News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jacquesm on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:09AM (#14536134)
This is roughly along the lines of the vast majority of the people that would happily vote in a police state if it meant that they were safe.

Freedom is a good thing, even if it comes at the price of some risk, no matter what the context.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by coldtea on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:42AM (#14536236)
>This is roughly along the lines of the vast majority of the people that would happily vote in a police state if it meant that they were safe.

Or how about it's along the vast majority of the people merely wanting the police to guarantee safe cities?

You don't live in your mobile phone: you use it.

>Freedom is a good thing, even if it comes at the price of some risk, no matter what the context.

"No matter what the context" is BS. I presume you lock your house doors or wear a safety belt -- sacrificing freedom of movement for more security.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jacquesm on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:55AM (#14536275)
I don't see the Linux eco-system as being more prone to malware and trash than the so-called curated app-store.

> Or how about it's along the vast majority of the people merely wanting the police to guarantee safe cities?

Which more often than not includes being safe from the police, and that's where the problem lies. This sort of power is bound to be abused.

> "No matter what the context" is BS. I presume you lock your house doors or wear a safety belt -- sacrificing freedom of movement for more security.

Interesting. I've lived in places where unlocked doors were the norm, the village where I live (20 Km from Amsterdam) still has plenty of unlocked doors. People wear safety belts because there are no downsides and because they are required by law so that stretched analogy doesn't hold.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by delinka on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:02AM (#14536301)
"I don't see the Linux eco-system as being more prone to malware..."

Did you count Android amongst Linux? It is after all...

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by pjmlp on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:14AM (#14536629)
Only developers without Android experience think that.

Android is all about Java.

The NDK is there as layer for implementing Java native methods, games and high performance audio, and general purpose native libraries from other OSes.

This is what you are allowed to call from C and C++ on Android:

https://developer.android.com/ndk/reference/index.html

https://developer.android.com/ndk/guides/stable_apis.html

Trying to call anything else terminates the application as of Android 7.

https://developer.android.com/about/versions/nougat/android-...

As of the upcoming Android 8, calling syscalls outside of what libc requires leads to application termination as well.

https://developer.android.com/preview/behavior-changes.html#...

Basically nothing really UNIX specific and could be implemented with any other kind of kernel (hence Fuchsia).

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by delinka on Monday June 12, 2017 @11:36AM (#14538088)
"Only developers without Android experience think that."

Think what? That Linux is malware-free? If you're addressing me only, I'm just asking for clarity on the dataset in question, not expressing an opinion about the safety of the platform.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by pjmlp on Monday June 12, 2017 @12:04PM (#14538337)
No, that Android having Linux as kernel is actually relevant to Android programming.

Given the OS architecture Google can easily announce a version using other kernel, given that there is very little UNIX specific on what can be done with public NDK APIs.

Only those customising Android builds would be impacted.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by pjmlp on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @02:03AM (#14543094)
I meant to say irrelevant, edit does not work any longer.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jacquesm on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:05AM (#14536315)
That's disingenuous. The fact that the Linux kernel powers Android is totally besides the point.

The Android eco-system does everything it can to bury the fact that it uses Linux under the hood, and it is relegated to the role of a fancy HAL.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jimbokun on Monday June 12, 2017 @11:07AM (#14537898)
The main reason Android has more malware than other kinds of Linux is because Android is extremely popular. Malware writers just target the systems with the most users so they can have the biggest impact.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by sbuk on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @03:48AM (#14543411)
> I don't see the Linux eco-system as being more prone to malware and trash than the so-called curated app-store.

What was it people used to say about Apple and he perceived lack of viruses and malware issues? Security through obscurity.

> I've lived in places where unlocked doors were the norm, the village where I live (20 Km from Amsterdam) still has plenty of unlocked doors.

Arguably that experience is an edge-case, at best annecdata.

> People wear safety belts because there are no downsides and because they are required by law so that stretched analogy doesn't hold.

If they are required by law, does that not limit your freedom of choice? Does this not stretch your own limited analogy?

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by zyx321 on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:09AM (#14536605)
>I don't see the Linux eco-system as being more prone to malware and trash than the so-called curated app-store.

An estimate 99.99% of the Linux software I use is from a curated repository. Yes, I could just download src.tar.gz and ‘make install‘ but I prefer the safer more convenient alternative.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by pjmlp on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:15AM (#14536632)
Meanwhile curl | sh appears to be trendy.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jsjohnst on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:46AM (#14536850)
Not only curated, but likely curated with a bias more restrictive than Apple's own bias with the App Store.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by _jal on Monday June 12, 2017 @09:32AM (#14537216)
And yet, I can install stuff from anywhere on Linux.

It is the inability for mortals to install stuff from anywhere but the App store that causes the curation policy to be an issue.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jsjohnst on Friday June 23, 2017 @02:11PM (#14621348)
Every human can install any code they want on their iPhone for quite a while now.

Every human is mortal.

Thus unless you were implying non-human mortals, your point is stale and no longer valid.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by neonhomer on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:44AM (#14536834)
Somewhat off topic but I would consider seat belt laws to be part of the police state. Shouldn't it be my personal choice to wear it or not?
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by agentgt on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:55AM (#14536946)
It's debatable.

When you are in a collision with out a seat belt more often than not your body becomes a 100 pound plus projectile going at non trivial speed that could easily kill some one.

Consequently even libertarians might be for seat belt laws (unless of course you are on private roads).

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by schrodinger on Monday June 12, 2017 @09:19AM (#14537131)
I'm not sure of the accuracy, but I've also heard it argued that you're much more likely to regain control of a vehicle after an evasive maneuver, since you will stay in your seat.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by sbuk on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @03:50AM (#14543419)
It's not. A federal/state law is a law. You are compelled to do something that may be against your wishes. Whether or not it is a good thing is neither here nor there! To spin the debate, apply the same for drug laws, or substance control.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by futurix on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:30AM (#14536195)
There is a huge difference between police state and letting dodgy products on some store's 'shelves'. Do you support Amazon allowing sellers of counterfeit goods on Amazon Marketplace?

Besides the walled garden of Apple is not so walled - you can install any app you want on your iDevice, as long as you have access to Xcode (which is free). It is the access to the marketing and reach of App Store that Apple denies.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jacquesm on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:59AM (#14536286)
> There is a huge difference between police state and letting dodgy products on some store's 'shelves'.

Yes, but the point was that people do not always realize the consequences of their choices, not that there were no differences.

> Do you support Amazon allowing sellers of counterfeit goods on Amazon Marketplace?

I don't support the Amazon 'marketplace' at all, Amazon should take full responsibility for anything sold through Amazon.com and if they allow counterfeit merchandise on their store that should be their problem, not the problem of their end users. And there is plenty of counterfeit merchandise on Amazon so I do not get what the point is, unless you wanted to make the point that in spite of being curated Amazon fails horribly at keeping their store in good shape.

> Besides the walled garden of Apple is not so walled - you can install any app you want on your iDevice, as long as you have access to Xcode (which is free).

That's fine, but for your regular end-user this has been made so difficult that it is something only developers will use.

> It is the access to the marketing and reach of App Store that Apple denies.

No, it goes much further than that. To all intents and purposes if your app is not in the app store then it doesn't exist because iDevices users think that that is the only way apps can go on their devices.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by futurix on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:36AM (#14536775)
You are looking at my point and refusing to see it, and then go on to make the same point yourself.

You want Amazon to take full responsibility for their merchandise, but yet okay with Apple not doing the same thing.

Amazon has to take the same responsibility with goods, as Apple has with apps.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jacquesm on Monday June 12, 2017 @12:02PM (#14538329)
I have 100's if not many thousands of options to buy from when it comes to Amazon, but yes, Amazon is ultimately responsible for what they sell and - surprise - we have laws against counterfeit merchandise sold as if it were the original brand. So yes, Amazon has some duty here.

Apple does not have the same kind of duties when it comes to apps in the Apple app-store, they have created a de-facto monopoly on the channel between the people programming applications for ios and their customers.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by futurix on Monday June 12, 2017 @01:49PM (#14539269)
Apple's duties might be partially self imposed, but that's part of their value proposition. I don't want to sift through reviews to find out whether the app is safe to use, like my friends with Android phones have to do.

And comparisons with police states or monopolies are just ludicrous. With police state you have no choice, but with app ecosystems you are free to choose another (yes, with a different phone - but you don't buy a $700 phone by mistake or chance). And Apple is not a monopoly, there are plenty of other viable options.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by doktrin on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:35AM (#14536218)
> This is roughly along the lines of the vast majority of the people that would happily vote in a police state

This kind of hyperbole isn't helpful. The differences between voting in a police state and using a walled garden app ecosystem run by a private company should be obvious.

> Freedom is a good thing, even if it comes at the price of some risk, no matter what the context.

What about the freedom to choose an application platform?

Since I'm sure I need to make this disclaimer, I don't own any Apple (or Windows) devices aside from my work-issued macbook.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jacquesm on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:03AM (#14536306)
> This kind of hyperbole isn't helpful.

It is helpful in the sense that it points out that people will often do things that have far reaching consequences out of their free will because they do not realize the long term effects.

> The differences between voting in a police state and using a walled garden app ecosystem run by a private company should be obvious.

Yes, but in the one case people vote with their ballots, in the other the vote with their dollars. In both cases the long term effects are negatives but since those effects are still safely over the horizon we can pretend that they don't exist. By the time those effects are felt it is too late to change course.

> What about the freedom to choose an application platform?

That would be fine with me, but only if the hardware were 'open' enough by default that third party application platforms would have a chance of making it to single digit percentage penetration.

> Since I'm sure I need to make this disclaimer, I don't own any Apple (or Windows) devices aside from my work-issued macbook.

I don't care what you use or why, what matters to me is that there is - at least in the mobile space - the choice between Google on the one side and Apple on the other and that both of those have substantial shortcomings when it comes to the freedoms they afford their users.

With Google you'll be tracked from here to kingdom come and with Apple you're going to be handed a smart terminal. Neither of those choices appeals to me.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by matthewmacleod on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:13AM (#14536622)
Freedom is a good thing, even if it comes at the price of some risk, no matter what the context.

That's a shallow quote, though. You're right, on the face of it – freedom is a good thing. But we accept compromises on absolute, unbridled freedom all the time, in order to trade of some other desirable outcome.

I would be concerned if computers generally were locked-down. But they aren't – competitors to iPhones are freely available, and desktop & laptop computers are ubiquitous. I will continue to oppose restraints on what can be done with them, but the freedom to choose a curated garden is also a freedom that should be respected.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by rz2k on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:03AM (#14536575)
Apple is also removing the freedom developers had to give users the options of track location even when in the background or never track location, but not the option to only track while using the app. They're also restricting the freedom developers had to ask for reviews.

One could argue that no one was forced to install those apps that always tracked them, or that they could manually switch between the options. However the small minority of people who care about the privacy of their location will now have a lot more apps available to them with less hassle, because Apple is deciding to enforce a rule.

I don't think these new guidelines about executable code in education apps will be a problem, but I can imagine dropping the restriction altogether allowing developers to take advantage of users who aren't vigilant, or simply making people have to be much more suspicious about everything they allow on their phone.

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by herghost on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:41AM (#14536233)
I used to advocate a similar philosophy to you on this. Now, I'm in a bit of a transition phase, although I'm not sure exactly where I'm transitioning to.

This article [0] has made points that I'm not certain I completely agree with, but has done enough for me to suggest that my original position might need updating.

The point being, essentially, that at some point we might need to consider the trade off of who we're actually afraid of and where we can get the best protection as part of a trade-off, since things like "freedom", "risk", "security", and "privacy" aren't absolutes in any meaningful way.

[0] http://www.newstatesman.com/2015/11/coming-anarchy-john-gray...

Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by nihonde on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:13AM (#14536623)
Freedom is a trade off, like everything else. For example, more freedom means more responsibility. Also, if everyone is perfectly free, then we're all forced to accommodate the least worthy among us. It's all trade offs all the way down.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by mattkevan on Monday June 12, 2017 @12:18PM (#14538447)
It's like playing a game. There's more actual freedom when people follow a defined set of guidelines than there would be if anyone could do whatever they liked.
Re:Apple’s Guidelines Now Allow Executable Code in Education... by jimbokun on Monday June 12, 2017 @11:05AM (#14537878)
I see there are similarities, but there are probably also a lot of people fine with using an App Store that are also big advocates of Freedom of Speech, Press, Privacy, etc. when it comes to the government.