News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by electricEmu on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:20PM (#14493208)
While I understand the sentiment, how many people are estimated to be displaced? It's possible the local governments could work with very small amounts instead of coding another loophole into another law.

Nuke Proposition 13, one-time grandfather some uses, and drop the remaining pain all at once.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by dv_dt on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:30PM (#14493285)
In general principle, I want to favor owners living in their property. That creates social stability, instead of upheavals of neighborhood on every bubble. Without prop 13, the stronger the bubble, the more people with deep pockets are favored because they can hold out longer on property taxes. You'll just end up kicking people out of their homes sorted from poorest to richest as the bubble intensifies.

Without prop 13, you may end up exacerbating bubbles - the system ends up favoring risky behavior: the uptake of buyers willing to take out the larger loans, or people taking out taking out loans to pay their taxes and try and ride out real estate bubbles. When the bubble bursts, there will be more people with more highly leveraged loans.

Cities working on random rules to help subsets of property owners is, by definition, coding loopholes. By comparison, a primary residence of a homeowner isn't a loophole, that's a basic tax status used by the IRS.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by aianus on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:13PM (#14493595)
> You'll just end up kicking people out of their homes sorted from poorest to richest as the bubble intensifies.

No, it's the richest people with the smallest cash flow that get kicked out first.

Property tax for a salaried worker with a $1m mortgaged house is totally manageable, property tax for a retiree with a $2m paid-off house could be unaffordable. The latter person (who's much richer) has to move, the former doesn't.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by dv_dt on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:26PM (#14493673)
I think you're splitting silly hairs - technically its anyone with bad cash flow. If someone has no liquid assets and their "wealth" is only tied in the property they're living in, it's monopoly bubble money, and you're kicking them out because they're fixed income doesn't match the real estate market values (which may be unrealistic in a bubble). If you're truly wealthy, and want to preserve the property, then you'll have many options to transition even fairly illiquid assets to keep a property.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by aianus on Monday June 05, 2017 @08:31PM (#14493709)
I don't agree it's hair-splitting. You can't get kicked out by surprise by repealing Prop 13 unless you've enjoyed huge capital gains and are therefore likely rich. It would make no difference for poor people who don't own property that was acquired at low cost many years ago.

It's really the opposite situation of what you said.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by tehlike on Monday June 05, 2017 @09:19PM (#14493956)
At the rates real estate prices are rising in bay area, you would be kicking people out of where they called home for years. Whether they sit on huge gains or not is irrelevant, they wouldnt be able to afford it.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by dv_dt on Monday June 05, 2017 @09:35PM (#14494034)
That capital gain isn't accessible unless there is a sale. If its a sale because the owner can't afford the property tax it is likely someone with limited/fixed income.

Once you force a sale, a buyer, rich enough to buy the home takes ownership, they have exactly the same incentive to approve or disapprove new homes as the original owner.

The person you've forced out on the other hand, now pays the tax, the transfer costs with a real estate agent and likely repair costs on the home, has the same fixed income, and now has to find a home to live in, but now has 5-10% less capital to work with then they had before. It's a bubble, and likely real estate costs in the near area are just as high. So what has been accomplished at the end of this other than harming the living situation of the original property owner and kicking out someone of limited income for someone with more income?

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by aianus on Monday June 05, 2017 @10:06PM (#14494140)
What's accomplished is that productive workers can live close to work instead of the double whammy of having a long commute and paying extra to subsidize rich people that don't work.

The fact that some people have been there longer than others shouldn't absolve them of their duty to pay their fair share of taxes based on the value of their property.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by JamesBarney on Monday June 05, 2017 @11:43PM (#14494583)
The seller will maybe pay 7-8% in terms of transaction costs. Lets assume a 30% increase in a house payments is enough to kick someone out. The costs of a typical house costs 6%(mortgage + taxes + insurance + repairs). That's means you need $1,000 a month for a 200k house.(Seems reasonable). Avg. California property taxes are 1.25%. So for that to increase your total payments by 30% you would need your house' value to increase $288,000 before it knocked you out of house and home. Of course with the 8% in transactions costs you leave with a modest $260k in profit.

I might be heartless but it's hard for me to feel too much sympathy for this individual.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by dv_dt on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @12:44AM (#14494792)
260k in profit which needs to be rolled into a place to live in the same market that just kicked you out of your home...
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by xyzzyz on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @02:02AM (#14495106)
Not the same market -- in some saner market somewhere else. That's the whole point of the exercise.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by pyrale on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @05:42AM (#14495951)
So the goal is to make the poor go away, in a place that will have less economic opportunities ?
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by xyzzyz on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @10:38AM (#14497530)
No, the goal is to make rich go away, and make poor have a place to live where they have more economic opportunities. If you cannot afford to pay $1k/month property tax, it means that you have an asset worth around $1M, so by no means you are poor.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by pyrale on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @01:16PM (#14498978)
If you cannot pay $1k a month in taxes, you probably cannot rent the place, either. The taxes driving the owners away will drive the renters away, too.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by xyzzyz on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @03:23PM (#14500344)
Sell the asset then, simple as that.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by JamesBarney on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @09:51AM (#14497191)
I don't consider anyone with 300k in net worth poor. And the goal is to not subsidize these individuals who have just had a massive windfall, which screws up the rental market leaving the truly poor(renters) SoL.
Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by pyrale on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @05:33AM (#14495913)
Are you asserting that the tax won't be passed down to renters ?

It is indeed a sort by cash flow, but whether you own the place or not won't impact the decision.

Re:L.A.'s crisis: High rents, low pay, and $2k doesn't buy much by georgeecollins on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @08:49PM (#14511061)
All you have to do is convince property owners that it is OK to pass a law that will probably lower the value of their property and raise their taxes. Or, figure out how to pass a bill that is opposed by property owners, by getting the support of the powerful California lobby that doesn't own property. Wait.. what is that lobby?