Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species
by protonfish on Saturday June 17, 2017 @08:46AM
(#14575659)
Except we already see negative population growth in all countries with a reasonable standard of living. The USA (and many European countries) would not be growing were it not for immigration. Places with high birth rates are often correlated with a stressful environment like war and extreme poverty. (When you can't be certain how much time you have left to live or how many of your children will survive, it makes sense to have any many children as soon as possible.) Also, the efforts against access to birth control by organizations like the Catholic Church or Texas's "abstinence only education" can unnaturally increase birth rates.
Reducing population growth is the struggle to reduce poverty, war, and oppression against women. We also would need to confront powerful organizations with anti-birth control agendas.
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species
by lukas099 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:30AM
(#14576030)
Surely you mean negative change in population growth?
Re:Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species
by protonfish on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:55PM
(#14576631)
No, I don't. Negative population growth is when the population growth is less than one per person.
Eugenics is edgy and the idea deserves an edgy death.
I hate to give a glib dismissal, but what else is there to say on that topic? No one can do it short of becoming the next AI overlord empire. It's like wishing for anti-gravity. It'd be quite convenient, but how?
We've also seen how well China's "one child per family" mandate worked out, so we even have evidence that it doesn't seem to work.
I almost don't want to entertain the question due to the trainwreck of a thread that might ensue, but I've been pleasantly surprised by HN before. I think prompting can make the difference. So:
If we all promise to be very substantive, how might it be possible to implement "population control"?
This is probably the ultimate test of self-control, too. Can intellectualism prevail over the urge to strike down an idea? Let's find out.
You'll need to be very substantive in your response if you're to have any hope of thoughtful conversation, so please don't put in a halfhearted effort into the opportunity of your choosing. Everyone's listening -- what do you propose?