News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by clairity on Friday June 09, 2017 @01:11AM (#14519300)
> Fact is that Boston Dynamics does one thing, really, really well engineered dynamic locomotion. From what I understand there's very little ML/AI to it, just really good modeling and engineering.

as someone who did a bit of graduate research in that area, i would debate the "really, really well engineered" part of that statement. they brute-forced the engineering and developed energetically expensive machines that were great as demos but not practical as products. compare how long one of their robots last vs any legged creature of comparable size, and the poor energetics are obvious.

i would speculate that their company was a bet that battery packs would become light enough yet have a high enough energy density that it's robots could one day become viable products, but it doesn't seem like they're winning that bet.

that's in contrast to the segway, which was a bet that computing power was fast enough to dynamically adjust and balance human scale motion with high dynamic stability. they won the technical bet, but still lost the productization bet.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by varjag on Friday June 09, 2017 @04:29AM (#14520009)
The energetics of the robots are constrained by size, weight and power requirements of the components on the market. As such sure, mechanical walkers will always be much less energy efficient than wheeled vehicles of the same era. Their competition on the rough terrain however is not Segway but flying drones, which are much less energy efficient than walkers still.

There isn't any particular inefficiency in their walker balancing implementation.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by clairity on Friday June 09, 2017 @03:11PM (#14523646)
but that's just it. the design presupposes an industrial mindset of motors and gears and pistons and rigid metal structures. it presupposes active control and computational power. it presupposes an unlimited energy supply, as would be found in a manufacturing plant.

but if we just look around, we find a huge array of locomoting, self-contained, relatively energy efficient beings to draw inspiration from.

for example, the tendons and muscles in your leg can return as much as 40% of the energy expended in locomoting. and your legs include passive mechanisms (like how your knee joint locks and the alignment of the cruciate ligaments inside it) to keep you mostly upright without a lot of active control.

nature has ingenious solutions to learn from and take advantage of.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by taneq on Friday June 09, 2017 @02:52AM (#14519609)
Can you suggest another company that produces legged platforms with similar capabilities and better energy efficiency?
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by rubidium on Friday June 09, 2017 @10:27AM (#14521587)
Any mule or horse rental company.

http://www.sombrero.com/trips/hunting/

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by seanp2k2 on Friday June 09, 2017 @04:08AM (#14519917)
I still don't understand the commercial value / applications of legged platforms to begin with. What are people using these for outside of hobbies, wooing government reps with deep pockets, and novelty?
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by michaelt on Friday June 09, 2017 @06:02AM (#14520330)
Humanoid robots can fit into existing environments without extensive adaption. And humans have legs.

Irrelevant in a factory, where you can adapt things as much as you like - but crucial if you envisage people sending robots to environments they don't own - like a robot carer helping Grandma go to the store.

Needless to say, the profitable applications for this aren't especially short-term, so the ROI for this research is hard to predict.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by dwighttk on Friday June 09, 2017 @09:16AM (#14521110)
The store Grandma is going to is probably already wheelchair accessible, so a wheeled robot would work fine.
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by michaelt on Friday June 09, 2017 @09:37AM (#14521237)
I'm sure that's the case where you live, but where I live our public transport isn't 100% disabled-accessible.

If you prefer, you can substitute "Like a robot delivery driver, who must deliver to flats without lifts" or "Like a robot cop, chasing truant teens through a mall" [1]

[1] http://pbfcomics.com/comics/truancy-bot/

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by seanp2k2 on Friday June 09, 2017 @12:31PM (#14522484)
Fwiw we already have mall cop robots in California: https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/26/15432280/security-robot-k...

They cost about $7/hr each to employ (~$62k annually since they're 24.7): https://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/knightscope-robots-i...

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by dwighttk on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:47PM (#14539860)
heh... it was springbreak
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by stevenwoo on Friday June 09, 2017 @04:23AM (#14519989)
They briefly convinced the Army/Marines that they could make electric/hydraulic mules to assist soldiers in carrying their gear in terrain without roads. But they were too loud - at that point, might as well insert troops/material by helicopter or use horses/mules. http://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/military-robots/...
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by taneq on Friday June 09, 2017 @05:28AM (#14520212)
Seems like a classic case of poorly chosen requirements. Someone specced a robotic mule with such-and-such range, carrying capacity and features, and forgot to add 'also must be quieter than weed whacker'.
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by daveguy on Friday June 09, 2017 @08:08AM (#14520804)
Stairs? Or any other rough terrain where wheels are insufficient.

A robotics mentor once told me "just use bigger wheels" for rough terrain rather than legs and fancy control algorithms. But stairs are particularly difficult for wheels. House bots will almost certainly need legs to maximize utility. Unless they are so cheap you can get one for every surface.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by greg7mdp on Friday June 09, 2017 @09:40AM (#14521256)
> wheels are insufficient

Tell that to these guys: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1apqfrJYwk. I think one day we have have two wheeled robots with these kind of capability.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by daveguy on Friday June 09, 2017 @03:30PM (#14523787)
That is badass. And energy intensive. I do think we will have legged/wheel hybrids rolling for efficiency and walking/hopping/etc for the difficult parts. He was certainly using his legs to perform those maneuvers. Wheels only can't bounce up. Wheelies, but not the hopping part. Wheelies + AWD may do it though. Good perspective. Thank you.
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by namlem on Sunday June 11, 2017 @02:18AM (#14530911)
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by jacquesm on Friday June 09, 2017 @06:43AM (#14520465)
It's hard to change the stance on a wheeled vehicle, I think that agriculture might be one domain where a legged platform could develop an advantage (if it were sufficiently energy efficient to begin with, wheels really are the greatest human invention).
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by jononor on Friday June 09, 2017 @07:58AM (#14520765)
Legged for agriculture, to handle uneven terrain? Outside of reforestation, I don't see how it can be a significant advantage? In soil-based growing, one needs to maintain the soil/ground and making/keeping it flat becomes a relatively minor point. For soil-less (hydroponics etc), I'd expect the whole 'field' to be automated, possibly with the produce moving instead of moving to the produce. This how modern salad farming happens for instance.
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by jacquesm on Friday June 09, 2017 @08:06AM (#14520798)
> Legged for agriculture, to handle uneven terrain?

That's one, and also a much smaller footprint than a wheeled vehicle.

> This how modern salad farming happens for instance.

And mushrooms too.

Mushrooms too.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by hitekker on Friday June 09, 2017 @12:42PM (#14522549)
One thing I keep in mind is that handwaving, overly dismissive criticisms tend to stem from the need to feel superior rather than actual shortcomings of the product.
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by TeMPOraL on Friday June 09, 2017 @03:56AM (#14519865)
Maybe there's still merit to BD's approach. The rule is: first make it work, then make it good, then make it fast (i.e. optimize). It's probably easier to find plenty of ways to incrementally improve on a working platform than to dream up those improvements completely from scratch.
Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by sharemywin on Friday June 09, 2017 @10:31AM (#14521621)
To me though a better approach would be:

1. wheeled sidewalk robots. 2. wheeled robot with arms 3. walking robot.

Still incremental just have sellable robots the whole time.

Re:SoftBank Agrees to Buy Boston Dynamics From Alphabet by namlem on Sunday June 11, 2017 @02:16AM (#14530910)
Their newest robot, the one with wheels for feet, is quite efficient. You need legs to traverse complex terrain. Adding wheels for efficiency after you've developed decent legs just makes sense.