informed about success and what will get you there than people who read a number of the gurus. Maybe they just got lucky :|

Re:Calling out Jason Fried for bad business advice by InclinedPlane on Thursday June 24, 2010 @03:27PM (#1458872)
Some things are facts backed up by hard evidence. Humans need Oxygen to live, that's not my opinion. It's important to note when you are stating an opinion. Not least because it can help set the right tone for a discussion.

If you state "this is my opinion, what's yours? I'm open to changing it if I hear a good argument or am exposed to new evidence" that sets the tone for a much different conversation than "these are the facts in my universe, for all you know they may be beliefs for which I would rather die than acknowledge they are even the slightest bit imperfect". When you say "I think ..." or "in my opinion ..." you are signaling something closer to the first message, when you don't you may be signaling something closer to the 2nd message.