News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by spodek on Saturday June 17, 2017 @08:02AM (#14575515)
This community is so fast to say Mars is possible. Mention any problem and it will start with the belief it's solvable and figure out how: "We can do it!"

Mention the idea of lowering the population on Earth to allow more resources per person or consuming less to pollute less and it's "It's against human nature" and "Absolutely impossible" and "Fusion or fission will make that unnecessary, we should grow forever."

I wish people here looked at reducing growth and consumption here -- changing mental models from growth to "enough" -- as something as attainable as terraforming another planet, or even with enthusiasm.

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by Anonymous107747 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @08:40AM (#14575639)
I think that you're missing the point. Your comment implies that you think colonization efforts are solely to solve resource problems on Earth.

The most important point of colonization is that it ensures no single event can wipe out humanity. Rather than encouraging lowering the population of Earth, we want it to increase. The larger Earth's population, the more people who will volunteer to join colonies. We need to spread humanity as far and wide.

As for the attainability of colonization, I expect that it is a matter of time. As is often brought up, it was once thought that flight was unachievable; and now we send out thousands of flights every day.

For now, attempting to harvest near-Earth resources seems to be the best approach to colonization. It requires many of the same advances while providing a strong short-term incentive.

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by gehwartzen on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:17PM (#14578497)
Why is it so important to spread humanity far and wide? And why would it be bad if humans went extinct sometime in the distant future?
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by Anonymous107747 on Sunday June 18, 2017 @12:10AM (#14578930)
I won't attempt to convince you with philosophical arguments, as there are none. Whatever philosophical argument I might make, someone will just counter with nihilism.

The only argument is biological. It's the same reason nihilists continue to live. Survival is an essential trait of all species. Ultimately it can be argued that all of our advances had that purpose in mind.

Spreading humanity far and wide helps to satisfy our need for survival. You might argue that it doesn't affect you, as by the time we colonize other systems you will be long dead. But when you produce offspring, you care less about your own survival than the survival of your offspring. That is to say, your need for survival is transferred to your offspring. As long as they survive, you survive in the form of the genetic material you pass on and the knowledge you have endowed upon them.

Presently, the greatest danger to humanity is self-annihilation. Making the transition to an interstellar species is imperative in order to eliminate this danger.

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by hollerith on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:31PM (#14578527)
Well, a person can care about dozens of separate things. It does not take much of a commitment to a thing to have conversations with others interested in the thing or to write about it on the internet. (And over the years, a small commitment to something can grow.)

If you meant to ask, "why should I care . . .," then I hope you will excuse me if I leave that one unanswered.

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by gehwartzen on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:49PM (#14578567)
I suppose I'm asking why should we, in general sense, should care; i.e what is the philosophical argument. I agree human suffering is bad but if we are all to die "instantly" (relative to out overall time in existence as a species) I'm not sure I see the argument for why that would be bad. The other argument I suppose is that the universe itself would somehow suffer if we were not in it, but again I'm not sure I fully understand the rationale.
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by hollerith on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:46PM (#14578715)
Maybe this is a little glib, but I've learned to pay less attention to arguments as to why a person should value X or Y and to pay more attention to any information that would help me predict (and when I am feeling bold, to influence) what people (and what groups of people working towards a common goal) actually value, i.e., to what "ultimate" ends are they actually willing to invest sustained effort and to sacrifice. (The purpose of the word "ultimate" in that last sentence is to distinguish between ends or goals that almost everyone has to work towards (which some call "instrumental" goals) and ends that do not have that property (ultimate or "terminal" goals).

For example, at least in the U.S., almost everyone has to put in sustained effort to produce an income and if they fail at that goal then they will struggle to achieve any goal (good or evil). Consequently, in the terminology I've just introduced, ensuring an adequate income would at least where I live constitute an instrumental rather than an ultimate goal. It is people's ultimate goals that I am the most interested learning about.

An internet manifesto with 10,000 signatures tends to matter less -- tends to have less of an effect on reality -- IMHO than a few relatively rational people willing to put in a few hours of effort every month towards an ultimate goal (or some collection of values that includes an ultimate value) as long as they can keep up the effort for long enough. By "effort" I mean effort sufficient to keep a job that many other people want (doled out at a rate of a few hours a month on average).

Also, people underestimate the importance of what (evil) things you (or I) are not willing to do and overestimate the importance of what good outcomes (e.g., curing cancer or ending world hunger) a person or group is aiming to achieve.

In other words, I believe that if the only thing you (or I) accomplish in the world is never doing any harm to any person -- never to steal anything that according to the generally-believed ethical standards of your society rightfully belongs to them, never to lie to them (particular for personal gain) -- then you (or I) will have done more net good than the vast majority of currently living human beings.

Since I started believing those last 2 paragraphs in 1992, however, I've met very few (but not 0 or 1) effective people who agree with them, so I will backtrack somewhat to the position that it is at least worth studying whether what I just asserted is as an important human cognitive bias.

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by sillysaurus3 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @08:11AM (#14575545)
Mention the idea of lowering the population on Earth to allow more resources per person or consuming less to pollute less and it's "It's against human nature" and "Absolutely impossible" and "Fusion or fission will make that unnecessary, we should grow forever."

Eugenics is edgy and the idea deserves an edgy death.

I hate to give a glib dismissal, but what else is there to say on that topic? No one can do it short of becoming the next AI overlord empire. It's like wishing for anti-gravity. It'd be quite convenient, but how?

We've also seen how well China's "one child per family" mandate worked out, so we even have evidence that it doesn't seem to work.

I almost don't want to entertain the question due to the trainwreck of a thread that might ensue, but I've been pleasantly surprised by HN before. I think prompting can make the difference. So:

If we all promise to be very substantive, how might it be possible to implement "population control"?

This is probably the ultimate test of self-control, too. Can intellectualism prevail over the urge to strike down an idea? Let's find out.

You'll need to be very substantive in your response if you're to have any hope of thoughtful conversation, so please don't put in a halfhearted effort into the opportunity of your choosing. Everyone's listening -- what do you propose?

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by protonfish on Saturday June 17, 2017 @08:46AM (#14575659)
Except we already see negative population growth in all countries with a reasonable standard of living. The USA (and many European countries) would not be growing were it not for immigration. Places with high birth rates are often correlated with a stressful environment like war and extreme poverty. (When you can't be certain how much time you have left to live or how many of your children will survive, it makes sense to have any many children as soon as possible.) Also, the efforts against access to birth control by organizations like the Catholic Church or Texas's "abstinence only education" can unnaturally increase birth rates.

Reducing population growth is the struggle to reduce poverty, war, and oppression against women. We also would need to confront powerful organizations with anti-birth control agendas.

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by lukas099 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:30AM (#14576030)
Surely you mean negative change in population growth?
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by protonfish on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:55PM (#14576631)
No, I don't. Negative population growth is when the population growth is less than one per person.
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by dgudkov on Saturday June 17, 2017 @11:49AM (#14576367)
The problem with lowering the population is that it would lead to slowing technical progress as well. The fewer humans we have the fewer high-IQ humans are born, the less is advance in science and technology.

One of the major benefits of space colonization is to increase human population so that it produces more high-IQ people that can keep advancing humanity. All that progress in the last 200 years can be attributed to larger amount of high-IQ people born which is a direct consequence of total population growth. Stopping growing population would lead to stagnation in technical progress.

Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by lxmorj on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:30PM (#14578523)
One is something you can do, the other is something you have to prevent everyone from doing...
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species by tomjen3 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:00AM (#14575924)
Going to Mars is desirable, at least to some people. Genocide (and you need that to bring the population down, restricting births is not unless you are willing to wait about sixty years) is very much not.